Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 September 2012

Google must get ruthless in attacking Apple, and even its own partners

Significance: The phase in Android’s life when its open source nature allowed it to gather its own momentum and unite a whole range of vendors around its platform is over. OEMs which saw an open platform, largely resourced by Google, as a quick and low cost route into the smartphone market have now reached that position, and need differentiation and greater control to continue to gain share. They are now fighting one another as much as Apple, RIM and Nokia, and that makes them less willing to play nice, and share revenue, with Google. As they introduce their own user interfaces and applications to Android, or even look to other OSs altogether, Google needs to compete in its own right ‘ by making its services too attractive to ignore, and by showcasing them in an optimized way on its own hardware. That means exploiting Apple’s vulnerabilities more ruthlessly than it has done before ‘ and those weaknesses do exist, as seen in the fiasco of the iOS Maps service. But it also means accepting that Android is no longer a big happy family with Google at the head of the table, but a jungle in which it will have to fight its corner even while it continues to invest the most in the platform. As always for Google, the country where it will have to fight hardest to preserve its own leadership is in China, where hardware and software players threaten to eclipse Android in the world’s largest market.

The launch of a new iPhone is always a good moment for the Android community, and especially Google, to take stock. Apple’s year-long upgrade cycle inevitably gives rivals their day in the sun, so the middle portion of 2012 has been ‘ outside the law courts at least ‘ a time when Android consolidated its lead and its key vendors, mainly Samsung, shone in the league tables. But those months were more about Samsung than Google, and that needs to worry the platform’s controlling force.

The Korean giant is an increasingly powerful challenger to Apple, and one more iPhone generation may see the Galaxy S win out even in the holiday season, not just when its rival is in a ‘quiet period’. That will be a mixed blessing for Google. As long as Samsung stays true to Android, it can only be good news for the OS to support the world’s number one smartphone vendor, rather than relying on the collective sales of several partners to outdo iOS. However, the Korean firm will demand concessions in return for delivering a lead share of the high end device segment to Google ‘ and if it does not get them, it can always share its favors around, as it is already doing to some extent with its renewed interest in Windows Phone. Even in Android, the more that Samsung dominates the platform, at the expense of HTC, Sony and Google’s own Motorola Mobility, the more difficult it will be for Google to keep the level of control it requires and to ensure a harmonized platform.

Google is torn between three Android aims which are no longer compatible ‘ to create a single platform for developers and users; to offer OEMs a way to steal share from Apple and Microsoft; and to build up its own brand, via Android-based applications and the Nexus and Motorola hardware activities. As Android vendors start to steal share from one another as much as from non-Android players they will increasingly look to differentiate their user experiences, which will loosen Google’s grip on the platform, even before we consider newcomers like Amazon, with its near-forked implementation of the OS. Without a harmonized experience, Google’s appeal to developers weakens, as does its negotiating power with carriers, which will play one supplier off against another and often feel able to oust Google apps from their Android homescreens. The likes of Samsung and Huawei are no longer smartphone newbies grateful for a readymade platform, they are companies as powerful in mobile as Google.

Google has to make some tough decisions and get off the fence between an open, free-for-all approach and pushing its own brand. Whether it likes it or not, key partners will only stick with Android and be willing to cooperate with Google if they have freedom of action. Many will still choose to showcase the firm’s user interfaces and apps, but increasingly the search giant will have to stop relying on Android to deliver it a free pass onto OEMs’ or operators’ devices, and sell its web services in their own right, as it has done in the past.

It is likely to end up with a similar approach to Amazon ‘ providing web services on all platforms which are hard to ignore because of their appeal to the mass consumer market; but delivering the optimized experience for those services on its own devices. That will be the job of the Nexus range, as well as its traditional role of spurring developer interest and innovation around the latest updates to Android. Both Google and Amazon will emulate Apple in creating an integrated device/software experience, but cannot afford to keep their applications away from the broader market too.

Google will have to learn the hard lesson it helped to deliver to Microsoft ‘ that in the mobile world, the wide range of devices, usage patterns and applications will ensure that one platform cannot suit all. It will be a fragmented world, in terms of operating systems, search engines and content platforms, because it is so much broader and more varied than the PC base ever was. Even HTML5, which was supposed to provide a web-based layer rendering OS differences irrelevant, is already fragmenting just as the previous great white hope for multivendor harmony, mobile Java, did.

