Significance: While Apple and Samsung may battle it out largely on conventional lines ‘ mobile device market share and profits ‘ the former is also engaged in a deadly stand-off with Google (and increasingly Amazon) to drive the whole multiscreen user experience. Dictating terms for the user experience, as the two giants did in the current smartphone generation, enabled them to set the mobile agenda and build businesses around integrated apps and content. Now they need to repeat the trick across multiple screens, taking into account the shift to the cloud, as well as the rising importance of previously neglected emerging markets. This will mean a greater variety of devices to capture different user profiles and price points, but an increasingly uniform user experience spanning handsets, tablets, PCs and TVs. To launch the quest for the new web platform, and to squeeze out Microsoft and the looming Windows 8, Google is expanding its Nexus range and partnerships, as well as breathing new life into Chrome, its bid for the next generation ‘PC’. Meanwhile, Apple has added a mini-tablet and moved away from its one-product tradition in the larger iPad too. The coming year will see even more diversity of devices, as the companies try to succeed in the difficult balancing act between margin, market share and platform control.
It’s the time of year when companies race to unveil new devices for the holiday season, but this time, the beauty contest has significance beyond just the hoped-for seasonal sales boost. With Microsoft’s Windows 8 and Surface tablet looming, Apple and Google seemed to be engaged not just in their usual head-to-head, but a pincer movement to minimize the opportunity for W8 in the mobile space. Both giants are diversifying their device ranges to steal market share from one another and to leave slim pickings for Surface or the upcoming tablets running Windows RT. Apple launched not just the expected iPad mini, but an upgraded full-sized iPad, indicating a change in its product cycle aimed at maintaining volumes even as Android competition mounts and the most credible challenge ever from Microsoft lurks. Google, too, is spreading its net wide, ramping up its previously niche Nexus family as well as getting aggressive about its Chromebook platform. The only mystery is how its actual handset subsidiary, Motorola Mobility, will fit into this aim of becoming a true hardware vendor and delivering a multiscreen experience to rival those of Apple and Amazon.
Of course, it is this multiscreen platform which will really decide success or failure in the web. For now at least, most companies seem to have decided that there are benefits to adopting Apple’s stance of controlling the hardware as well as the software. Amazon, Google and even Microsoft have gone that way, creating difficult balances for themselves with device partners, and others like Facebook could follow. But the real challenge is to woo customers to the user experience, preferably one which spans every device they ever use in a consistent way, and drives the consumer to make more purchases and/or respond to more adverts. The precise business model balance will vary ‘ in particular how profit is split between the gadgets themselves and the services they enable ‘ but the war is for the UE.
In that context, the new Chromebook is more important for Google than the new Nexus models it is expected to launch next week. The search giant showed off an aggressively priced new version of its ‘cloudbook’, made by Samsung and selling for $249. Apart from the price, the important change was that, like Android products, the device now has access to the Google Play store. This fits with Google’s ongoing moves to converge its two operating systems, Android and Chrome OS (for instance, their respective browsers are harmonizing, and now there is a common app store).
Google explicitly said it wanted to control all a user’s screens with a single experience, and
converging the two OSs ‘ mobile, download-focused Android and cloud-based Chrome OS ‘ improves its proposition, by supporting a common interface and set of services whether users prefer web or conventional software.
The strategy is also, of course, enhanced greatly by a highly affordable Chromebook. These devices, a modern take on the old ‘thin client’ idea, have attracted interest but limited sales, partly because they have sold in the same price range as high end tablets or midrange notebooks. AT that price, users and even enterprises have failed to fall for the charms of the model which puts nearly all the applications and storage in the cloud, accessible via the browser.
But the new price tag could encourage customers to experiment with the still embryonic cloud-only approach, buying a Chromebook as an additional device or instead of a tablet ‘ another form factor which many regarded only as ‘nice to have’ until they could be bought for $199 (soon to be $99, if Google releases its rumored entry level Nexus slate).
The 11.6-inch Chromebook is co-branded with its manufacturer Samsung, and like the Samsung Series 5 550, released in May, it runs the second generation of Chrome OS and increases the processing power compared to first wave models. The latest device is slimmer and lighter than its predecessor, clearly targeting the MacBook Air, which is the most popular ultra-portable notebook product, though more conventional than the Chromebook with local apps and storage. If the new pricing, and the promise of aggressive retail marketing, does give the Google platform the fillip it needs, it could woo buyers from tablets and also from Intel’s preferred design for the hybrid market, the ultrabook. It strikes a blow at the x86 giant in another way too, by using an ARM-based processor (previous models used x86).
