Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 November 2012

Report questions economic benefits of UK LTE

The UK’s first mainstream LTE roll-out is proving to be one of the most controversial to date, and two days after services went live, EE’s service is facing further criticism.

A new report from The Economist’s influential Intelligence Unit questions EE’s claims for the returns and economic benefits of its early deployment. The study argues that existing 3G+ networks will be capable of delivering many of the new services promised for LTE for at least a few more years. And it points out various obstacles which will limit the advantage to be gained from 4G in the early days ‘ from skill shortages to user resistance against change.

The UK got its second LTE service, and its first from a major cellco, on October 30, when EE (formerly Everything Everywhere, formerly Orange + T-Mobile) switched on 4G service in 11 major cities. The launch has been dogged with controversy, initially because EE was allowed to refarm its 1.8GHz GSM spectrum, giving it a headstart over major rivals Vodafone and O2, whose 2G networks are in 900MHz and which have to wait until next spring’s spectrum auction to be able to start rolling out LTE.

Then EE took advantage of its first mover advantage to launch with unpopularly high tariffs, starting at £36 a month with a 500Mbytes monthly cap (a trivial amount on a 4G network), and with no unlimited options or fully subsidized handsets. Capital London has the best coverage in the first stage and EE will spend £1.5bn to extend the network by 2,000 square miles a month, including 16 cities by the end of this year.

Vodafone responded to the launch with an aggressive advertising campaign touting the quality of its 3G networks and indoor coverage, and questioning whether EE customers would get good reception inside. O2 took a different tack, with its COO Derek McManus offering ‘congratulations to Olaf’ (Swantee, EE’s CEO), and calling it a ‘major step forward for mobile’. The initial EE LTE devices are the iPhone 5 and a total of six smartphones from Nokia, Huawei, and Samsung.

Back at The Economist, the EIU’s director of global technology research, Denis McCauley, said in a statement: ‘Over time, superfast broadband [LTE and fiber] will undoubtedly provide a platform for numerous positive changes in the life of the nation. A dose of reality is in order, however, about the scale of the impact in the shorter term. For many anticipated benefits, it is less about building bigger pipes and more about the need for established systems, processes and skills to evolve.’

The report, sponsored by Huawei (actually the supplier of EE’s network), backs up some of the claims which EE deployed aggressively when lobbying to be allowed to switch on LTE ahead of its rivals. 4G as well as fiber will deliver new growth and jobs, but the study argues that this impact will not match that of the switch from dial-up to broadband, at least in the near term.

In the short term, there will be a boost to jobs as network build-out accelerates, but high speed connectivity is not enough, on its own, to transform healthcare and education services ‘ these will also require reforms of processes and regulations in those sectors.