Significance: For the first time, Microsoft has an operating system and user experience which are genuinely distinctive and will offer users a choice. In fact, it has three OSs ‘ Windows 8, Windows RT and WP8 ‘ but they can increasingly be considered as one platform. Success will depend on many factors, two particularly interesting. One is how effectively it delivers a seamless content and apps experience across its screens, using Xbox and SkyDrive to facilitate ‘ integration at code level is not enough, cloud leadership depends on seamlessness, Amazon-style. Another is whether Microsoft wean enough people away from the Android/iOS norms towards the very different Metro UI, even as it labors under the ‘Windows’ name and all its associations with compromised user experience? That, in turn, will rely on execution ‘ delivering on the promises of a strong apps base; exploiting partnerships like Nokia Navteq and adding more, even perhaps Amazon itself; turning out desirable devices, whether under Microsoft’s Surface brand or from OEMs. The bare essentials are in place, but Microsoft has a mountain to climb here, even in its PC heartland where users finally glimpse an escape route towards new form factors, touchscreens and different UIs. The good news is that consumers will have a real choice now, rather than being pushed from the Windows frying pan into the fire of an Android/iOS duopoly.
Microsoft has been putting the building blocks together all year, but now it has finally unveiled its make-or-break bid to rule the multiscreen world of computing, cloud and content. It has taken years to recognize that this world needs a unified software platform and user interface just as the PC market did ‘ but that unified experience must span all kinds of devices and screens, and must be a radical step forward from Windows and the monolithic display/keyboard design. Microsoft has responded at last. It is too late in the game to achieve PC-style dominance, but it has innovated sufficiently to be a major force in the ‘post-PC’ environment, capable of squeezing iOS. It may have clung to the Windows name, but the user experience of Windows8/Windows Phone 8 is a radical step forward from their predecessors, and even from the Android/iOS norms. And it comes with optimized hardware and multiscreen content ‘ the Xbox consoles and increasingly important media brand, and the new Surface tablet, which is likely to spawn further gadgets.
Microsoft’s big challenge now is to avoid the mistakes of the past and keep evolving. If its new platform gains significant market share, and it survives the perils of competing with its own OEMs and splitting its apps base between two architectures, it must not think the job is done for a few years, as it did with Windows, Office and other successes. Google made its name, in the early days, for being in a state of ‘continuous evolution’, and that remains essential in the cloud-focused world (though Google under Larry Page shows fewer signs of sticking to that mantra).
Microsoft must recognize that Windows 8 is a response to current assumptions about the mobile and multiscreen experience. It may take a few steps forward but it will soon be outmoded itself by emerging platforms fully based on the browser and cloud services. Many companies are trying to be the one to define that user experience, even if it will be years before the mass market is mainly doing everything online and doing away with fat local memories and applications. Google itself is making the attempt with Chrome OS, into which it can fold Android as the need arises. Mozilla, Facebook, even HP’s webOS are contenders, and others are sure to emerge. Microsoft, like Apple, needs to prepare for life in the cloud, and we would hope that both vendors, when they next update their platforms, will show clearer steps to evolve them towards the next generation of web usage and devices.
For now, though, it has a striking new platform to show off, spanning hardware, OS, content and multiple screens. There were few new features left to unveil on the day that W8 made their official debut – after a string of previews this year – so much was left to hyperbole, with CEO Steve Ballmer saying the new OS was ‘the biggest product we’ve ever done’ and Windows president Steve Sinofsky adding that the company ‘shunned the incremental’ with this release.
With the Surface tablet also becoming official, Ballmer confirmed the firm planned other devices to showcase its new operating system(s). Like Google, it is set to create a range of different form factors from smartphones to TVs, though initially it has focused on trying to position its Surface tablets in a new niche.
Apple also tried this with its new iPad mini, pricing and sizing it somewhat above the 7-inch players like Nexus 7 and Kindle Fire and seeking to carve out a distinctive ‘in-between’ segment. Microsoft also wants to be ‘in-between’, in this case saying Surface is neither a PC nor and iPad. It is very questionable whether such a nascent market can bear so much often semantic subdivision, and in reality users will judge more simply ‘ by whether they get a good experience at the right level of price and portability for them.
Apple CEO Tim Cook dismissed the Surface as a ‘flying car’, saying: ‘I suppose you could design a car that flies and floats, but I don’t think it would do all of those things very well.” At the launch, Sinofsky said Surface was not really a tablet in the iPad sense, but was more geared to content creation and documents, like a PC, because of the keyboard. “Is it a tablet? Is it a laptop? What category does it go in?’ he asked.
Some analysts were buying the argument. Michael Gartenberg of Gartner told CNet: “Surface is a different vision of computing than we’ve seen from Apple. Surface is a new category of device. It’s Microsoft’s vision of computing evolved.”
