Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 October 2012

Fateful iPod lawsuit seen as sparking mobile patent war

The escalating patents war which is distorting competition and restricting innovation in the mobile market may date back to an event in 2006, when Creative Technologies won a $100m ruling against Apple, whose iPod was judged to violate Creative’s patent for a “portable music playback device”. A win based on such a generic description prefigures Apple’s attacks on Samsung for its rectangular device with round corners, and it was enough to make then-CEO Steve Jobs resolve to ‘patent it all’.

A fprmer Apple executive told The New York Times that the event led to a process whereby patent lawyers and engineers would meet for ‘invention disclosure sessions’ where the attorneys would decide what applications could be filed ‘ even if approval was unlikely.

Most recently, Apple has won a US patent on the design of its first iPad, even though this comes almost three years after the device’s debut. The vendor gained more than 30 patents this week, including one as vaguely titled as that important Creative Technologies one ‘ it is called just ‘portable display device’, though the picture matches the first iPad, and the patent was filed the daey before that gadget’s launch. Apple already has another design patent for the iPad, which it has held since 2005 and which has featured prominently in its litigation, but that is even more generic, lacking details such as the home button, volume buttons, and dock connector.

However, Apple’s comprehensive approach ‘ which later escalated into Jobs’ famous declaration of ‘nuclear’ war against Android ‘ has led to an unhealthy climate of litigation in the mobile industry. Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos may be getting nervous about his own firm’s relative shortage of IPR, given what happened to Google when it underplayed the need to amass software patents. He is certainly hostile to the current legal tactics being adopted by Amazon’s mobile competitors. He expressed concern, in an interview last week, that the lawsuits “might start to stifle innovation’ and suggested that governments should consider intervening in the suits to protect consumers. “Governments may need to look at the patent system and see if those laws need to be modified because I don’t think some of these battles are healthy for society,” he said.

His concerns were echoed this week by patent experts speaking at a US event hosted by the Advisory Committee to the Congressional Internet Caucus. Start-ups, in particular, have to deal with thousands of patents in some cases, and Marvin Ammori, a technology, argued: “The system isn’t really conducive to innovating around all these patents. We’ve essentially set up a system that … harms innovation, rather than promotes it.” He called on Congress to end patents for software and business methods and so deter large hi-tech firms from applying for large numbers of such IPR on a purely defensive basis.

That trend, and the resulting IPR arms race, has not seen any abatement of law court encounters as yet. In the latest twist, Microsoft will finally drag Google directly into the patents war against Android, seeking to amend a German suit against Motorola Mobility to include the handset maker’s parent. So far, Google has operated from the sidelines, providing resources and even IPR to Android partners, and has been directly attacked only by Oracle. However, now it has acquired Motorola, it has provided a route for Microsoft ‘ and probably Apple soon ‘ to open up a new front against the Android wizard itself.

Microsoft’s lead counsel, Tilman Mueller-Stoy, told a court in Munich, Germany ‘ one of the chief arenas for the Windows giant’s assaults on Android ‘ that it will amend an earlier lawsuit to include Google. Microsoft has had a different agenda to Apple in its Android attacks, seeking licensing revenues (which reduce Android’s appeal by increasing its costs), rather than injunctions. However, Motorola has been the main stand-out, refusing to sign licensing agreements like Samsung and many other OEMs.

Adding Motorola to its list of licensees would give Microsoft virtually a full house, netting it higher revenues than its own Windows Phone, and endorsing its claim to have vital IPR in Linux-based operating systems. That could have implications for other open source, mobile Linux initiatives such as Mozilla’s Firefox Mobile, should these start to gain market position. And victory against Google itself would make it very difficult for any Android user to reject Microsoft’s advances in future, and that could be significant as the OS moves into new device sectors such as embedded gadgets or set-top boxes.

Florian Mueller noted Microsoft’s latest move on his Foss Patents blog, saying that the lawsuit was filed in April this year, and relates to Google Maps. Microsoft argues that the app, which was developed by Google and is used in Motorola handsets, violates its own IPR related to “identifying local resources.” Motorola denies the claims.

Mueller says that Microsoft still has to serve the official complaint, and the trial date, set for March 7 2013, could be pushed back. Google’s deputy general counsel Allen Lo told CNet: “We want to focus on innovation, not litigation, but we’ll vigorously defend against any amended complaint Microsoft files.’

Before anything results from that action, Motorola has already suffered a blow in Germany, where it has stopped sales of smartphones and tablets after failing to overturn patent judgments won by Microsoft and Apple. This could trigger an exit from the country by the Google unit, whose new CEO Dennis Woodside has indicated he wants to focus his efforts on fewer devices and territories. The company says it has already phased out some lower end devices in Germany and other European markets, unrelated to the lawsuits. Previous CEO Sanjay Jha had pulled back significantly from Europe, though towards the end of his tenure there were some moves to increase distribution in the region again, something Woodside has now reversed.

This injunction and other blows to Android vendors are leading some to question whether Google’s patent-driven, $12.5bn purchase of Motorola is justified. Mueller told the UK’s Guardian newspaper: “The company that Google bought for $12.5bn to protect Android from patent threats cannot even protect itself. It appears that Google as a whole is struggling to keep up with the fast growing number of Android related patent infringements identified by courts in the US, Europe and Asia.”

Microsoft has already won three court actions that ban the sale of Motorola devices in Germany for infringing a FAT file system patent, an SMS patent and a patent describing a method for handling communication between a keyboard and an application. A fourth legal challenge was denied in Mannheim, Germany, last week.

The most important Android OEM, Samsung, has also suffered several blows at the hands of Apple, notably its landmark $1bn loss in the federal court in San Jose recently. Decisions in both directions, plus appeals and new filings, continue to mount up between the arch-rivals, though both gained valuable reprieves last week. A Korean judge in Seoul granted Apple’s request to stay an injunction against the iPhone and iPad until it can conclude an appeal against the previous ruling. The ban was imposed in August after a court decided that both Apple and Samsung violated one another’s IPR. The iPhone 4, iPad 2 and Samsung’s Galaxy S II and Galaxy Nexus, were all slapped with a ban. Samsung has so far not requested a stay on its own injunction.

Meanwhile, the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has given Samsung a break in its war with Apple, and has reversed an injunction against the Galaxy Nexus. The preliminary ban had been imposed by a district court in California against the Samsung-Google device, but the appeal judge found that court “abused its discretion” in awarding an injunction. The case will now return to the California jurisdiction. After filing a patent infringement suit against Samsung early this year, Apple asked the court to ban the sales of infringing products while the market waited for the case to be heard. District Judge Lucy Koh agreed but the ban has now been suspended until a final ruling is reached.

Apple is appealing another ruling, this one in Tokyo, where a court said Samsung did not infringe an Apple patent for synchronizing music and video data with servers.