CCAP (Converged Cable Access Platform) has been the talk of the cable TV world all this year for its promise to migrate from MPEG to IP video by converging CMTS with both narrowcast and broadcast edge QAM, in a single dense integrated device. The big four vendors, Cisco, Arris, Motorola and Harmonic in that order, have all pushed hard to convert roadmaps into real products and have been joined by two other hopefuls, Commscope and Casa Systems, which also now have CCAP offerings on the table. It seems unlikely that these two will make much of a dent in the big four’s armory, since between them they have the world’s major MSOs sewn up and have been tireless in promoting their own CCAP strategies. Casa Systems’ biggest MSO customer for example is Stofa, Denmark’s second cable TV operator with around 350,000 TV customers, while Arris by contrast numbers the two largest US cable operators, Comcast and Time Warner, in its portfolio, with well over 30 million customers between them.
Given that a large part of the motivation for CCAP is to cut costs for MSOs in their intense battle with Telcos for TV and broadband subs, margins will be tight and this will favor the big vendors whose kit is serving much larger subscriber bases. We are seeing pay as you go models emerge for CCAP, with Cisco charging MSO customers only for the capacity they actually use on a per port basis. Again the big vendors are better placed to compete on a pay as you go basis.
Nevertheless MSOs will welcome some competition for the big four, and CommScope has achieved a high density with its Converged Services Platform, which made its public debut at the recent Cable-Tec Expo. This comes in two versions, a nine-rack-unit model with support for a maximum of 9,600 downstream QAMs and aggregate throughput of 640 Gigabits per second, and a 14-RU model, with up to 19,200 downstream QAMs and throughput of 1.28 Terabits per second.
Casa Systems for its part was the first out with a full CCAP product in May 2012 in the form of a high-density module for its existing C10G cable modem termination system, but with slightly less capacity than CommScope’s unit, delivering 96 channels per port for a total of 768 channels per module, or 8448 in total given that up to 11 functional modules can be accommodated in a single chassis.
CommScope’s products will not be available for deployment until 2013, but is on the money in emphasizing the growing upstream bandwidth with a promise that customers will be able to mix and match that with the downstream, without giving full details. However CommScope has unveiled its PON (Passive Optical Network) product for those operators deploying FTTH, often to multi-dwelling units, with the potential to support upstream bit rates up to 1 Gbps.
In practice of course no home will need anywhere near 1 Gbps upstream yet awhile, but Telcos such as Verizon that have deployed a substantial amount of FTTH have put MSOs under the cosh with insinuations that with their shared HFC access infrastructure they would be unable to respond when it comes to upstream capacity in particular. But with GPON still in fantasy land for most Telcos as well as MSOs, a more cogent threat to MSOs in the upstream has come from Alcatel-Lucent with its vectoring technology that enables 40 Mbps of upstream capacity to be made available over copper loop lengths up to 400 meters on a one to one basis. For now this has thrown down the gauntlet to MSOs more than PON at a time when demand for upstream capacity is growing at 30% a year, faster than downstream, driven not just by increasing uploading of user generated video content to the likes of YouTube, but also the proliferation of cloud based storage and backup services for storing all sorts of multimedia content, including music and photographs.
Against this background the arrival of CCAP products could not come too soon, and of the vendors Arris seems most keenly aware of this, having been collaborating closely with Cable Labs over the specifications for three years. Therefore CCAP was the main feature of Arris’ E6000 Converged Edge Router (CER) launched at SCTE Cable-Tec Expo. This integrates edge QAM legacy video architecture and CMTS DOCSIS IP network to deliver a readymade integrated-IP platform through CCAP.
But Arris also stressed the importance of a new upstream cable access module integrated with the CMTS, supporting DOCSIS 3.0 upstream channel bonding and up to 12 upstream Channels per RF Connector with 24 connectors per Physical Interface Card, and flexible mapping of channels to the connectors. A significant advance is the ability to spread the upstream channels over an extended 80 MHz of spectrum from 5 MHz to 85Mz, reducing the cost of hardware. This is enabled by S-CDMA (Synchronous Code Division Multiple Access), which was added in DOCSIS 2.0 and then enhanced in DOCSIS 3.0 specifically to improve efficiency and increase robustness against impulse and burst noise, which is a notable problem in the upstream band below 20 MHz. The main improvement added in DOCSIS 3.0 was the ability to boost the Signal To Noise Ratio (SNR) of selected modems attached to paths suffering from particularly high attenuation, by increasing the power on a per symbol code basis, without affecting the operation of the rest of the network. This feature is particularly advantageous for some legacy HFC networks with long cascades of amplifiers over the coax segments, and perhaps reduces the need for node splitting to increase upstream capacity ‘ so once again the benefit is ultimately economic.
S-CDMA relies on the mathematical ability to superimpose multiple bits over a single symbol. In this context a symbol represents the unit of conversion between digital or binary information comprising strings of ones and zeroes, and continuously varying analogue signals such as waveforms over which this digital information is modulated. By exploiting the ability of equipment to recognize multiple small changes of amplitude in a signal within a given time slot, more than one bit can be encoded in a symbol, and this is the basis of 64 QAM and 256 QAM for example. In the case of S-CDMA, 128 bits are imposed on a symbol, which means that each symbol can be stretched in time by 128 times for a given bit rate, since 128 symbols can be then simultaneously transmitted without interfering with each other.
