Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 November 2012

Cook reorganizes Apple to be a normal company again

Significance: Apple CEO Tim Cook continues to come out from under Steve Jobs’s shadow and his latest assertion of independence came with his first major executive reshuffle. Most notably, this saw iOS software chief Scott Forstall depart in the wake of the Maps fiasco, as well as one of Cook’s few external hires, retail chief John Browett. Behind the drama of those oustings was a more important change, with the product groups realigned into four units which reflect Apple’s strategy for the next generation. The new structure has two roles ‘ to try to avoid some of the recent mistakes, especially in Apple’s area of weakness, in cloud services; while adapting to being a ‘normal’ company which has dangerous rivals and has to apologize for disappointing products and results every so often. But most importantly, it shows that Cook has recognized the importance of adapting more quickly to a future of multiscreen, cloud-based content and services. He has brought iOS and Mac OS X under one division; and done the same for industrial design and user interface. A new Technologies unit includes chip design, a further bid to control every aspect of the platform. And the toughest job goes to Eddy Cue, now in charge of an expanded online services business and with turning iCloud from an also-ran into the strategic linchpin Cook envisages.

Apple is a normal company again. It releases disappointing products and apologises for annoying its users, just like its competitors. It has postponed the launch of iTunes 11, wary of upsetting users with an unpolished experience as it did with Maps and even with the high profile but sometimes unreliable iCloud and Siri. It even disappoints Wall Street occasionally, admittedly with results most would kill for.

As Google and Nokia hover like vultures around the wounds inflicted by sub-standard Maps and Siri applications, and consumers express frustration at the ‘same-old’ approach of the last two iPhones, Apple CEO Tim Cook faces his hardest task ‘ to adapt to being a firm which cannot rely so heavily on ‘magic’ any more, but in the meanwhile to focus on new products which could eventually restore that magic.

That can no longer, of course, be done with the charisma of his predecessor Steve Jobs, but this is not all about the loss of a CEO with unparalleled personal market impact. The new stagnation in Apple’s product strategy stems from the Jobs era, and while the Maps fiasco was a product of a new, somewhat panicky company, it emerged from a virtually unchanged management team. That is about to change. Cook himself may have been supported as CEO because he was a safe pair of hands, steeped in Apple culture and with proven excellence in supply chain efficiency. But he now seems to have recognized that Apple cannot cling to past successes, but needs to change quite radically, in product strategy as well as external perception. He has unleashed his first major executive reshuffle, and this indicates not just the reshaping of the team to reflect his own culture and priorities, but a major rethinking of the whole Apple offering.

Cook is remaking the management team in his own image with his first major top level reshuffle since the death of founder Steve Jobs. He has created or reimagined a series of new business units, each run by Apple veterans and focused on the four key foundations of the integrated mobile model ‘ OS, online services, chips/hardware and user interface.

Most controversial is the departure of iOS software chief Scott Forstall, reportedly in the wake of the Apple Maps fiasco.

According to The Wall Street Journal, Forstall was considered a divisive figure by most Apple executives, though he had Jobs’s confidence and was sometimes regarded as his heir apparent. Apparently the last straw came when he refused to sign the latter apologizing for the flaws in Apple’s own mapping software for iOS 6, which replaced Google’s offering as the default on iDevices. That latter, acknowledging Apple’s mistakes, was seen as a key indicator of a new, more amenable culture under Cook, who has also indicated that he might pull back from some of the aggressive litigation initiated by his predecessor.

The WSJ report says: ‘Mr Forstall’s departure came after mounting tension with members of Apple’s executive ranks. For years, senior executives had complained that he wasn’t cooperative and showed off his close relationship with Mr Jobs.’ And clashes were not just over personality but strategy ‘ Forstall reportedly sent an email to members of the iOS team recently, complaining that they were not ‘working on enough big ideas in mobile software’ and worrying that Apple would struggle to compete in future. That actually echoes the thoughts of many observers after two decidedly non-radical iPhone/iOS upgrades in a row.

Forstall will be replaced by Craig Federighi in 2013. Federighi will oversee both the iOS and OS X units, indicating the increasing convergence between the mobile and desktop platforms, mirroring similar strategies at Microsoft and, to a lesser extent, Google (with Android and Chrome OS).

Recently hired SVP of retail operations, John Browett, will also leave the company after less than a year. He was also held responsible for an embarrassing Apple apology, sparked by bad public reaction to his decision to cut back on personnel in the firm’s stores ‘ a decision which was quickly reversed. Apple said it was seeking a successor though this change comes at a difficult time, in the run-up to the holiday period and when it is looking at a retail expansion in India and China. Browett was a controversial appointment from the start, coming from the UK’s electronics chain Dixons Group, which itself had gone through a series of problems.

The really interesting aspect of Cook’s plan is the creation or redefinition of product groups ‘ now comprising Online Services, Human Interface, Technologies and Software. These mirror the four key elements of the Apple platform, but the changes are instructive and indicate the firm may indeed be aware of the need to change, and particularly to evolve towards the cloud. Cook has given signs of this before ‘ he initially seemed to be putting iCloud at the very heart of the mobile strategy and accelerating the convergence of that with the Mac.

