Significance: Softbank is to pay $20.1bn for a 70% stake in Sprint, but although it needs to expand beyond its saturated home market, it is taking on a huge level of risk by tying itself to a carrier labouring under years of poor performance; a shift to the low margin market; an ambitious and risky network upgrade; and an excessive commitment to the iPhone. If Softbank engages very actively with its new ally, it could influence Sprint’s services and user experience for the better, harnessing all the expertise gained from the advanced Japanese mobile web market. However, it may be more hands-off, limiting the benefits of the deal for the US consumer. To enhance the value it can derive from its gamble, Softbank should turn its attention to an element of Sprint where there are genuine common interests, namely the Clearwire joint venture. Taking full control of that operator could allow Softbank to exploit its huge spectrum capacity more effectively than Sprint ever has, at least since the first year of its WiMAX push. And the Japanese firm could benefit from device and roaming partnerships for its own TD-LTE networks at home, making the deal look somewhat more positive to a generally negative Japanese shareholder base.
Softbank duly announced its expected deal to buy a majority stake in Sprint, acquiring 70% of the third US cellco for $20.1bn. The advantages for Sprint are obvious ‘ a much-needed capital injection to remove some of the risk from its 4G strategy; the expertise of one of the world’s mobile innovators. But as a record drop in Softbank’s share value showed, the Japanese firm is piling up its risk and, while it does need to seek growth beyond its own saturating home market, it has very likely picked the wrong vehicle to do it.
The deal marries two firms which are number three in their market, and which have pinned much of their growth strategy on the iPhone. There the similarities end. Softbank has been gaining ground on Docomo and KDDI thanks to its Apple handset and some creative tariffs and services. It has acquired the most serious of the smaller challengers to its position, eMobile, and has strong ratings for customer experience.
By contrast, Sprint is still losing postpaid subscribers; lost its initial 4G headstart once the market shifted from WiMAX to LTE; and made huge commitments to the iPhone just as the handset was being offered up to every carrier in the country, including prepaid ones. As the big two operators increase their dominance, Sprint is increasingly being pushed down to compete in the prepaid bear pit with T-Mobile and MetroPCS.
However, the Japanese firm is looking for greater scale, and international footholds, as its home market saturates. The ongoing realignment of the US wireless business reflects changes in the global patterns of power. While Deutsche Telekom has tried (and failed) to exit T-Mobile USA, as the European telcos battle with debt and look for emerging market growth, the Asian powerhouses of Japan, Korea and China are looking for expansion abroad, harnessing their superior financial position and technological influence.
Though their natural inclination is to expand to neighboring countries, Softbank has set its sights on the US and the Sprint stake may be the prelude to bigger ambitions in a country where scale is necessary to put any dent in Verizon and AT&T. Some insiders believe the Sprint tie-up is part of a two-step move on US operators, and that the new partners could go on to outbid T-Mobile for MetroPCS, and/or to buy the 52% of Clearwire that is not already owned by Sprint. Although somewhat sidelined in Sprint’s strategy since it started to roll out its own LTE network, the former WiMAX carrier has significant spectrum holdings and is migrating to TD-LTE and then on to LTE-Advanced. Like its largest shareholder, it would benefit hugely from a cash injection to support its 4G strategies and the best way for Softbank to get a decent return on its investment, in the medium term, might be to leverage Clearwire’s huge spectrum position more effectively than Sprint ever did ‘ especially as, with TD-LTE networks of its own at home, it could also leverage economies of scale in devices.
This is the largest outbound acquisition by a Japanese company since at least 2000 and the combined entity will be the world’s third largest cellco by revenue, with a total of 96m subscribers between them. The agreement involves paying $12.1bn to the US firm’s shareholders and injecting $8bn in new capital, which will boost the coffers for the Network Vision LTE and modernization project. This will make the carrier’s plan look more attractive to shareholders, which have been worried by the combination of an aggressive 4G/capex program and heavy subsidy payments and iPhone sales commitments to Apple. ‘It could not be a better time to get this investment of capital,’ Sprint CEO Dan Hesse said.
