Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 October 2012

Ballmer and Cook: both need to discover their innovative streak

Significance: Apple, despite its massive sales and market value, is no longer untouchable in the mobile world, and there is rising frustration that it is not innovating at its old rate. Recent iPhones have been step upgrades which did not move the goalposts, and while there is good reason to stick to a winning formula, the downside is falling confidence in the firm’s ability to be radical. That is reinforced to the transition to a world after Steve Jobs, since his successor Tim Cook has none of the founder’s charisma or focus on design. However, he has equally important talents for mobile success, notably supply chain genius, and now needs to prove to the markets that Apple can still rethink design and user experience norms even without Jobs. Meanwhile, as Apple reflected on what it had lost on the anniversary of Jobs’ untimely death, Microsoft is having less kind thoughts about its CEO Steve Ballmer. Ballmer saw his bonus cut because of poor performance in mobile and online businesses and there is a rising feeling that he has only one more chance to prove that he does have real innovation in him. His response is to promise a ‘new era’ at Microsoft, one based on ‘devices and services’ not software alone. That is hardly innovative ‘ it is basically a copy of Apple’s model, which Google and Amazon are chasing, and Microsoft faces bigger hurdles than any of them in executing effectively. Ballmer’s challenge now is to be creative in how he delivers the new vision, outpacing rather than copying Apple, and in particular, attacking the TV weaknesses of its two main rivals.

On the one-year anniversary of Steve Jobs’ death, it was natural for analysts, and Apple executives, to consider how the firm had changed since. There are certainly signs of new approaches and culture, but while some cling to Jobs’ memory and resent any changes his successor Tim Cook may make, there is a stronger and less sentimental tide of belief that Cook needs to innovate more quickly. Sticking too long with a formula, however successful, is dangerous in the rapidly changing world of mobile and multiscreen web, and despite the undoubted record breaking success awaiting iPhone 5, the vulnerabilities are starting to appear. Cook’s burden is that they will be blamed on him, even though most date back to Jobs’s own decisions, and only taking more risk will ‘ if successful ‘ bring him out of his sainted predecessor’s shadow.

Meanwhile, Google and Microsoft both want to emulate the Apple model Jobs created, controlling the whole mobile experience from device to software to content and purchasing. Both are accelerating their moves in that direction, sometimes failing to remember that it didn’t come easily to Apple, and risking a repeat of mistakes which are often glossed over in the glow of the iPhone’s massive success. Recognizing past missteps, and innovating rather than imitating, will be critical to Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer ‘ indeed, this may be his last chance to prove he really can deliver the ‘new era’ he promised to shareholders this month, one built around ‘devices and services’, Apple-style.

In Microsoft’s case, the risks are especially great, given its poor track record in either side of the mobile equation, software platform or devices. The Kin, the Zune and Windows Mobile are hardly an impressive CV for a would-be mobile leader. However, it has some stronger tools too, notably the increasing convergence of Windows 8 and WP8, and the success of its best integrated platform, Xbox. Ballmer will need to deploy these far more effectively than he has so far. His limited understanding of the mobile and online markets, and his clinging to the myth of Windows’ superiority, have been factors in Microsoft’s failure in this sector, and that is now reflected in the mounting pressure on him personally. His bonus was cut as a result of online failures, while there was even market talk that co-founder Bill Gates might return. Gates, his formerly negative reputation fully restored by his commitment to philanthropic ventures such as eradicating malaria, understandably showed little interest in this, though clearly the decline of Microsoft would hit his personal fortune and therefore his charitable foundations. But the fact that the markets could feel wistful for Gates shows the depth of frustration with Ballmer, much of that stemming from the missteps in mobile and web content sectors.

So how will these CEOs ‘ Apple’s Cook, struggling to make his mark, and Microsoft’s Ballmer, perhaps outliving his usefulness ‘ be regarded in the mobile world another year from now? The answer, of course, depends on the decisions they are making right now.

In Cook’s case, the negative is disappointment at yet another iPhone with only incremental changes. Of course it will sell in droves and there is understandable reluctance to fix something that is very far from broken, but there have been too many cycles of huge over-anticipation of radical new features, followed by rather modest updates which chip away at Apple’s reputation for constant innovation. Much of that product innovation is now seen in the iPad, where Apple really did carve out a new segment, but that was not a profound shift in thinking, for all the attractiveness of bringing the iPhone experience to a larger screen.