So how can Google ensure it retains significant profile in Android now that it cannot browbeat the main OEMs into following its rules? One answer is obvious, and clearly seen in the fiasco of Apple’s first homegrown maps service, which has attracted high levels of ridicule for its gaps and flaws. The weakness of the offering, especially from a firm which rarely delivers half-baked goods, highlights just how difficult it is to build a really good location-based platform. Apple will get there, but in the meantime, iOS users are begging Google to launch a native app for them, so they can return to the familiar service that was previously the iPhone default.

Building strong, reliable, usable applications in difficult, resource-hungry areas is what Google does well ‘ far better than the big handset makers, which will find, the further they drift from vanilla Android, the more they will struggle to deliver a really good software and content platform.

Keeping these players reliant on its search, browser, maps and advertising engines is one thing, but Google can also go a step further and tie important OEMs to it via Nexus, where it seeks to showcase those mobile engines at their very best. We have always been sceptical of the Nexus strategy and its potential to force Google to compete with its own partners, but there is an element of logic in having devices over which the search giant can exert full control – as long as it does not make the fatal error of entrusting the range entirely to Motorola in future. Not only because it would alienate other handset makers still further, but also because Motorola has shown no proof that it is up to the task ‘ Nexus will only succeed in making the industry fall in love with the Google user experience if its products are powerfully designed and executed. The latest RAZRs are nice smartphones, but not good enough.

Nexus has no hope of delivering to Google the kind of successes Apple has had with its integrated strategy, but it indicates the increasing challenges of a model that relies on getting one’s services adopted ubiquitously. Major players want differentiated offerings, and they do not want to share the resulting revenues, nor the power, with Google. Even Apple, with its tightly controlled platform, used to be happy to default to Google maps and search, but it has now exiled the former from iOS 6 and, in Russia and China at least, is working with alternative default search engines too. In such a climate, Google needs to work hard on making its own platform not just adoptable but excellent.

The other important lesson for Google from the Maps experience is that Apple has weaknesses. Despite the runaway success of iPhone 5, it is on the defensive to a greater extent than ever before because of the rise of Samsung and the increasing saturation of the base of iPhone lovers. The wider choice of top devices and the size of its existing base would both have been factors in the ‘disappointing’ first weekend sales of the iPhone 5, though shortages of components such as the new touchscreens may have been more significant.

Of course, 5m sales in three days would not normally be a disappointment for anyone, but over-enthusiastic Wall Street analysts had hoped for 6m, 7m or even 10m units (see inset), and for a huge leap on last year’s iPhone 4S launch (normalized for the number of countries, the performance was much the same). Apple is a victim here of over-inflated expectations, but the ‘failure’ to deliver a stunning result last weekend, followed by the outcry over the sub-standard new maps feature, highlights that there are vulnerabilities in the iOS camp now. Google’s job is to exploit them far more aggressively than it has in the past, now that its revenue stream from iPhone apps ‘ historically higher than proceeds from Android itself ‘ looks set to be squeezed.

That will mean being braver about taking Apple on directly, whether that is by launching patent battles directly, rather than through OEMs, or by turning developers against its rivals controlling tactics. The maps saga offered an opportunity to do this, but one which Google appears to be ducking. Executive chairman Eric Schmidt said this week that his firm would not submit a native Maps app to the iOS App Store, a move which would be popular with iPhone users but could spark a new level of confrontation with Apple.

Google Maps is still accessible via the web, but the search giant was also widely reported to be preparing an updated iOS app, which would provide all the features of the Android version, and perhaps even more. However, it would force Apple to make a critical decision ‘ whether to block such an app from its storefront, as it has sometimes done with products that compete with core functionality in iOS. That would provoke a major showdown with Google, and possibly antitrust complaints, as well as stimulating developer and user anger at Apple limiting their choices. It seems that Google itself is keen to avoid such a situation, which smacks of cowardice at a potential turning point in the Android/iOS war. Schmidt told reports that the two firms were in constant communication “at all kinds of levels,’ but that any decision on a possible return of Google Maps to iOS – or approval of a native app ‘ would be in Apple’s hands. ‘We have not done anything yet,” he said. ‘We think it would have been better if they had kept ours. But what do I know? What were we going to do, force them not to change their mind? It’s their call.”