There should also be many positives – if the transaction is better handled than Sprint’s previous merger with Nextel ‘ for US consumers. An enriched Sprint with a powerful partner to guide it – and no issues of network alignment, as with MetroPCS ‘ could be a stronger challenger to the Verizon/AT&T duo, without reducing the number of US players. That would please antitrust authorities in the US, which blocked the AT&T/T-Mobile takeover partly on the grounds that it would remove a national cellco from the map and so reduce consumer choice. Indeed, few expect any serious regulatory hurdles, especially after Verizon’s spectrum purchasing and cross-selling agreement with four cablecos was waved through with relatively light conditions.
But while the benefits to Sprint are clear, Softbank is taking on a still-troubled third player in a market where the big two have got increasingly strong in high value sectors. Softbank shares fell still further on confirmation of the deal, down 5.3% in Tokyo to ‘2,268, continuing a record 17% nosedive on October 12, when the acquisition first hit the news. Analysts said investors were worried by the scale of Sprint’s challenges; by the contrasts in its technologies and business environment compared to Softbank’s; and by a poor understanding of how growth was to be generated for Softbank by this alliance.
Yoshihisa Toyosaki, an analyst with Architect Grand Design in Tokyo, summed up the thoughts of many: ‘Softbank is trying to take advantage of the economic turmoil in the US to buy a majority stake in a carrier. This represents an opportunity for them.’ It would certainly take the cellco into a larger market, and a less saturated one than most developed European and Asian mobile bases. But with most of the operational and technical excellence, and international influence, on Softbank’s side, it may find itself paying a high price and taking on a long term rescue project.
‘It’s not an easy path to go,’ Son told journalists in Tokyo as he announced the deal today. ‘But without taking on a challenge, we may end up facing bigger risks.’
On the positive side, there are various common interests between the two firms which could be exploited to benefit services and consumers in both the US and Japan. In areas such as mobile payments and carrier web applications, Softbank has considerable resources and expertise, and while that is something of a one-way street, its new vehicle has a better chance of gaining share from the big two ‘ rather than just from the low margin prepaid carriers ‘ if it has distinctive services and user experiences to offer.
The 70% stake is sufficiently large to give the Japanese firm considerable influence over how Sprint deploys its network and services ‘ indeed, Softbank’s eccentric but powerful CEO, Masayoshi Son, may insist on it. “Every time I come to the US I say ‘Oh my God, the mobile phone network is so slow’,’ he told the analyst call to discuss the stake.
While the US operator insisted its Network Vision modernization programme and 4G roll-out would be unaffected, it will certainly be taking Softbank’s ideas on board in other areas. Analyst Chetan Sharma told The New York Times that Softbank was bringing expertise from a country where operators, rather than Google and Apple, were still in the driving seat in delivering advanced services. “Things that Google and Apple are trying to do here, operators are already doing in those countries,” he said. For instance, Softbank owns PayPal Japan, a 50:50 joint venture with the eBay unit, whose PayPal Here m-commerce platform could enhance Sprint’s payments activities. And as the NYT points out, Softbank has also been aggressive in mobile advertising with its $200m investment in InMobi, which not only has an advertising network, but also the SmartPay mobile app billing system and an HTML5-based rich media distribution system.
However, while it seems logical that Softbank would share its superior knowledge in order to boost the viability of its new partner, it may take a more hands-off approach. Craig Moffett, an analyst at Sanford C Bernstein, said: “There are no synergies whatsoever in a Japanese company buying a US telecom operator. This is tantamount to Japanese buyers buying Rockefeller Center. Unless they simply think they’re investing in US real estate, and it happens to be electromagnetic real estate that they’re buying, this is not a merger with anybody. This is just somebody coming in and buying Sprint stock.”
The exception would be in TD-LTE, where there would be direct benefits to Softbank at home, should Clearwire be brought into the deal once it is finalized next year. Even if it is not, Sprint remains the largest stakeholder and gives Softbank a close alliance with one of the few currently commercial TD-LTE device and roaming partners for its own 2.5GHz network in Japan. If Softbank were to harness the Clearwire connection effectively, it could increase the value of the network it has built in spectrum acquired from Willcom, and inject the resource and vision to turn Clearwire into a jewel in its strategy.
