Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 October 2012

Ultrabook not enough to get Intel through post-PC transition

Significance: Intel’s third quarter results were ahead of muted expectations but still showed the impact of the stagnation in the PC market ‘ and the failure of the chip giant, so far, to build a position in post-PC devices large enough to offset the threat to its largest business. Of course this will be a long and difficult process but there is rising urgency for Intel to demonstrate it can continue to drive the new device form factors as it has the PC industry. Its main hopes rest on the ultrabook, but this is basically a refinement of the classic notebook, and more innovative designs are emerging from the ARM community. Much rests on Windows 8, though Microsoft’s strategies have effectively confined its old ally to its high power heartland, making it difficult for the x86 version of W8 to reach down into the fully mobile sector. That makes two changes essential ‘ to accelerate the progress of Atom in the Android world, and to come up with a showstopping new form factor in the evolving convertible or cloudbook segments.

An unexpected uptick in PC processor sales in September enabled Intel to beat (previously downgraded) third quarter sales estimates, but the results still highlighted the crisis in the traditional PC market, which is still the bedrock of the chipmaker’s business. It is expanding in areas like network processors, and fending off ARM in the server, but its most critical task is to ensure that the devices that replace the PC still rely on Intel x86 silicon. So far, its gains in this respect ‘ Atom devices and Core-based ultrabooks ‘ have been far too small to offset the risks to the PC base, leaving Intel with a difficult transition period. How long that lasts, and how far Intel will need to rely on non-device growth areas like network hardware, partly depends on how the Windows 8 launch pans out at the turn of the year.

Intel reported third quarter sales of $13.5bn, down 5% year-on-year and flat on Q212, while it turned in net income of $3bn, down 14% on last year and up 5% on the second quarter. Sales were above analyst consensus expectations of $13.2bn thanks to an upturn in the PC sector at the end of the quarter, as vendors started to prepare for the Windows 8 launch. But while this enabled the chip giant to please Wall Street, it had last month cut its sales targets to $13.2bn, because of PC weakness. Last week, research firm IHS iSuppli forecast that PC sales would fall in 2012 for the first time since the 2001 slump.

Revenue from Intel’s PC client group was $8.6bn in the quarter, down 8% year-on-year, while the data center group had revenue of $2.7bn, up 6%, though down 5% on Q212. Intel also cited soft PC demand and reduced microprocessor inventories across the PC supply chain ‘ as well as the economic climate and some enterprise slowdown ‘ as it warned that the fourth quarter would see minimal growth. For Q4, it expects sales to be between $13.1bn and $14.1bn, which would represent a 1% sequential increase at the midpoint.

The demise of the PC will be a long one, and will be less a death than a metamorphosis into a new form ‘ a Frankenstein-style one if some of the concept designs doing the rounds ever hit the shelves. But the loss of growth is now hitting a critical point for Intel and it needs to accelerate the move of x86 into mobile and post-PC devices, in whatever shape.

The five-year history of Atom, the low power family created for this challenge, has been one mainly of disappointment in the smartphone space, though Intel is finally making some inroads with models like the Motorola RAZR Droid. However, the bigger opportunities lie in driving the form factor for the post-PC hybrid devices which sit between smartphones and PCs ‘ tablets, ultrabooks and other emerging designs, plus various combinations of these. Securing a place in the tablet sector rests mainly on Windows 8, but Intel has already been bidding for the middle ground with its ultrabook concept. However, uptake has been slow so far, and most analysts, while expecting this form factor (or its successors) to play a major role in the device market, think a significant uptick will wait until 2015.

Whether it is pushing tablets, ultrabooks or emerging new designs Intel will, ironically enough, need to rely on its old strength, processing power, despite the huge investments it has made in energy efficiency.