If Google has let Apple off the hook this time around, it is even more indecisive about how to handle the biggest threat to its Android leadership, China. The company has limited influence in the country ‘ now the world’s largest smartphone market ‘ after a string of political disputes which led to it withdrawing key services and ceding the search space to Baidu. Now, many of the challenges to Google’s own version of Android are coming from China, including rival browser-based operating systems, from Baidu itself and from Alibaba; and independently minded Android OEMs. Both Huawei and ZTE are becoming significant smartphone forces, partly because of the huge growth in their own country, and both have recently decided to support back-up alternatives to Android.

Google reacted strongly when Acer, its partner for Nexus tablets, decided to launch a smartphone for the Chinese market running Alibaba’s Aliyun cloud-oriented OS (which Google claims is an unsupported fork of Android, something the online retailer denies). Forcing Acer to cancel its launch was an aggressive gesture, but no more than a finger in the dyke when it comes to the rising influence of Chinese players over the new mobile experience.

Alibaba, for instance, notwithstanding Google’s hostility, plans to spin Aliyun into a separate company and invest $200m in the project to build a significant OEM and developer base. According to Reuters, its CEO Jack Ma has decided to make a serious play for the Chinese mobile web experience, and then potentially take Aliyun abroad too.

China may be the largest smartphone base, but it is also an immature one, and the user experience is more fragmented and fluid than in many other economies. This means there are opportunities for new mobile players to bid for Google-style influence over the platform and Alibaba clearly thinks the time is right to invest in gaining a firm foothold ‘ and perhaps, in future, influencing other vast markets where the mobile user experience remains immature, such as India and Indonesia. The autonomous unit will be headed by Jonathan Lu, Alibaba’s chief data officer, whose tasks will include ‘meeting with hardware vendors to secure business for the Aliyun OS’. So far, apart from Acer, it is supported by local OEMs Haier and Tianyu (K-Touch), and passed one million shipments between July 2011 and May 2012.

Baidu is taking a similar line, while other Android challengers will use the power of the Chinese OEMs to ride in from outside, including Mozilla’s Firefox Mobile, which has scored a deal with ZTE. The leading Chinese handset maker plans to launch Mozilla devices alongside Android ones next year, and also to step up support for Windows Phone. Similarly, Huawei has confirmed earlier reports that it is building its own mobile operating system, in order to hedge its bet on Android. CEO Wan Biao told Reuters that the firm will also continue to support Windows Phone 8, saying: “Whatever consumers like, we’ll develop.”

However, the homegrown OS project is not just to offer customers another option, but to act as a back-up plan should it be sidelined in the Android community. OEMs are concerned about legal challenges to Android ‘ though this is likely to be less worrying to Huawei, with the might of the Chinese IPR system behind it ‘ and that Google will show favouritism to its own handset unit, Motorola Mobility. So far, Huawei has been firmly in the outer ring of Google partners, while closer ties ‘ and in the case of the Honeycomb OS release, early access ‘ has gone to Motorola, HTC and latterly Samsung and Acer.

This will be increasingly unacceptable as Huawei starts to build a significant business in smartphones, expanding from its roots in featurephones and white label devices. Wan said in the interview: “We’re also devoting resources into coming up with a phone operating system based on our current platform in case other companies won’t let us use their system one day.”

Motorola wins and loses in German patent courts:

At last, Samsung won a parents court victory against Apple after a series of high profile defeats in the US. This one came in the Mannheim Regional Court in Germany, which ruled that the Korean firm does not violate and Apple patent related to touchscreen function.

The ruling did not stop at Samsung. Motorola had also been cited in the same lawsuit and was also found not have infringed the touchscreen technology. It follows similar decisions in the UK and the Netherlands, though Apple has 30 days to appeal.