Google, never one to underplay its hand, proclaimed: “It’s the best computer that’s ever been designed at this price point,” as Sundar Pichai, SVP for Chrome and Google Apps, put it. He added: “We are going to take more of an active presence in the market.We believe we have a device for the mainstream. You’ll also see us run a marketing campaign like we’ve done with Chrome.”
CEO Larry Page enlarged on the broader strategy during the earnings call, saying that the search giant aimed to deliver common content and ad serving tools, under a seamless user experience, across every screen a user may have. Increasingly, of course, Google is also designing those screens itself, via its Chromebook and Nexus partners and its Motorola subsidiary.
It will need to keep the impetus behind Nexus now that the initial 7-inch tablet has a direct challenge from Apple ‘ and at the iPad mini launch, executives lost no opportunity to scoff at the Google rival, claiming that class of slate did not showcase applications well or provide sufficient real screen space. And of course, Google is likely to take on Apple on other fronts soon, notably with a larger tablet.
The Nexus co-branded family is changing its role significantly ‘ from a niche device, released one at a time and mainly to showcase the latest Android enhancements to developers; to a mass market range with multiple models and screen sizes, and a selection of manufacturing partners. Away from Motorola, which recently launched a new Intel-based flagship, the RAZR i, Google is reported to be launching a new Nexus handset and large-screened tablet, both of which will showcase the new Android release, 4.2, as will an upgraded Nexus 7. Like Apple, it knows it needs to have more form factors and price levels as it moves out of a premium sector into the mass market and looks to drive Android upgrades and related services with its own muscle, not just relying on sometimes overly independent licensees.
This will be the first time that Google has launched three models simultaneously and it will be tapping into the talents of its partners ‘ the Samsung Nexus 10 is reported to have a higher resolution display than the iPad for instance.
Insiders claim the new OS release will not yet be a full new version, codenamed Key Lime Pie, but an interim update, Android 4.2+ (or JellyBean+). The devices are expected to be the Nexus 10, a high end tablet made by Samsung and based on the Galaxy Tab 10.1; a new Nexus 7, made by Asus; and LG’s first handset for Google, the Nexus 4. Samsung has been the primary Nexus smatphone partner in recent years though HTC made the original one and Sony and ZTE have both recently been rumored as possible additional recruits. Spreading the favors widely would help to keep key Android OEMs onside as well as creating a wide range of products with limited R&D cost (since they are usually just variants of an existing model, but tapping into Google’s brand, its latest OS updates, and its particular user experience).
Notable by its absence so far is Google’s own handset unit Motorola Mobility, no doubt to reassure other OEMs that there will be no favouritism. However, in the medium term, if Google intends to keep its hardware subsidiary intact, it will make no sense to deny itself the control and economies of its own phonemaker.
It certainly needs to accelerate its review of the future of Motorola ‘ whether that will entail selling on the hardware elements, keeping the patents and design teams but continuing to rely on multiple manufacturers for Nexus; or streamlining the firm aggressively to dilute the drag on profits that has come from taking on a device company. In the third quarter, Motorola pulled down its parent’s results and helped drive the stock down by 8% on the announcement. The handset arm posted a $505m operating loss in the mobile sector in the third quarter, compared to an operating loss of $41m a year earlier, and its revenues were $2.58bn, below analysts’ estimates of $3.3bn. Unit sales fell about 26% year-on-year.
No such problems will beset Apple when it announces its quarterly results on Thursday, though with supply constraints possibly keeping the iPhone 5 from fulfilling its potential, some analysts are surprisingly negative. And undoubtedly, while the firm will doubtless deliver results which will be the envy of any other device maker, it does have challenges ahead to maintain its market share, its famous margins and its quality of experience simultaneously. The first of these was not initially a goal for the iDevices, which stayed in the premium category, but has become so since the iPhone 4 made its debut, and now with the iPad mini. Growth and continuing influence for iOS and iTunes will rely on penetrating the growth engine markets of Asia, and that will need new price points, distribution strategies and features, hence Apple’s move to diversify its range, hoping to launch mass market products while keeping the cachet of the top end products.