Others see the Surface as a bold attempt to seize back the initiative in ‘post-PC’ and change the assumptions people have about tablets, just as the Metro user interface seeks to do that for an iOS/Android-obsessed mobile base. Reinvention and new approaches are always welcome in enriching the consumer experience in general, but it is doubtful whether Microsoft is really the company to lead that, given its close associations with legacy systems, unfriendly UIs and a clinging to past glories. However, it really does have vision this time around, and so perhaps a new-look Microsoft will emerge, and convince the developer and user bases too.
Microsoft chairman Bill Gates was taking a more homogeneous view of the world, and a more relevant one in terms of how the post-PC market will develop ‘ driven by users gaining an appealing and consistent experience across many devices, not by the design minutiae of each model. Gates said in an interview that Windows would end up in a ‘single platform’, providing a common OS for PC, mobile, TV and phone. That seemed to confirm what has always been logical since Microsoft introduced the Metro user interface and started talking about multiscreen ‘ that Windows 8, RT and Phone will soon converge into a single system again.
This is why Windows Phone 8, whose official debut came a few days after that of its big brother, is more significant than it would be merely in the mobile world, where its predecessor has such a small presence. But in the multiscreen world, it is an important player and will eventually converge with W8. Windows Phone is no longer presented as a standalone mobile platform ‘ a sector in which Microsoft has comprehensively failed ‘ but as a key part of the multi-device strategy embracing PCs, Xbox and the cloud. There is increasing harmonization with ‘grown-up Windows’ ‘ WP8 and W8 share the Metro user interface framework and code base, a change which means the new mobile OS has no backwards compatibility with WP7, to the consternation of owners of Nokia’s current Lumia models.
But corporate VP Joe Belfiore was keen to tout WP8 as ‘the perfect companion for your Windows devices and your Xbox’, all linked by the Skydrive cloud storage platform, which allows for syncing and sharing of content. He commented: ‘This is the first cloud service that fully integrates and syncs your Office documents, so you can access them from any of your devices.’
There was actually more meat at this launch than at W8’s – Microsoft has been learning lessons from Apple’s iOS launch tactics, WP8 months ago to stir developer interest, but keeping some key features back for the full debut with handsets.
Among the new capabilities are Data Sense, which seeks to address the strain on mobile data networks intelligently and therefore improve the user experience ‘ and appeal to mobile carriers. This feature uses compression techniques to minimize data traffic loads and to offload to Wi-Fi where this is appropriate. It also automatically adjusts usage when a customer is close to his or her data limit.
These kind of features will be critical in consolidating Microsoft’s bid to be the ‘cellco’s friend’, providing a counterweight against Apple and Google, but also making devices which are kinder to cellular systems ‘ once RIM’s trump card in attracting carrier support for its network friendly handsets. Data Sense will be implemented in partnership with operators, the first public one being Verizon Wireless, which will support it in early 2013.
The main changes in WP8 on the hardware side are support for multicore processors, removable storage and three screen resolutions (800×480, 1280×768, and 1280×720).
It also sports a new start screen, which allows users to resize Live Tiles adn see more interactive ones. The increasing integration with the vital Xbox brand is see in an enhanced Music and Video Hub, now with full support for Xbox Music and its own microSD option. Users can also connect to a Windows PC and browse internal and microSD card storage directly with the File Explorer. There are also improvements to Games Hub, including in-game purchase support, and Xbox SmartGlass.
The app store has also been revamped and is now called Windows Phone Store rather than Marketplace. It has new ways to browse for apps, new payment options, plus cloud back-up and reinstall. Microsoft has added a Wallet which can store debit, credit, loyalty and membership cards on the phone, like Apple’s PassBook, and will support NFC applications on relevant phones. Microsoft’s key alliances come into play in much improved Maps, courtesy of Nokia, and fully integrated Skype.
Another new feature shown off by Belfiore was Kid’s Corner, a ‘worry-free way to share your phone with your kids’ by limiting the functions available to prevent accidental misuse; and Rooms, which enables users to create private groups in which to share information. Microsoft will make some of its innovations available on other platforms too, indicating its recent conversion to multi-platform software ‘ an acknowledgement that it will never again be able to dominate the OS to the same extent as Windows did in PCs.
Some elements of the Windows Phone presentation have not changed. Microsoft is still promoting its distinctive tiles-based user interface as a much-needed alternative user experience, to the norms set by iOS and Android. Belfiore said: ‘I would say that the state of the art in the core smartphone experience hasn’t really evolved much in the five years since its inception. If you think about the predominant user experience on most of the smartphones people are using today, it was standardized by Apple and the iPhone, and essentially that same interface was copied by Android and Android phones, and it really hasn’t evolved all that much. The static grid of icons has been the standard on smartphones.’