Also in Germany, Motorola was less fortunate in a case being fought with Microsoft. While the Windows giant has succeeded in obtaining licensing deals from most major Android vendors for its Linux-related patents, Motorola Mobility has been a hold-out. But a Munich regional court has ruled that Motorola is infringing on IPR related to text input, in a case which could leave to injunctions against certain products, plus damages, if the expected appeal is unsuccessful.

The Munich verdict is a victory in a series of cases against Motorola in Germany. Previously Microsoft has won injunctions against Motorola in the US and Germany for violating patents related to the FAT file system, SMS messaging and ActiveSync.

“We’re pleased this decision builds on previous rulings in Germany that have already found Motorola is broadly infringing Microsoft’s intellectual property. We will continue to enforce injunctions against Motorola products in Germany and hope Motorola will join other Android device makers by taking a licence to Microsoft’s patented inventions,” Microsoft said in a statement.

Of course, the stakes have risen in any cases involving Motorola because of its new ownership by Google, the real arch-enemy of Apple and Microsoft. “With its phones and tablets now subject to injunctions in the US and Germany, Google can no longer doubt the relevance of Microsoft’s patent portfolio to Motorola’s products,” said Microsoft counsels Brad Smith and Horacio Gutierrez pointedly.

Meanwhile, Apple is seeking to increase the damages it can claim after its victory against Samsung in federal court in Silicon Valley last month. It has already filed additional lawsuits extending its attack to newer Samsung devices including the Galaxy S III, and now it has filed a motion asking for a further $400m in damages on top of the $1.05bn already awarded (though subject to appeal). It is also claiming $135m for willful infringement of its utility patents; $121m in supplemental damages based on Samsung’s product sales not covered in the jury’s deliberation; and $50m of pre-judgment interest on damages until December 31. The requests together come to $707 million.

In return, Samsung is alleging juror misconduct in new court filings asking the trial judge, Lucy Koh, to throw out the billion dollar verdict. It claims that interviews given by jurors to some news organizations are evidence of misconduct serious enough to have influenced the verdict, and should trigger a retrial.

As iPhone sales mount up and Apple continues to be aggressive about litigation, legal challenges against its own IPR are coming from all sides. The latest comes from the Swiss state railway operator SBB, which claims iOS 6 infringes, of all things, a trademarked design for rail station clocks. The Swiss are, of course, as famous for clocks as Apple is for touchcreen phones, and allegedly the latest iPad operating system includes a clock icon with black and red hands, a design created in 1944, and used by companies like Mondaine Watch under licence.

‘The money isn’t in the front of our interests because we are proud that Apple took an SBB design,’ a Swiss Railways spokesperson said. ‘If we have a cooperation agreement between two good brands, that’s a win-win.’

Apple manages to disappoint Wall Street with 5m iPhones:

The iPhone 5 sold over 5m units in its first weekend, but still managed to disappoint Wall Street, reflecting the hugely high expectations that are often set for Apple these days. This tendency for analysts to dream the impossible for the company will bite it in the next year or two as the competition to iOS devices becomes increasingly effective, but for now, pundits refuse to dampen their enthusiasm ‘ despite a lukewarm reaction to the weekend figures, some are already predicting a haul of 50m units for the fourth quarter.

Apple shares fell by almost 1%, or $6.60, on the release of the sales figures, though they were still at a dizzy $693.49 in morning trading, having crossed the $700 barrier on Friday, the day the iPhone 5 went on sale in nine countries including the US, Germany, France and Japan. The 5m total was a record for any handset, but only marginally outdid the iPhone 4S launch. Brian White, an analyst at Topeka Capital Markets, told Bloomberg he mainly blamed supply shortages for the failure to meet his projection of 6m to 6.5m units in the initial three days.

Some watchers had had even more inflated expectations. Piper Jaffray’s Gene Munster had thought Apple might even do 10m units in the first weekend. He wrote in a recent client note: ‘We believe that the reported 2m iPhone 5 pre-order unit number suggests that Apple could sell 6-10m phones in the launch weekend. The midpoint of our weekend sales total would suggest 100% y/y growth from the iPhone 4S launch. We note that iPhone 4S grew 135% y/y in its launch weekend compared to the iPhone 4.’