Despite all those millions of dollars, the hybrid market still sees ARM playing to its low power credentials and Intel to its horsepower. In reality, the two platforms are coming close to one another in both respects, but in terms of the customers they serve, there is still a clear division: Intel for high end processing, ARM for battery life. This game is played around more than technical specifications ‘ even more important are existing customer and supply chains, design norms and software bases. Intel will remain a niche player in those devices with clear roots in the handset world, for all its efforts to support Android and low power. Its opportunities lie when the entire device base cycles to something significantly new, in which it is on a level playing field with ARM supporters like Qualcomm, or preferably, which it has helped to shape.

This will be a very long cycle in the handset space. Smartphones may eventually be replaced by larger-screened gadgets, with users just keeping a lower end cellphone for voice, but for now the tablets are usually additional purchases, and are basically just stretched smartphones, with the same components and dominant vendors.

Intel’s opportunity to leap in, then, is limited. Its own major play for this hybrid space is the ultrabook, but that is basically a PC replacement and does not impinge on the ARM heartlands. It has modern credentials such as long battery life, slimline design and the potential to evolve into a true cloudbook (the latest iteration of the thin client idea). But at the moment, it largely appeals either because it Core processor is more powerful than an ARM, for heavy duty users, or because it offers a PC experience in a more portable format. Therefore, it may be an add-on purchase like a tablet, but it may also replace a notebook, cannibalizing Intel’s base. While the x86 giant has to face a ‘post-PC’ shift, there is no ‘post-smartphone’ transition as yet, leaving the ARM brigade with a hefty, and growing, base on which to build their hybrid devices.

The ultrabook and the current iPad-style tablet, then, live in PC and mobile worlds respectively, and as yet these are muddled up far less than many perceive. The portable devices really get thrown into the blender from next year, when Windows 8 will have appeared. That enables ARM-based platforms to run the fully fledged Windows, the OS of the PC world, rather than being confined to mobile specific OSs. But of course, the way that Microsoft has split its new OS between ARM and Intel actually serves to maintain the walls between the PC and mobile worlds. Windows RT devices do not get software compatibility with the huge existing Windows base, which will limit enterprise support and remove one of the key reasons a user might buy a W8 rather than and Android or iOS tablet.

With its own strategy for its Surface tablet, Microsoft has positioned RT in the traditional mobile world, pricing it the same as the iPad and stressing lower power, while the Surface Pro, running on x86, is expected to come with a heftier price tag of about $1,000, competitive with an ultrabook or notebook. That means that Windows RT remains primarily a mobile OS. It will converge with Windows Phone over time and together they could create a more powerful smartphone/tablet platform than Microsoft has ever achieved. But for users wanting apps compatibility and hefty processing, will a Windows 8 ultrabook or tablet, running either Atom or Core, be enough to convince them that this is the real PC replacement platform, and a move from PC to ARM would just be too much of a stretch?

The attempt to colonize the whole hybrid space with the moble tablet (ARM) or ultrabook (Intel) has failed for now and left the contenders’ ecosystems still clearly separated. However, the next wave of form factors may enable them to meet head-on, if vendors succeed in thinking more laterally than merely shrinking the notebook and adding a touchscreen (Intel) or stretching the smartphone (ARM).

“I don’t think the tablet as we’ve seen it evolve over the last several years is the end state of computing,” Intel CEO Paul Otellini said on the results conference call. “What I can’t predict is what form factor is going to win here,” he added. This uncertainty pervades the industry, and for Intel represents a source of hope rather than frustration ‘ hope that the hybrid and post-PC markets will not inevitably be designed by Apple, despite the enormous impact of the iPad. That device has certainly impinged on the notebook segment, but for now remains largely an additional product, or a possible alternative to a new MacBook Air for Apple devotees. Intel and others need to move quickly to produce other designs which can head off the iPad ‘ and the ultrabook will certainly not do that alone.