The iPad has changed user behavior, perhaps in ways Apple did not foresee or certainly direct ‘ its role as a second TV screen is particularly interesting for service provider business models. It will help to push consumers more rapidly towards a multiscreen world where a single experience and content store can be pushed to all kinds of devices. The problem is that Apple needs to change more quickly to take advantage of that beyond providing the mobile gadget. As the limited impact of Apple TV has shown, the company is far from filling in the TV link in the chain, and here Samsung (and Sony) loom large with their huge incumbent status in this particular segment and distribution chain. And the uncharacteristic incompetence of launching iOS Maps long before it was fit for purpose hints at a company which is no longer in full control. It is racing to outwit enemies like Google and Samsung but is actually outpaced by them in areas like TV (Samsung) and control of core web services and data (Google). That throws Apple on the back foot and it resorts to defensive tactics like lawsuits and closing down the iOS platform.

Both those defensive tactics were vintage Steve Jobs, but when they backfire, as with Maps, they tend to be presented as a sign that Jobs’s magic has gone away, or Cook has failed to imagine successfully what his predecessor would have done. In reality, Cook’s real challenge is to stop wondering what Jobs might have done and use his own strengths ‘ his intimate understanding of the supply chain, his excellence in execution ‘ to come up with new solutions. After all, in his first year at the helm, he has see Apple’s market value leap by 78% and even top the record $700-a-share mark ‘ hardly the performance of a second rate CEO, even if he is trading on strategies put in place by his forerunner.

He also knows that he needs to change the culture at Apple. As the most valuable company in the world, it was becoming disingenuous for Jobs to play the role of the underdog, the legacy from the PC-Mac fight ‘ now Cook has to live with the rising perception of Apple as a leader, a bully, an ‘evil’ company as Microsoft and IBM have been in their time. He does not have the cult status to get away with behaving like an evil company while still attracting adoration ‘ he has introduced charitable programs for the first time at Apple and made efforts to address abuses at factories. He has also apologized for key blunders ‘ the maps incident, cutting back on retail employees, and withdrawing from the environmental certification program. The problem with apologies is they highlight the mistakes and reinforce the myth that missteps have only started happening at Apple since Jobs died. But Cook knows he cannot get away with blustering through mistakes ‘ and increasingly, Jobs’ Apple couldn’t either, as ‘Antennagate’ showed.

That is his real weakness ‘ that he isn’t Jobs ‘ but his strengths, particularly as a supply chain genius, are exceptionally valuable ones in the mobile market, as long as he keeps the right people around him to attend to design and branding. ‘His leadership style is quite different, both internally and externally. He’s much more open,’ Toni Sacconaghi, an analyst at Sanford C Bernstein, told BusinessWeek. ‘I think he believes he doesn’t have all the answers, so he’s willing to listen to other people. I’m not so sure that was the case with Steve.’ His challenge is not to behave like Jobs, but to create a new leadership style for a new set of market conditions; to leverage his operational strengths to steal competitive advantage away from Samsung and others; and to innovate so that Apple remains a driver not a follower in key trends like cloud and multiscreen content. In the first two, the signs are good ‘ the style is changing and that is appreciated by many important parties such as carriers; and the ability to control key components and keep margins high in such a competitive market is impressive.

But in innovation, there are fewer gold stars on the one-year report card. Pete Solvik, managing director of venture capital firm Sigma and a former Apple employee, spoke for many when he told the LA Times: ‘The $64,000 question is: does Tim have the ability to lead the organization to another major breakthrough in a new product category? I have little doubt he is going to have continued success with revisions of the current products. Everybody hopes that he has the ability to sustain the business with a new hit too.”