Sprint, having made the initial leap of imagination to partner with Clearwire and try to steal a march on rivals in 4G, has then repeatedly mishandled the relationship, which has left the smaller firm struggling to achieve its goals, and its huge swathe of spectrum underused. As high frequency bands like 2.5GHz gain new favour with the shift towards smaller cells and high capacity networks, and TDD technologies move to the mainstream, Clearwire will have a new attractiveness which Softbank, far more than Sprint, will be equipped to recognize and leverage. Hence why, despite the new partners’ efforts to downplay the notion, many observers believe the former WiMAX player will be acquired in 2013.
The timing would be good, just as TD-LTE technology is becoming ‘respectable’. Clearwire’s close alliance with the sector’s driver, China Mobile, has been important to its strategy, and this week the Chinese government agreed to support the 2.5/2.6GHz TDD band ‘ as used by the US provider ‘ for 4G services (along with unpaired 1.9GHz). One influencing factor was said to be the partnership between China’s largest cellco and its US ally, a pact that has focused on shared procurement and R&D in devices, as well as roaming. All that will also be important to Softbank’s own TD-LTE and converged efforts at home.
“We believe that Clearwire will play a critical role in Softbank’s plans to aggressively compete with AT&T and Verizon in the United States,” wrote BTIG analyst Walter Piecyk in a research note. “Clearwire’s depth of spectrum paired with Sprint’s network and customer scale and Softbank’s cheap capital will enable the companies to offer faster speeds and more capacity than their rivals. Sprint would be wise to take control of Clearwire as soon as possible in order to protect that differentiation but in recent history Sprint has been slow to act, allowing their peers to poach opportunities.”
Sprint may be slow to act, but Softbank generally is not. With few regulatory hurdles anticipated, it should move as swiftly as possible after its stake is agreed to take over Clearwire, giving it the spectrum capacity to mount a real challenge to Verizon and AT&T. That could shift at least a little of the balance of benefits in Softbank’s own direction, and make the deal more than just a high risk investment in wireless real estate.
TD-LTE developments:
China Mobile is expanding its massive TD-LTE ‘trial’ to 13 additional cities and will divide the spoils among seven vendors ‘ ZTE, Alcatel-Lucent, Huawei, Ericsson, NSN, New Postcom Equipment and Datang Mobile. The tender includes contracts for some 20,000 base stations and 52,000 carrier sectors. ZTE will supply 13,000 carrier frequencies in the cities of Beijing, Tianjin, Guangzhou, Shenzhen and Shenyang. while Alcatel-Lucent Shanghai Bell will provide about 3,000 base stations in Shanghai, Nanjing and Qingdao in early 2013. The operator plans to instal 20,000 4G base stations by year end and during 2013 it will expand the effort to 100 cities and 200,000 base stations. It already offers commercial services on the network even though it is still officially a trial, as the government has not awarded 4G licences yet. Its endorsement of the key spectrum bands may be a signal that it will address this next year, despite previous indications that it would wait until 2014 or later to allow all three Chinese cellcos to get return on their 3G investments.
Nokia Siemens says that it has provided the infrastructure for the first TD-LTE pilot in Spain ‘ in Murcia – ahead of a November launch of commercial services, which will be southern Europe’s first TD-LTE network in 2.6GHz. Although European regulators are selling unpaired as well as FDD spectrum in this band, most major cellcos have concentrated on paired frequencies for now, leaving the way open for smaller players. COTA acquired 10MHz of spectrum in 2011. It will use its network to provide wholesale services ‘ its first customer is wireless DSL provider WiMAX Online ‘ and its own IPTV offerings in future.
Bharti Airtel and Huawei have announced the launch of India’s first multimode TD-LTE smartphone, the Ascend P1 LTE. This also supports Circuit Switched Fall Back (CSFB) voice technology to allow voice calls to be handled on the 3G network. Earlier this year, Bharti Airtel became the first provider in India to deploy TD-LTE and it launched services in Kolkata and Bengaluru.
Saudi operator Mobily says its TD-LTE network has now been expanded to cover 31 cities. The 2.6GHz network, which is operated by Mobily subsidiary Bayanat Al-Oula, launched in September last year and will eventually cover up to 85% of the Saudi population.