Otellini optimistically said ultrabooks would become one of the highest volume form factors because they offer “the best of both worlds”, but admitted: ‘We won’t know for 12 months’, even though Intel expects 140 of these gadgets to debut in the coming year, about 40 with touchscreens and 12 as convertibles. Some will come down to $699 in price, which will help boost volume, though Intel surely has to set a target of matching high end tablet pricing as those gadgets increase in functionality and reset customers’ expectations of price. An ultrabook may look affordable when compared to a notebook, but Intel and its partners have to readjust their thinking to a world where users can get a product perceived to be ‘premium’, like an iPad, for under $500.

This is the real challenge the device ecosystem has to face ‘ the new, and rapidly changing, norms in consumer expectation, whether that is about pricing, hardware features or user experience. If the mobile and PC experiences do truly converge, it is likely to be around the price points set by the ARM/Android/iOS axis. The user interface, however, could just as well evolve from the starting point of Windows Metro as from iOS/Android ‘ or eventually, something entirely new, focused on the browser and cloud. It is clear that the touch experience will be key, whatever the device type, but other aspects of the form factor remain to be decided, or rethought entirely.

Over the space of just a few years, we have seen the emergence of the touch tablet (success), ultrabook (jury out), smartbook (disappeared), netbook (temporary success), and now there are two new waves, centered on convertibles and cloudbooks. The latter has very uncertain prospects so far but has been strongly driven by Google with the Chromebook. This is the latest iteration of the thin client idea ‘ a device with very little local storage or apps, relying on cloud connectivity for everything, even most of its browser processing. The ultrabook could extend in this direction, but Intel’s more obvious chances lie in the convertibles. These provide various combinations of tablet and PC, with different and increasingly ingenious ways to switch from one to the other. And they may incorporate the phone more directly than the current tablet ‘ Asus just showed off the PadFone 2, an Android handset which docks into a thin 10.1-inch tablet shell to power it for many hours, syncrhonizing data, media and apps. This is reminiscent of the recently cancelled Webtop offering from Motorola, which was widely seen as being ahead of its time. Whichever of these options becomes mainstream rather than a gimmick, the worrying factor for Intel is that most of the more novel designs are driven by the Android/ARM community. It needs to start using its supply chain influence and considerable R&D capabilities to try to direct the ‘next big thing’, if it is to remain in the vanguard of any device which gains power in the ‘post-PC’ era.

Microsoft goes head-to-head with iPad with $499 Surface:

Microsoft never quite gets the headlines to itself. On the day it revealed pricing as part of the build-up to the launch of its Surface tablet, Apple sent out the invitations for an event on October 23, presumed to be the debut of the ‘iPad Mini’. So while the cost of the Windows RT-based Surface, starting at $499, takes Microsoft head-to-head with the iPad, Apple will be deciding whether to price its small slate low enough to take on Google and Amazon directly.

That would involve a tag around $199 for a Wi-Fi model ‘ or a little more to allow for iDevice premium perhaps, but the new gadget will be all about reaching out to new users, so price will be a more important factor than it is among loyal Apple buyers.

For now, though, Apple is keeping quiet about all details ‘ or indeed, whether its party really will be for the iPad Mini. Its invitation, to an event in San Jose in Silicon Valley, just reads: “We’ve got a little more to show you.’

The firm is expected to unveil a 7-inch iPad as well as a range of other ‘mini’ devices on the roadmap, including a 13-inch MacBook Pro with RetinaDisplay and new Mac Mini desktops.

Meanwhile, the first Surface model, the RT version (running on ARM processors), will cost $499 for a 32Gbytes slate, rising to $599 when bundled with a multitouch keyboard case. The 64Gbytes version is $699, with the TouchCover case included. Pricing is still not known for the Intel x86-based model, the Surface Pro, which will ship about three months later than the RT. The Pro is expected to be priced more like a slimline notebook or ultrabook, around $1,000.

Although the Surface RT will pack more hardware features than the iPad, it will not support cellular connectivity nor a super-high resolution display (1,366 x 768, compared to 2,048 x 1,536 for RetinaDisplay).