His rival at Microsoft, Steve Ballmer, has never had a mobile hit, though Xbox has increasingly been a powerhouse further up the device chain. Microsoft has recently innovated hard and delivered a genuine new user experience with Windows Phone, and the promise of a converged platform with Windows 8. But progress is slow and Microsoft has none of the influence over the market or supply chain that it has in the PC world. As Apple risks doing, Microsoft has done for years, clinging to past glories and old truisms when it should have been completely reinventing, or even dumping, Windows and seizing leadership in multi-device platforms and cloud content. It is making belated progress now, and like Apple, for all the mistakes and the criticism, it remains a juggernaut. Cook should certainly take comfort, when reassuring users that iOS Maps would come right in the end, that Microsoft has built an empire around delivering sub-standard software in at least the first two releases.

However, the mobile and web worlds are less forgiving ‘ or less locked-in ‘ and slow progress in online and mobile businesses has hit successive Microsoft quarterly results, and even Ballmer’s own bonus for fiscal 2012. This was $620,000, lower than last year’s $682,500 and well below the potential maximum of $1.37m. Board members, an SEC filing revealed, cited online losses and slow growth for Windows Phone, as well as the company’s failure to meet requirements of a 2009 agreement with the European Commission. (Ballmer’s bonus was 91% of his salary. He does not receive stock compensation at his own request.)

Ballmer has responded to intensified pressure to innovate by promising a ‘new era’ at Microsoft, in which the company becomes a ‘devices and services’ provider rather than a software house. That directly emulates Apple’s model and justifies Microsoft’s decision to launch its own devices ‘ the upcoming Surface Windows RT tablet and probably accompanying smartphones ‘ despite the obvious conflicts of interest with its PC OEMs and its main handset partners Nokia and HTC. In his annual letter to shareholders, Ballmer said there was a ‘fundamental shift under way in our business’, and issued the strongest hint yet that Microsoft would launch its own handset. While insisting, somewhat disingenuously, the firm would ‘continue to work with a vast ecosystem of partners to deliver a broad spectrum of Windows PCs, tablets and phones’, he added: ‘There will be times when we build specific devices for specific purposes, as we have chosen to do with Xbox and the recently announced Microsoft Surface’.

The aim is to create a single platform and user experience around Windows 8, spanning the PC, tablet, phone, server and cloud, and with the hardware and software fully integrated, Apple-style. This is hardly innovative thinking ‘ all the major platform companies are moving this way ‘ but it requires very different behavior from that of a software house. Creating a hardware/software platform is not enough, it needs to be an excellent one, with real user and developer appeal, since Microsoft cannot trade on its market share or partner control any longer. Until recently, it rose to this challenge by designing much improved operating systems, and by continually bolstering its content and web offerings such as Bing and Xbox ‘ though it remains well behind Apple and Google in this respect. The potential to create a multiscreen, cloud-oriented content and apps platform around the Xbox brand, harnessing the mobile software assets of Nokia (especially Navteq) is there, but has been only marginally exploited as yet. Microsoft apparently hopes it will make more impact by tightening its control of the hardware side ‘ not just, as before, by imposing certain design rules on OEMs and providing reference platforms, but by devising its own products to showcase the Windows 8 experience and offer a blueprint for other vendors. It says it will have new freedom to invest in the latest hardware features and form factors and bring them to market rather than waiting for partners.

The flaw in the thinking is that Microsoft has a bad track record in device design, with the exception of Xbox (where it did not launch against an existing base of hardware partners, and where it took the firm’s traditional three attempts to get the offering right). It risks antagonizing hardware partners, some of whom ‘ like Samsung ‘ are just showing renewed interest in Windows Phone, and have far greater ability to influence consumer choice than Microsoft. Also, it has an unfinished and somewhat fragmented software and content platform, with many confusing brands, and the integrated strategy will only fly if the content, not just the gadget and UI, are powerful.

Ballmer wrote: “Last year in this letter I said that over time, the full value of our software will be seen and felt in how people use devices and services at work and in their personal lives. This is a significant shift, both in what we do and how we see ourselves ‘ as a devices and services company. It impacts how we run the company, how we develop new experiences, and how we take products to market for both consumers and businesses. The work we have accomplished in the past year and the roadmap in front of us brings this to life.”