The launch of iOS 6 was somewhat disappointing in that respect, since iCloud was pushed forward far less than it needed to be, reflecting the difficult balance between embracing the new, and protecting a strong legacy built around downloads and local processing. And iCloud itself is still proving unreliable, a year after launch, with a string of outages.

But Cook’s instincts remain, and the enlarged Online Services Group will be critical. This now embraces Siri and Maps, (formerly under Forstall). Both are critical ‘ if currently very flawed ‘ elements of the broad services strategy which must be developed quickly around iCloud. This group will be run by Eddy Cue who certainly has the toughest job in Apple now. He is taking on the cloud platform which is both central to future growth, and one of the few parts of the company which has suffered more failures than successes. It is easy to forget that product disasters are not just a recent post-Jobs phenomenon. Web services have always been problematic at a company whose world view would rather stay with localized processing. MobileMe’s launch was a major failure, while the Ping social music network was killed after two years, and even the much lauded Siri is praised more for its potential than its actual performance. Yet iCloud is essential. Cook said in January: ‘It’s not just a product, it’s a strategy for the next decade.’ It enables the seamless multiscreen experience and it powers FaceTime, GameCenter, iMessage and Siri. Increasingly, those services grab the headlines, and influence users’ satisfaction levels with their iDevices, rather than the hardware features or UI. Cue, however, is well respected in many parts of the industry and used to difficult tasks, having headed many of the negotiations with record labels and other content providers for iTunes.

Meanwhile, the influential Jony Ive, head of industrial design, becomes head of the new Human Interface division, highlighting the continuing importance of the actual look and feel of the device and UI in Apple’s ‘magic’. Perhaps the most dangerous of the criticisms of recent iPhone launches was that customers would become bored of the hardware/software design in the fickle consumer electronics world ‘ and despite huge sales of the 4S and the 5, a new survey from Strategy Analytics is just one that claims customers in Europe, in particular, are starting to fall out of love with the Apple handset, with lower numbers indicating they will choose one at their next upgrade. Putting the whole interface ‘ UI and industrial design ‘ under a single executive may have hastened Forstall’s departure, since his speciality was the user interface software, but it also seems somewhat belated for a firm whose differentiation rests on an integrated hardware/software experience.

With Federighi potentially accelerating iOS/OS X convergence at the software unit, the final piece of the puzzle is hardware where Bob Mansfield, who had retired as head of hardware engineering earlier this year but was persuaded to return, will now run the Technologies unit. This now includes chip development, an increasingly important element of Apple’s differentiation, and a favorite of Cook’s because of its ability to drive supply chain efficiencies and control. However, it is also an area of risk because of the investment required, and the significant impact if anything goes wrong, either with a new design or a manufacturing partner.

In a statement, Cook said: ‘We are in one of the most prolific periods of innovation and new products in Apple’s history. The amazing products that we’ve introduced in September and October … could only have been created at Apple and are the direct result of our relentless focus on tightly integrating world class hardware, software and services.’ It is to his credit that he is thinking through the culture and structure which will deliver another generation of ‘amazing products’. But perhaps his weaknesses are showing too ‘ he is strong on structure and process, as the more streamlined organization shows, and it does better mirror the future product directions Apple must take, especially in cloud services and multiscreen experience. But he has put only solid, Jobs-era Apple veterans in charge, and his one attempt at recruiting new blood at a top level, Browett, has been a major failure. For all the successes the old guard delivered, new ideas and thinking will become necessary ‘ and of course, Cook is old guard himself. One of Jobs’s talents was to know who to listen to, even if that person was unpopular or offside. Cook runs the danger that he is still listening to Jobs’s favorites, even as the market around the iDevices is changing by the day.

Apple disappoints on profit and iPads:

Apple had a mixed fiscal fourth quarter, beating Wall Street forecasts on revenue but not on profits or iPad sales.

The company reported revenue of $36bn and profits of $8.2bn, or $8.67 per share, while analysts had expected, on average, $35.8bn in sales and earnings per share of $8.75. Apple’s own forecasts were $34bn and $7.65.

“We’re very proud to end a fantastic fiscal year with record September quarter results,” CEO Tim Cook said in a statement. “We’re entering this holiday season with the best iPhone, iPad, Mac and iPod products ever, and we remain very confident in our new product pipeline.”

Apple sold 26.9m iPhones, exceeding Wall Street’s forecast of 25m, and up 58% year-on-year, despite supply constraints affecting the new iPhone 5. The firm would not disclose how many of the total were the new model, which was only on sale for nine days before the quarter ended on September 30. The iPad sold 14m units, well below the 17m-18m anticipated by analysts.

Non-US sales made up 60% of total revenues, 3% less than in the year-ago quarter. Apple offered a conservative forecast for the current holiday quarter, at $52bn in revenue and earnings of $11.75 per share, also below Wall Street hopes.

CFO Peter Oppenheimer said that there had been 190m sign-ups for iCloud a year after its introduction, while Cook added that 1.3m Apple TVs shifted in the quarter, making a total of over 5m for the fiscal year, the product’s best performance to date.