According to Horace Dediu of Asymco, the iPhone 5’s opening weekend is roughly the same as that of the 4S, which sold 4m units, when normalized for number of countries. This is hardly a poor performance, given that the iPhone now has more impactful rivals than ever before, including the Samsung Galaxy family. The most negative view is that the firm is losing its magic, but the reality is that, given the major expansion of the base which Apple chased by broadening distribution for the 4S, there will inevitably be a declining number of incremental users going forward, even without the added factors of supply constraints and economic downturn.

In a statement, CEO Tim Cook said demand had outstripped supply and many pre-orders will slip to October, missing the current quarter. He said: ‘While we have sold out of our initial supply, stores continue to receive iPhone 5 shipments regularly and customers can continue to order online and receive an estimated delivery date. We appreciate everyone’s patience and are working hard to build enough iPhone 5s for everyone.’

The main supply constraint is likely to be on the redesigned touchscreen, which uses in-cell technology to combine the display and the touch sensor into a single part, for a slimmer device. The suppliers are LG Display, Japan Display and Sharp. But according to analysts at Barclays, Sharp was struggling to reduce defects in the new screens and was unable to start shipments before the iPhone debut ‘ a problem that also afflicted it when the iPad HD first went on sale. Meeting Apple’s demand was tough for the remaining two suppliers, said Barclays’ Ben Reitzes. ‘Apple is facing significant production constraints due to a move toward in-cell display technology,’ he wrote in a research note. ‘Apple is struggling to keep up with demand.’ He thinks about 10m units of in-cell panels will be available in the calendar third quarter.

There is also the possibility that Qualcomm’s much publicized difficulties in securing volume of its latest LTE chips may have affected the iPhone 5, because of yield challenges at its main foundry, TSMC, during the move to a new process.

The phone will go on sale in 22 more countries on Friday and in more than 100 countries by the end of the year. That kind of distribution, in contrast to the limited release of earlier iPhones, is leading Apple bulls to predict sales of 50m iPhone 5s in the holiday quarter.

Samsung reported to be readying first Tizen phone:

This fall is seeing several big Android vendors launcbing high profile devices running ‘back-up’ operating systems. ZTE has promised a Mozilla handset, HTC and Samsung are putting renewed emphasis on Windows Phone, and now the Korean giant is reportedly ready to unveil its first smartphone supporting the Tizen Linux-based OS.

Rather than creating a separate brand for this platform, as it did with the Wave family for its homegrown bada OS, it seems that it will create a Tizen version of its Android bestseller, the Galaxy S III. The plans came to light because the product has already achieved Wi-Fi Alliance certification, according to Techworld.

Release 2.0 of Tizen is now available as an alpha release with an accompanying SDK, the Tizen project announced this week. The open source OS was formed from the merger of MeeGo, the shortlived Nokia/Intel platform, and the LiMO Foundation’s carrier driven offering. Samsung, which was the main vendor to create LiMO handsets, is the primary Tizen backer, along with Intel.

Two weeks ago, the Wi-Fi Alliance published a document certifying that a Samsung smartphone called ‘GT-i9300_TIZEN’ had passed its interoperability testing process. GT-i9300 is the model number Samsung gives to Galaxy S III.

Meanwhile, the alpha code for Tizen 2.0 shows an OS which is getting close to commercial usability, comprising the kernel plus device drivers, middleware subsystems and web APIs. Recent new additions include advanced HTML5 features such as video subtitles, and a multi-process Webkit2-based runtime to improve security and reliability for web applications.

The steering group will add more features over the coming weeks and the OS should be ready in early 2013, in the same timeframe that analysts believe Samsung could ship a Tizen handset. Like Wave, this will be very much a second string to Android in sales terms, but like other OEMs, the Korean giant is keen to keep its options open to avoid giving too much power to Google, especially in the light of its Motorola acquisition and the barrage of patent lawsuits against Android.

Samsung will need to attract developer interest to make worthwhile applications for Tizen, and needs to interest mobile phone operators to sell smartphones running the new operating system, said Jeronimo. Besides that, Tizen is not known by customers, he added. “Most operators currently concentrate on Windows Phone,” he said. Another problem is that Tizen will never get anywhere if Samsung is the only manufacturer making Tizen devices, he said.