It did that successfully, years ago, with the iPod, but then adopted a rigid single-product approach for the iPhone and iPad. Now it will look to repeat the iPod effect with its wireless offerings, possibly signalling the arrival of a lower end iPhone next year, and the move to offering two or more new handsets per year. Of course, the risk in that ‘ even for a firm with such deep pockets as Apple ‘ is that quality and brand power become diluted and profits are squeezed. And the company has a particularly tough job on its hands because it has a head-on battle on two very different fronts. One is with Google and Amazon, which involves selling large numbers of devices mainly to generate content and services sales and promote a user experience. The other is with Samsung, which despite its software and media moves is all about vast hardware sales, and a constant rebalancing of volume versus margin, a process at which the Korean vendor has become uniquely skilled. These three monsters, each with their own strengths, plus a possibly rejuvenated Microsoft, put an awful lot of competitive burden on the small Apple family of mobile devices.
For now, experimenting with product tiers is confined to the tablets. Apple unveiled the iPad mini, as widely expected, but had a surprise up its sleeve with an upgraded full-size iPad too. The 7.9-inch version of the iPad was launched by CEO Tim Cook, and the scornful comments of some executives about the Google Nexus 7 left no doubt about Apple’s primary target in launching a smaller tablet. However, Apple is not going head-to-head with Google – or the other main small-sized slate maker, Amazon ‘ in pricing. While those vendors offer a $199 model (and Google is rumored to be preparing a $99 entry level Nexus, while the older Kindle Fire is $159), the iPad mini will be priced from $329 to $659.
That sees Apple trying to define a new sub-segment of the market it largely created in the first place ‘ a device sufficiently modest not to cannibalize iPad HD sales significantly, but keeping the vendor out of the tablet price war. It is risky to segment such a new market so precisely at this early stage but if Apple is right, it will be able to convert a higher percentage of iOS enthusiasts to spending the money on a tablet.
It will be relying on iPod touch upgraders and first time tablet buyers who always wanted an iPad but were deterred by the cost, or by the less than portable size. This will be a large sector, given how many people do not yet have a tablet, but the pricing is still challenging for those not in love with iOS ‘ but to take it any lower, Apple would be risking a big dent in its margins.
The bigger challenge, of course, will be to lure those who have not previously succumbed to the iOS experience and so will not see the need to pay a premium for that, but will instead opt for a lower cost Nexus or Kindle Fire. Each successive iPhone generation has relied more than the last on upgrading the existing base ‘ a natural enough progression, but one to be avoided when the iPad is still at such an early stage, which is why the rival devices are dangerous.
And apart from price, many are wedded to the Nexus (for the pure Android experience) or the Kindle Fire (for Amazon Prime and the addictive content consumption) and would be hard to lure to a different platform. Certainly, Apple has taken on a difficult balancing act ‘ discounting the budget sector, and the aficionados of Android and Kindle, while trying not to attract customers away from the full-sized iPad.
Some analysts are not convinced the firm has got the balance right. Two Apple watchers, Bill Choi of Janney Capital Markets, and Gene Munster of Piper Jaffray, think the new device will cannibalize large iPad sales ‘ Choi to the tune of 15%, Munster 20%. Choi predicts total iPad sales of 25.5m for Q412,with 6m being mini models. One million of those, he thinks, will go to users who would otherwise have purchased a larger slate.
That still means incremental sales of 5m units and Choi recently upped his iPad sales forecast for fiscal 2013, which began on September 30, to 102m units, from 82.2m, nearly a 25% increase. For the full fiscal year, he predicts Apple will sell 32m iPad minis and 70m larger models with the average selling price dropping to $480 from $521 across the year. Meanwhile, Munster thinks the small tablet could account for 5% of Apple’s sales in fiscal 2013, and that the vendor will sell 5m minis in the current quarter, reducing iPad HD sales by 20%.
It is clear that all the big mobile guns ‘ Apple, Google, Samsung and increasingly Amazon and Microsoft ‘ will be making a series of trade-offs and calculated risks in the coming year. None has the power to dictate the way the multiscreen experience evolves on its own, but each will need to maximize its influence, and that will partly rely on massive device sales. We can expect more form factors and segmentation in the months ahead, and a renewed focus on non-mobile screens such as ultraslim notebooks, TVs and cars.
The new iPads:
Analysts believe Apple’s entry into the 7-inch tablet space will, by itself, significantly expand that segment. Its move will help double the size of this category to about 34m units this year, predicts IHS ISuppli. Apple may sell 5m to 7m of the smaller iPads by year end, Brian Walker of Topeka Capital Markets told Bloomberg. Another researcher, NPD DisplaySearch, predicts the total slate market will more than double to $162bn in the next five years. Apple said it had sold more than 100m iPads since the first one launched in January 2010.
The new device is about half the weight of the iPad 2 at 0.68 pounds, and 7.2 millimeters thick, with battery life of 10 hours. The product runs on a dual-core A5 processor but has a lower resolution screen than its larger stablemate (1024 x 768 pixels). Other specifications include 802.11a/b/g/n Wi-Fi; a FaceTime HD front camera and 5-megapixel iSight rear camera; Lightning connector; Smart Covers; and LTE options. Orders will start on October 26 and the Wi-Fi models will start shipping on November 2, with cellular versions to follow later.
Its debut shows Cook’s Apple moving out of the shadow of founder Steve Jobs, who had thrown cold water on the smaller tablet size, saying in 2010: ‘This size isn’t sufficient to create great tablet apps, in our opinion.’ It emerged during the Samsung patents trial in San Jose that other executives had tried to change Jobs’s mind on this point.
Apple’s marketing chief, Phillip Schiller, took a shot at other mini-slates. “Others have tried to make smaller tablets, but they’ve failed,” he said, showing a photo of the Nexus 7, while also highlighting the advantages of the App Store and iTunes platform, with 700,000 iOS apps, and 275,000 iPad-specific offerings. He said the new device’s size gave it 35% more display real estate than the Nexus 7 and is actually 67% larger in landscape mode for browser use.
More surprisingly, Schiller also showed off a fourth generation full-sized iPad, which supports more LTE spectrum bands as well as doubled Wi-Fi data rates, 10-hour battery life, a front camera supporting FaceTime with 720p HD video capture, and new SD and USB cables.
LG’s increases hopes of mobile turnaround:
LG’s long struggle to make an impact on the smartphone market is starting to bear fruit, and handsets were the main factor behind a solid quarter for the Korean firm. The Mobile Communications unit returned to profit in the third quarter after a Q2 loss, on a 9% rise in device shipments to total 14m.
Of course, this is a small figure compared to those of Samsung or Apple, and LG’s days of being a clear number three in the mobile market are unlikely to return. But like other former stars, such as Motorola and Sony Mobile, the firm has been refocusing on higher value devices, prioritizing quality and margin over quantity to boost profits and escape battles with low cost Chinese vendors.
This has been a difficult transition for LG, which entered the smartphone game fairly late and with decidedly midrange models, and had previously relied on featurephones, especially in CDMA, for its mobile success. However, this year it has released a string of high end and innovative devices in its Optimus range, concentrating on differentiators such as 3D and early LTE support. In Q3, the firm cited ‘healthy sales of LTE smartphones in Korea, Japan and the US’, and the 3G Optimus L model was also a strong contributor.
Looking forward, LG said it expected further gains in the current fourth quarter from the global launch of the Optimus G high end model, and from Korean sales of the Optimus Vu:2.
The Mobile Communications division reported operating profit of KRW22bn ($19.42m), compared with a year-ago loss of KRW139bn, despite higher spending on R&D and marketing to raise its smartphone profile. Mobile revenue was KRW2.45 trillion, down 11%. Within these figures, the majority – KRW21bn of profit and KRW2.42 trillion of sales – was attributed to handsets. There was a continuing decline in featurephone sales, putting more pressure on the Optimus line, which reaches from midrange to superphone devices.
LG’s mobile unit has reported operating profit in two of the year’s three quarters so far, and in Q411, which was the first quarter in the black after a long series of losses which saw the firm reportedly considering exiting the handset space.
Handset margins were 0.8%, rather than a negative 5.2% a year ago, as LG shifted to higher margin smartphones running LTE.
At a group level, the company reported its third consecutive quarter of net profit, with operating profit in all four of its units (Mobile Communications, Home Entertainment, Home Appliances, and Air Conditioning & Energy Solutions). It reported net income of KRW157bn, compared with a loss of KRW414m a year earlier, on revenue of KRW12.38 trillion, down 4%.
CFO David Jung expects a quarter-on-quarter rise in sales in Q4 though he warned that operating profit may weaken “slightly” thanks to seasonality for some products, such as air conditioners, and rising mobile marketing costs. There were also better results at LG Display.