The world of TDD spectrum and technologies has been in flux ever since WiMAX lost its bid to be the only standard in unpaired frequencies in the face of the rise of LTE ‘ complete with the previously neglected TDD flavor. The story is well known ‘ the initial Intel-driven push behind WiMAX as the first 4G platform; followed by the mobile industry marshalling its forces to accelerate LTE progress and put its weight behind TD-LTE too. That saga came to its logical conclusion this week when the WiMAX Forum confirmed that it would embrace other air interfaces such as TD-LTE in its future architecture. But that does not mean plain sailing for the newer standard. Although definitely entering the mainstream as a future option for many carriers, not just those migrating from WiMAX, it is less developed than its FDD cousin in terms of device ecosystem and equipment cost. Those will develop as critical mass is reached, but that goal received a setback this week when two major adopters pushed back their plans.
Aircel in India will not deploy TD-LTE until next year, while Clearwire has been forced to reduce some of its roll-out targets. Aircel is unlikely to start launching 4G services until into its next fiscal year, which starts on April1 2013. According to local media, the main reason is regulatory uncertainty, particularly about the date and prices for auction of the more mainstream FD-LTE spectrum in the digital dividend band. Another contributor is ongoing industry upheaval amid events like the re-auction of GSM spectrum (some of which could potentially be refarmed for LTE) and the looming end of domestic roaming charges.
It seems that Aircel wants to assess the impact of all these changes on its business case before going ahead in its BWA spectrum. Rival Bharti Airtel has already switched on some TD-LTE services, while Reliance Infotel is the only carrier with national holdings in the BWA band and is seen as the most important short term driver for the TDD technology, in volume terms, after China Mobile and Clearwire.
The latter will not be contributing as much to TD-LTE build-out and subscriber growth as anticipated though, at least in the near term. The operator has radically reduced the number of 4G cell sites it plans to have in commercial operation next summer because of decline in its wholesale business ‘ following the defection of cableco partner/investors Comcast and Time Warner Cable to a Verizon LTE deal ‘ and sluggish performance in its retail services.
Clearwire will now install only 2,000 TD-LTE base stations by the end of June 2013, well down on the planned total of 5,000. This will reduce costs by staggering the build-out, but will slow the transition from the current WiMAX network to TD-LTE, planned for key urban customer bases, putting Clearwire at a competitive disadvantage given the rapid expansion of rival 4G offerings. However, the revised schedule will reduce Clearwire’s costs and “better align capex with the expected receipt of LTE revenues” from Sprint, the main wholesale customer (and majority stakeholder), Clearwire said in its quarterly filing.
The reduced number of TD-LTE cell sites will not affect the prepayment Sprint has promised to Clearwire for rolling out the service, it added. The big hope now, for Clearwire, will be that Japan’s Softbank, which is purchasing a 70% stake in Sprint, will also acquire, or inject cash into, the 4G joint venture once its Sprint deal is approved. Softbank also has a TD-LTE network in Japan and has joined various device and roaming initiatives with China Mobile and Clearwire, to stimulate the TD-LTE ecosystem. The firm will be disappointed if the second largest TD-LTE operator pulls back on its plans.
“It does preserve our cash, but it makes certain that we don’t build well in advance of the revenue stream,” Clearwire CEO Erik Prusch said on his firm’s earnings call. He indicated how tightly the company’s plans are tied to Sprint’s decisions after the loss of the cablecos and amid slow progress in its own-brand offerings. Sprint plans to have dual-mode LTE data devices available in Q212, which will support its own FD-LTE network and Clearwire’s system, and will add smartphones in the third quarter. “So what we’re doing is pacing the build alongside with that,” Prusch said. With the launch of its own LTE offer, Sprint has cut back on supporting dual-mode WiMAX/CDMA devices, increasing pressure on Clearwire.
In Q312, Clearwire reduced its losses from continuing operations to $320m while sales slipped to $313.8m from $332m last year on a 15% decline in wholesale revenue. Clearwire lost 489,000 wholesale customers, and wholesale churn more than trebled to 5.4%, from 1.5% last year. Retail churn was also worse, at 5.1%, though the company added a net 21,000 retail subscribers.
