Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 September 2012

UK’s Virgin tightens cellco ties with small cell backhaul moves

Cable operators are becoming one of the most interesting groups in determining the shape of next generation wireless services. In many areas, they have toyed with investing in their own spectrum and networks but then backed away. This was seen in the US, where four cablecos have sold their licences on to Verizon in return for a broad MVNO and cross-selling deal, and also in the UK, where the largest cable firm, Virgin Media, said last week it would not bid in the upcoming LTE auction. Some cablecos, like those in The Netherlands, continue to pursue their own quad plays, but in many cases, the firms aim to be disruptive using Wi-Fi, creative MVNO strategies, and the increasing value of their infrastructure to cellular carriers.

Amid the scramble for backhaul, cable lines are attractive for backhauling some grades of cell tower, and many cablecos also have fiber, but they are even more valuable for supporting the rising tide of carrier Wi-Fi access points and small public access cells. This factor could give large cablecos a key role in the evolution of the HetNet (heterogenous network) which will boost capacity by combining base stations of different sizes, in multiple spectrum bands and supporting multiple air interfaces including Wi-Fi.

The US MSOs have led the way, particularly the close alliance of Comcast and Time Warner Cable, often also embracing Cox. This triumvirate, as well as the smaller BrightHouse Networks, has been through different phases in working out the cable/4G strategy ‘ partnering to buy spectrum; investing in Clearwire to gain control over a 4G service; defecting to Verizon for LTE and the beginnings of jointly supported quad play bundles. They have also partnered in a carrier Wi-Fi initiative which could achieve the scale and ambition of the huge cellco roll-outs in south east Asia, providing national roaming across their hotspots and offering mobile carrier partners a huge offload facility.

In carrier Wi-Fi, they have the advantage of their cable lines for backhaul, and vendors like BelAir (now Ericsson) and Ruckus have worked hard to integrate cable and WLan systems. There is gold to be made from small cell and LTE backhaul and the same drivers are also clearly seen in the strategy of Virgin Media in the UK. The firm has considered ‘ and now rejected- buying LTE spectrum and has tested its own small cells. Its group also owns one of the largest MVNOs. It has invested in Wi-Fi services to add a wireless dimension for its users while supporting offload partnerships.

And it has a significant mobile backhaul operation thanks to its build-out of fiber. This scored a huge victory a year ago when it swiped an eight-year backhaul deal with MBNL ‘ the joint venture between 3UK and Everything Everywhere, which runs the cellcos’ networks ‘ from under incumbent BT’s nose. The £100m ($161m) contract sees Virgin upgrade backhaul infrastructure for the combined mobile networks of the cellcos to support increased mobile broadband capacity in preparation for LTE roll-outs, harnessing 1Gbps Synchronous-Ethernet services over Virgin’s fiber network. The company is setting up 14 regional aggregation networks to connect thousands of base stations, leaving only some rural areas to be served by microwave backhaul by the end of the period of the deal.

Now Virgin is looking beyond big fiber backhaul systems to the other end of the spectrum, cable (or fiber) support for small cells. This week it pitched a ‘small cells as a service’ (SCaaS) proposition, similar to the ‘femtocell as a service’ idea previously mooted by Europe-wide fiber provider Colt Telecom. This would involve Virgin taking responsibility for some of the most complex aspects of a small cell deployment for the cellco ‘ negotiating and acquiring thousands of sites, building up an inventory of street furniture, and providing power supplies, backhaul and installation services. It would then host small cells running in the cellco customers’ spectrum.

‘It’s a very natural extension of Virgin Media Business’ backhaul business,’ said Kevin Baughan, the cableco’s director of metro wireless, at an event in London this week and the idea was endorsed by Erol Hepsaydir, director of radio solutions strategy at 3UK. ‘We just bring the radio head,’ he commented, with many of the obstacles to small cell deployment taken off the carriers’ hands. In a recent survey of 65 tier one mobile carriers, Maravedis-Rethink found that acquiring sites in optimal locations was seen as the number one obstacle to wide small cell roll-outs, with backhaul also being in the top three along with cost issues.

Some operators will shy away from a hosted approach because they want to use their own small cells for differentiation, either by securing the best sites in terms of quality of service, or adding location and presence aware applications to add consumer value. However, that strategy relies on local authorities permitting base stations from multiple operators being installed close to the ground, and on the carrier taking on the added cost and complexity.

Other firms see the opportunity to offer an end-to-end small cell network service, notably Alcatel-Lucent, which includes site management, contract negotiation, backhaul and other elements in its portfolio. Colt Telecom has also promised its FaaS offering, leveraging its fiber network and particularly targeting MVNOs, which may want a small cell capability separate from that of their hosting network (a concept extensively explored by the US cablecos during their Clearwire days, as a way to differentiate themselves to end users while sharing a RAN). There are also mobile operators discussing wholesale small cell platforms which, because they would include spectrum, could support a wider range of options at the base station, and even more dynamic approaches such as offering on-demand access for enterprises and service providers.

Virgin has been trialling small cells itself, in the cities of London (working with Airspan Networks), Bristol and Newcastle.It used 20MHz of test spectrum in 2.6GHz. However, although it was reportedly evaluating the case for acquiring spectrum in the sale of 2.6GHz and 800MHz licences, due to take place in the spring, it has backed away from that option.

The operator confirmed to Computerworld that it was in talks with the largest mobile operator, Everything Everywhere, about an LTE MVNO deal. Given the existing relationship in mobile backhaul via MBNL, and Virgin’s hints that it would soon test its hosted small cell idea with a major mobile player, there are clear opportunities for a Verizon/cable-style alliance between the UK’s biggest cellco and cableco, covering all aspects of the converged network and services.

If a 4G MVNO deal is announced ‘ adding to that existing for 3G between Virgin Mobile and EE ‘ it will be taken by other cellcos as another sign that EE has been handed an unfair advantage by being allowed to start rolling out 4G early, in its refarmed 1.8GHz GSM spectrum. Barring last minute legal challenges, EE’s LTE1800 services will become available in London, Bristol, Cardiff and Birmingham in the coming weeks, and in 12 more cities by year end. The aim is to cover 70% of the population by the end of 2013 and 98% a year later.

Please contact [email protected] for more information, or an executive summary, of Maravedis-Rethink’s new report, ‘Transforming the Mobile Data Network: Operator strategies for profitable small cell networks 2012-2016’.