This is not true yet, at least not in a way that is visible to the world. Microsoft is clearly on the back foot in the hardware/software experience, in the mobile world and in web services, and while Windows 8 has some claim to be revolutionary, those claims are yet to be tested. Where Ballmer could steal a march on Apple and Google, and proclaim himself an innovator for the first time, is in addressing the TV element of the multiscreen system, where the other two have clear weaknesses. Xbox is the key here, and Microsoft has sensibly been extending the gaming system’s user interface and brand to video and integrating its user interface with those of Windows Phone, W8 and Live. In turn, the updated Xbox UI is built around the Metro design of WP8 and W8, and harnesses Bing search. And Microsoft is boldly pushing Xbox to the core of the TV entertainment experience – partnering with 40 content providers from around the globe to increase the amount of live and on-demand content for the platform ‘ assets which will be shared with W8 in future.

It is learning lessons from geniuses of the early multiscreen video world like Amazon, in terms of consistency and habit, and also how to drive loyalty via subscriptions. Many of the programmes and apps from partners are only available to customers who purchase an Xbox Live Gold Membership. All this takes Microsoft a small step closer to its long term goal of replacing set-top boxes with Xbox to make it a critical center of the living room, and then pushing the whole user content and apps experience towards Windows ‘ on PCs, tablets, TVs and media players.

The other important platform to integrate into the overall ‘devices and services’ strategy will be Mediaroom ‘ far less successful than Xbox, but sitting in the about-to-explode connected TV space, and with more inbuilt advantages over Apple and Google than Microsoft has had in other non-PC segments. Success in connected TV will depend on partnerships and integration with other platforms, far more than on boxes or packages on their own, no matter how sexy, and this could benefit Microsoft over Apple. The latter’s closed and tightly controlled ecosystem could well find its stumbling block at last in TV, and in going head-to-head with pay-TV providers, Apple will actually have internal conflicts of interest, since one of the key drivers for the iPad is to encourage consumption of existing subscription content around the home.

So far, Microsoft has played a far stronger hand than many rivals and is well perched to give Apple, Google, Samsung and others a very good run for their money. One key difference is the strategy, in that Microsoft is aligned with rather than against the pay-TV industry, actually helping operators withstand the onslaught from emerging players ‘ a role it also claims for Windows Phone. Microsoft sees connected TV as a positive disruptive force that pay-TV operators should embrace by deploying TV Anywhere to extend their reach and defend against cord cutting, while actually attracting new subscribers for OTT-only subscription packages. And now Xbox has been in effect united with Mediaroom, acting as a catalyst to ignite relevant development and acquisitions.

Microsoft now has a far more convincing TV ecosystem than its competitors including Apple, and this is being reflected in partnerships with key operators. This advantage is already feeding into Xbox and will be called into service to differentiate W8 too. It has significant challenges ‘ Google has greater content assets, including YouTube, and the alignment with Samsung to boost Android TV. However, this is an area where the Windows giant has real edge. Rather than blindly imitating Apple’s integrated model, Ballmer needs to dig deep for his creative side, and change the rules ‘ basing them around Xbox and TV ‘ at a time when Apple’s own innovative impulse is running slowly.

Motorola scores patent point against Microsoft:

In the latest twist in the Android patent wars, Motorola Mobility has scored points in a long-running battle with Microsoft in Germany. The Mannheim Regional Court, where many of the Android bouts have been fought, has ruled that Google’s subsidiary does not infringe on a Microsoft patent.

The patent concerns radio interface technology to make the use of applications easier ‘ it is titled ‘method and radio interface layer comprising a set of application programming interfaces’.

Two weeks ago, another German court, in Munich, ruled in Microsoft’s favor in a different patent infringement suit with Motorola Mobility, and granted Microsoft the right to apply for an injunction against offending smartphones and tablets in Germany. That patent relates to a system to help handset keyboards communicate more simply with applications.

Germany is the main European battleground in the wireless wars because of its particularly friendly laws for patent holders, but in previous decisions regarding Apple/Android lawsuits, the extension of German decisions to the European Union as a whole was denied. Other European centers for IPR warfare include the UK and the Netherlands.

Most major handset makers have signed licensing deals for Microsoft’s patents in Android/Linux, but Motorola has been the main stand-out, and its battles have new significance now it is part of Google, which acquired the firm mainly to bolster its own patent arsenal. