Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 October 2012

Lumia 510: as important as the 920 flagship in turning Nokia’s fortunes

Significance: All the chatter around Nokia has centered on the high end Lumia 920, which will launch in the US soon as an AT&T exclusive. But important as it is for the Finnish firm to make an impression in the US at last, and to claw back high end handset share, these will be long processes. Its third quarter results, none of whose small positive signs related to smartphones, it was clear that short term improvements will come not from the top end, but from the firm’s more natural heartland in the midmarket, where its chief rivals are less established than in the west. It has started to fix its proposition for the high end featurephone sector, and it is seeing valuable increased contributions from non-device businesses like Navteq and even Nokia Siemens. But the critical device will be the affordable smartphone, enabling it to hold on to some of the Symbian base ‘ once 40% of the total, now dwindling rapidly ‘ and start to generate volume and cash again. Thus its latest Lumia model, the 510 – though unexciting in terms of specs and hardly attracting a whiff of publicity in the week of the iPad mini ‘ may actually turn out to be far more significant than its top end stablemate in deciding Nokia’s fortunes in the coming months.

Nokia and Microsoft are joined at the hip in the smartphone world, for better or worse, but they still have to follow other paths apart from Windows Phone, if they are not to end up squeezed into an uncomfortably tight niche together for the next two quarters. WP8 may eventually leapfrog iOS as some analysts expect, but it will be a long process, and in the meantime its two biggest supporters need other options. Microsoft’s third quarter clearly highlighted the long wait for the really important platform, Windows 8 ‘ and indeed, it will be convergence with W8 which allows its mobile cousin to fulfil its potential in future. And Nokia’s own results, in another quarter of painful transition from Symbian to the Microsoft OS, did have some hopeful signs, but none of them were in smartphones. That puts a significant burden on its latest Lumia product, the 510, which may finally give Nokia its first strong offering for several years in the critical midmarket where it should, by rights, be king.

The Finnish firm reported losses for its third quarter and warned of tough times ahead, but nonetheless, it did better than analysts had expected, and showed signs of entering a recovery phase. Building on those early green shoots, however, will rely on a far stronger performance from the Lumia family than was seen in Q3, as most of the current bright spots are coming from other activities like Asha, Navteq and even Nokia Siemens.

The Finnish giant’s loss ‘ before one-off items – of €0.07 per share reversed a year-ago profit of €0.03 but outdid consensus forecasts of a €0.11 deficit. Net loss including charges was €969m ($1.27bn), compared with a €68m loss a year ago, but less than the eye-watering €1.4bn of Q212.
The operating loss was €576m, but this figure, while huge, is on the right path ‘ in Q1 and Q2, Nokia made operating losses of €961m and €826m respectively. The improvements have been achieved mainly by a major cost cutting program, which accounted for many of the one-off charges.

The next challenge will be to head back towards profit, and to achieve that through growth in higher margin products, not just through cost reduction. That is still a rocky road. Nokia shipped 82.9m handsets in the quarter, including 6.3m smartphones, but only 2.9m of these were Lumia Windows Phone devices, a decline from about 4m in the second quarter.

This was partly to be expected ‘ the new Lumia models, including the flagship 920, came too late to impact Q3, and will not be launched by some key carriers, like AT&T, until later this month or November. Fans of Windows Phone will wait for the new products, which run the upgraded WP8 (a trend heightened by the fact that a WP7 smartphone is not upgradeable to the new OS).

However, some analysts were surprised ‘ optimistic forecasters had looked for Nokia to increase its Lumia sales despite the seasonal challenges and to top 8m units for smartphones as a whole. It is now critical for Nokia to make a strong showing with Lumia in Q4 ‘ the numbers need to instil confidence, after six straight quarters in the red, that the vendor can regain some of its old success; and they need to offset the decline in sales of legacy smartphones running Symbian, which has been quicker than Nokia management anticipated.

That will be a challenge as management acknowledges. The new devices shipped halfway through the quarter and in a crowded holiday market where, even in the WP8 niche, there are strong rival devices from Samsung and HTC. In its statement, Nokia accepts Q4 will be tough and says it expects ‘lower than normal’ benefit from the holiday season than usual.

CEO Stephen Elop said in his statement: ‘As we expected, Q3 was a difficult quarter in our Devices & Services business; however, we are pleased that we shifted Nokia Group to operating profitability on a non-IFRS basis. In Q3, we continued to manage through a tough transitional quarter for our smart devices business as we shared the exciting innovation ahead with our new line of Lumia products.’

Overall, Nokia saw handset sales fall by 22% year-on-year, though only 1% compared to Q2. This was another indication that the firm is arresting its downward slide, and also highlighted more robust performance in featurephones, a natural Nokia stronghold where, nonetheless, is has struggled in recent quarters against low cost Asian suppliers.

Revenue from handset sales fell by 34% year-on-year while overall revenue dropped by 19% to €7.24bn ($9.48bn). Sales of non-smartphones rose by 4% compared to Q2, to 77m, but this was still down 15% on the previous year. However, that was predictable and also indicates Nokia placing more focus on margin rather than volume, concentrating on its Asha range, which is a high end featurephone family, designed to bring elements of the smart web experience to low end gadgets and act as an entry point to smartphone migration down the road. Though it may be resisting trying to compete in the ultra-low cost space, there is pressure on price in every device category – average selling prices dropped to €160 from €186 per phone.

The figures are still a sad shadow of the old days, when Nokia regularly achieved 40% handset share ‘ by contrast with its 6.9m smartphone shipments, Samsung is expected to report 55m units and Apple 27m iPhones.