These setbacks are not fatal, but they do postpone the day when there is mass availability of TDD or dual-mode devices outside the Chinese bands ‘ where of course, TD-LTE’s biggest cheerleader China Mobile is creating a volume base all by itself with its huge ‘trial’ network. And other former WiMAX players are moving quickly too, notably Yota in Russia, whose LTE network is hosting 4G services for several larger cellcos, and which has started to implement certain features of the LTE-Advanced standard. This will combine the FDD and TDD strands to a far greater extent, and introduce a broad range of new functions, many of them optional. Early adopters are particularly interested in carrier aggregation and this is the feature which Yota has deployed in selected base stations in Moscow, working with Huawei. CA is also the element on which SKT, another early mover, has concentrated as it begins to take the first steps to LTE-A.
The appearance of LTE-A will squeeze the remains of WiMAX still further in the mobile market and its trade body, the WiMAX Forum, is acknowledging the inevitability of carrier migration to LTE now. It has opened its platform to include elements of the TD-LTE standard it once sought to fight off and its ‘WiMAX Advanced’ framework will support various air interfaces. Although Declan Byrne, president of the industry body, insisted this would not ‘open the floodgates of a migration from WiMAX to other technologies’, in effect this was an acknowledgement that, at least in the core mobile broadband space, that shift is already under way.
The Forum confirmed reports that its board had unanimously approved a proposal to add TD-LTE support to the upcoming WiMAX 2.1 specifications, at a meeting a few weeks ago. That spec will be ready in draft form by year end and ratified in early 2013. The WiMAX Advanced platform will effectively provide an IP-based framework which can support multiple air interfaces including its own 802.16 and the 3GPP TD-LTE standards.
Operators with software programmable dual-mode base stations would be able to support both WiMAX and TD-LTE devices simultaneously ‘ something some carriers are already implementing, but this would allow for a standards-based approach.
The aim will be to make a dual-mode WiMAX/LTE platform simpler and more cost effective, which would prolong the opportunity for multimode device and chip suppliers and help operators to migrate in a gradual way. Currently mobile WiMAX providers are under pressure to move swiftly to LTE-only to tap into the larger device availability. However, to take advantage of the changes, they will need to have invested in flexible infrastructure with a view to eventual LTE coexistence, rather than older, single-mode kit.
WiMAX, after an early headstart, was overtaken by the huge mobile industry weight behind LTE. As long as five years ago, the Forum was reaching out to the 3GPP about greater convergence, and some basic similarities between the standard and the TDD flavour of LTE has allowed vendors to create flexible base stations, and help operators make relatively smooth transitions to the newer platform and its wider ecosystem. The significant opportunities for WiMAX now lie outside the mobile world, in vertical sectors such as smart grid and aviation, and in its traditional sphere of fixed wireless access.
The Forum’s latest move would eventually allow WiMAX base stations to support LTE, though standardization is likely to come largely after the horse has bolted. Major Mobile WiMAX flagwavers like Yota in Russia, Clearwire in the US and Packet One in Malaysia have already embarked on LTE coexistence and migration programs and the first two aim to start introducing LTE-Advanced at an early stage (Yota is already supporting some elements of LTE-A in selected base stations).
‘There is a fair amount of political freight along with this decision,’ Byrne told WirelessWeek. ‘What we don’t want to suggest is this announcement is opening the floodgates of a migration from WiMAX to other technologies.’
The WiMAX Forum has largely stopped discussing the next generation of its standard, 802.16m or WiMAX2, but it is promoting the WiMAX Advanced extension to its platform as well as specialized subsets of the standard tailored for key markets like the utilities (WiGrid). WiMAX Advanced focuses on a more generic IP broadband data framework which can embrace various radio access methods including 802.16 and the 3GPP and potentially 802.11 standards.
‘WiMAX has always stood for innovation, open standards and low IPR costs,’ Forum chairman Mo Shakouri said in a statement, ‘Our focus is to preserve these fundamental values of the WiMAX Forum and continue to build a powerful and broad ecosystem that addresses the needs of operators and customers worldwide.’