This stretching out of symbols in the time domain makes S-CDMA more than 100 times more resilient to noise resulting from electrical impulse and short bursts than its predecessor TDMA. It relies on the fact these impulses or bursts are short lived and so their impact is reduced and can more easily be countered by error correction if the symbols are of longer duration. Further enhancements such as Trellis Coded Modulation (TCM) have boosted upstream transmission robustness further.
Clearly S-CDMA is going to play a big part in MSOs’ upstream deployments aimed at repelling attacks on their customer base from predatory Telcos. Surprisingly perhaps Arris also emphasized another aspect of its CCAP portfolio, particularly for the upstream, and this is its support for IPv6. We say surprisingly not because IPv6 support is unimportant, but because it does not appear to be a source of competitive advantage for vendors, or for their operating customers. It has been seen as a necessary chore that has to be undertaken to cope with an impending IP address crunch exacerbated by the Internet of Things creating a plethora of new IP connected devices within the digital home and in the workplace. But Arris believes its customers can gain an advantage by being faster off the mark than their competitors to deploy IPv6, which will then deliver significant cost savings in content delivery, and quality of experience benefits for TV Everywhere services in particular.
The primary reason for bringing on IPv6 has been to tackle the Internet address crunch faced by the preceding IPv4 which still is predominant across the Internet. While IPv4 is confined by a 32 bit address space, which means there are 232 possible addresses, or 4.3 billion, considerably less than the population of the planet, IPv6 has 128 bits, creating 2128 possible addresses, which is 18,446,744,073,709,551,616, enough for every person on earth to have as many IP devices as there are grains of sand on the planet.
As IPv6 evolved it has also incorporated features particularly relevant and valuable for broadcasting and video transmission. One is in-built end-to-end device security via the IPSec protocol, which facilitates end-to-end authentication and identification of IP devices and so is useful for mobile TV. There is other good news for mobile TV, with support for global IP roaming, enabling devices such as audio codecs to go anywhere in the world and be contactable via a single IP address.
But the most exciting mobility aspect is one that perhaps will not be loved by all content or service providers, which is inherent support for media rich peer to peer (P2) applications, bypassing intermediate nodes in an IP network. This will make it much easier for individuals to set up P2P services from their mobile devices, and make them available either to a specified group of users, or anybody.
Broadcasters and OTT operators will also welcome IPv6’s embedded QoS support. While IPv4 was confined to ‘best effort’ IP packet delivery across networks, and therefore needed QoE mechanisms bolting on, IPv6 has a traffic-class field within packet headers allowing operators to prioritize data packets. This makes it much easier to ensure that audio/video content is delivered in uninterrupted streams across networks that are shared by less critical data traffic such as email. Of course this advantage diminishes in the case of a network almost entirely dedicated to premium video, but then such a network will probably involve some form of CDN anyway and so not rely on best effort delivery.
The remaining significant advantage of IPv6 for broadcasters lies in multicasting, with changes relevant for large scale OTT services or CDNs. Under IPv4, specific multicast routers are required to send multicast IP packets over IP networks, which tends to inhibit scalability to large geographical areas, because it may involve traversing long distances and many router hops for a service to reach the relevant multicast router serving a particular destination.
IPv6 fixes this via support for anycasting, which is sometimes described as a ‘fourth way’ of routing packets. Firstly there is unicasting, which is one-to-one, then there is broadcasting, which is one ‘to-all, and thirdly multicasting, or one-to-many but not everybody. Anycasting is one-to-one of many, where an IP packet’s destination is defined as any one, but just one, of a group of hosts or servers. It enables multiple hosts or servers that each provide the same service to share a single IP address. Then users can be directed just to the host nearest them to access the service, rather than having to go to a host the other side of the world. In this context nearest may not mean the geographically closest server, but the one that is accessible via the smallest number of hops, although the two will often coincide.
Anycasting is designed for services where a given set of users wants to access applications or data replicated across more than one server. It is particularly relevant for large scale video distribution, above all where interactivity is required when latency is a key issue. It means that the same content can be stored several times on different servers around the world, as is already increasingly done, and then users are directed to the nearest one. As well as reducing latency, this supports a degree of load balancing, depending on the scale, and also on how users are distributed around the region of operation. Configuration is also simplified, because there is just one single IP address to manage for all content, avoiding the need to correlate multiple DNS servers distributed around the network, DNS being the acronym for the Internet’s hierarchical naming system based on underlying IP addresses.
This approach can also provide an elegant solution for redundancy or high availability, because the information conveying which host to go to for the content (called the route advertisement) can be made dependent on the QoS information. If the nearest server is unavailable or congested for whatever reason, a user can be switched to the next nearest one. This leads to the final advantage, which is scalability. Instead of having to pump up a given server in a densely populated location, another server can be dropped in nearby and configured with the same anycast IPv6 address. Then users can be routed to the second server, and this idea can be propagated across a global network, enabling rapid reconfiguration to new routes in the event of congestion occurring. Here IPv6 does not achieve anything that cannot be done with IPv4, but makes life much easier, and the deployment will almost certainly be less expensive, more robust, and faster to converge or reconfigure in real time as required.
Many of these advantages are unappreciated in the video arena partly because IPv6 has remained low down the marketing agendas for most vendors in the ecosystem. Arris though rightly views it as an integral part of its strategy, recognizing perhaps its particular relevance for MSOs as they migrate towards all IP distribution and extend into the home.