In other businesses, the Location & Commerce unit, based around the Navteq platform, is experiencing strong growth and a growing list of licensing partners such as Amazon, while the Nokia Siemens infrastructure joint venture had a ‘remarkable quarter’, according to Elop. Underlying operating profit at NSN jumped to €323m from €6m a year earlier, amid cost cuts and rising sales.

However, handsets remain the engine, and the pattern of the results ‘ especially the longer than hoped-for wait for Windows Phone to deliver growth ‘ only emphasize how urgently Nokia needs to reassert itself in its natural territory, the midmarket. Asha is a good proposition for the top of the featurephone space, but it has lacked a convincing offering in midrange or affordable smartphones for the past couple of years, a significant factor in its string of poor results. Now it aims to put this right with a series of lower end Lumia Windows Phone devices, starting with the 510, priced at about $199 without subsidy.

The midrange Symbian Series 60 platform has declined far more quickly than the Finnish firm had anticipated once it transferred its loyalty to Windows Phone, and WP itself has not reached down to lower price points where Android rules. Nokia has done a good job of extending the low end Series 40 system to support advanced web functionality, but it is not a full smartphone offering and in its main emerging market territories, it is under pressure from low cost Asian models.

The Lumia 510 aims to fill some of the gap and according to Nokia, meets it ‘commitment to bring Windows Phone to new, lower price points’. There has been some progress by Microsoft in this direction, largely under pressure from its main handset partner, notably with the ‘Tango’ release ofWP7. This extended the operating system to lower specified handsets ‘ Microsoft has three standard reference designs for its OS, with varying screen sizes, memory and so on, but the overwhelming focus has been on the high end.

The 510 will be firmly targeted at emerging markets although Nokia may also try to push it into prepaid sectors in Europe and even the US. Launches are expected first in India and China, followed by other Asian countries and some of Latin America. A hit in China will be particularly important ‘ the erosion of Nokia’s once-leading market share in the world’s largest smartphone market has been a major factor in recent poor quarters. The firm’s volumes in China fell by 64% year-on-year in the third quarter to 5.8m units, and revenue was down 78%. However, Lumia does not yet support China Mobile’s TD-SCDMA 3G network, excluding Nokia from the country’s largest cellco except in 2G.

The 510 represents a new entry level for Lumia, slotting in below the first midmarket model, the 610. However, it is still priced more expensively than the high end Series 40 featurephones, the Asha family, which come in around $99. It runs WP7.5 (Tango) rather than the new WP8, which is, for now at least, targeted at the high end. The challenge for Nokia is that it is building volume for the older OS, but there is no upgradeability to the new platform. The 510 runs on a Qualcomm processor with 256Mbytes of RAM, a 4-inch display and a 5-megapixel camera.

If Nokia’s results exposed the long wait for a new OS to take root, so did those of Microsoft where everything is in limbo in the wait for W8. The pressure on a successful aunch has intensified, following the lacklustre figures, with fiscal first quarter revenues falling by 22% year-on-year.

Revenue from existing Windows and Windows Live products fell, although adjusted profits topped analyst expectations. However, Microsoft is going through a challenging period when it is overhauling several key platforms at once ‘ Windows itself, Office, the IE browser, Windows Phone and its back end server software.

Continued strength in Office helped to cushion the blows to ageing Windows offerings and as so often, the productivity suite is a valuable buffer for the firm in times of transition. The shift to a new OS was combined with general softness in the PC market, as seen at Intel too, and that is putting intense focus on the ARM-based version of Windows 8, which could power a variety of ‘post-PC’ form factors such as tablets, in which Microsoft has so far been a niche player.

For the quarter ended September 30, Microsoft reported profit of $4.47bn, or 53 cents a share, down from $5.74bn, or 68 cents a share, a year earlier. The latest quarter included $1.36bn in revenue deferred for the company’s Windows upgrade offer, Windows 8 presales and Office promotion. Excluding deferred revenue, adjusted earnings were 65 cents a share. Revenue slipped 7.9% to $16.01bn. Analysts polled by Thomson Reuters had projected earnings of 56 cents a share and revenue of $16.42bn.

The Windows and Windows Live division saw revenue decline 33%, as profit slumped 50%. By contrast, revenue for the company’s servers and tools products, which underpin the enterprise and cloud businesses, rose 8% while profit climbed 12%. At the business division, which earns most of its sales from Microsoft Office, sales slipped 2.4% as profit slid 1.9%.

At the entertainment and devices unit, which houses the Xbox video game console, sales slipped by 0.8%. In online services, which includes the company’s Bing search engine, revenue jumped 8.7%.

‘The Microsoft numbers are a little worse than expected, but for Wall Street, it’s all about Windows 8,’ Mark Moerdler, an analyst at Sanford C. Bernstein, told Bloomberg. ‘These are not substantially off enough to change the fact that people are largely going to shrug it off and look towards the launch of Windows 8 to see how that goes.’

Note:
Nokia also said it plans to convert $980m worth of bonds into ordinary shares, as part of a public offering aimed at improving the company’s balance sheet. ‘This offering is designed to further strengthen our financial position and liquidity profile while allowing us to benefit from the current attractive long term financing opportunities in the convertible bond market,’ said CFO Timo Ihamuotila.

Several ratings agencies have downgraded Nokia’s debt to near junk status over the past year, and the company has seen its cash mountain eroded by falling profits ‘ its recent Q3 figures were its sixth consecutive quarter in the red, and the firm reported about $5bn in net cash reserves, down 30% year-on-year. Net losses were $1.2bn on $9.5bn in revenue, down 19% on the previous year.