Microsoft concentrated on US carrier support at the launch event, with existing flagwaver AT&T planning to launch devices from various vendors, along with Verizon Wireless and T-Mobile USA. “Our hardware partners are all in,” Ballmer said. “Verizon, AT&T, and T-Mobile here in the US are all in.”
AT&T will launch the Nokia Lumia 920 and 820 and the HTC Windows Phone 8X in November; T-Mobile will release the $99 Lumia 810 and $149 8X; and Verizon will offer a customized version of the Nokia flagship, the Lumia 822, plus the 8X. It will also add a Samsung model, the Ativ Odyssey (a variant of the Ativ S) in December. The three vendors’ WP8 handsets were all previewed in the summer and LG, ZTE and others are expected to join the platform too.
Verizon’s conversion is significant to market share in the important US market, especially for Nokia, which has noted that one factor behind its adoption of WP8 was to leverage Microsoft’s far higher brand profile in north America. However, Ballmer was quiet about international roll-out plans. In the WP7 era, Verizon only offered one handset, the HTC Trophy but the carrier’s senior executives have been vocal about the need for a ‘third way’ to balance iOS and Android, heavily hinting that WP8 should fill that role.
While significant progress has been made, there are two obvious risks in Microsoft’s strategy to steal a march on Apple and Google on every screen. One is whether it really can stimulate interest with its own W8 and WP8 devices. It has taken the gamble on upsetting OEMs by competing with them and getting its Surface tablet to market first. Acer has postponed its own Windows RT slate launch, saying it wants to assess the performance of Surface first; Nokia, the premier WP8 partner, has not shown any signs of leaping to WP8 or large-screen devices. Success here will rely on the Surface delivering a superior W8 experience to that of third parties, and therefore having more Apple-like magic for users. Admittedly a new approach is needed to catch consumers’ eyes and make them look again at a platform which is still saddled with the name Windows. It remains to be seen whether Surface really does a better job of changing everyone’s assumptions about the Windows experience than Acer, Dell and the others could.
The other risk lies in the shortage of apps and content relative to major rivals. Making the Xbox platform and brand the hub of the multiscreen content effort is a masterstroke but there needs to be real substance behind that. Many of the much touted bundled apps in Surface are boringly familiar ‘ Wordpad, Paint and so on, and strangely, no Windows Media Player. Many observers were disappointed that there were not more big name software houses supporting the W8 launch from day one, though some like Hulu and Netflix did turn out. But others, notably Facebook, decided not to develop for Windows at this point and of course the ARM-based RT version lacks compatibility with the legacy apps base.
While Ballmer and his team did a good job of arguing that W8/WP8 apps are now piling in, with the common code base between the platforms creating the tipping point, Microsoft needs more than a bigger tally of same-old applications and an updated Office.
It would do well to find a stand-out software partner here, and Amazon is one that comes to mind. It has supported Android of course, but in an independent way, with a user experience and app store which compete with Google’s. And several W8 and Windows RT OEMs are preloading the Kindle app on their tablets and notebooks, PC leaders HP, Lenovo, Dell, Samsung, Acer and Asus among them. The Kindle app opens the device up to the entire Amazon store and content ecosystem, and supports syncing of ebooks across many gadgets ‘ a feature which is being extended to many content types. Microsoft has already shown keen interest in this model with its investment in Amazon rival Barnes & Noble, but a close alliance with the market leader could give it something really distinctive for Windows, while striking a blow at Google too.
Microsoft sued over live tiles UI:
Microsoft has often been the aggressor in the recent wave of mobile patent wars, but this time it is on the receiving end of a lawsuit, focused on the distinctive ‘live tiles’ at the heart of the user interface for Windows 8 and Windows Phone.
SurfCast, of Portland, Maine, filed the suit on Tuesday in the US District Court for the District of Maine, and is asking for Microsoft to pay unspecified damages and legal fees. Timed just after the official coming-out of Microsoft’s two major new operating systems ‘ W8 and WP8 ‘ the suit centers on US Patent 6,724,403, titled ‘System and Method for Simultaneous Display of Multiple Information Sources’, which SurfCast was awarded in 2004.
The smaller firm says it developed the live tiles ‘ rectangular icons in the start screen which link to websites, apps and other resources, and can update dynamically ‘ back in the 1990s. Unlike icons used in older UIs like Android, iOS and older Windows releases, the tiles display constantly updated data ‘ unread emails, news alerts and so on – on the homescreen without the user having to click into the app.
In a statement, Microsoft said it was “confident” it would prove in court that SurfCast’s claims were without merit and that the giant had created a “unique user experience’. The suit highlights how much the mobile and multiscreen battle now centers on the user interface rather than underlying technology for the network or hardware.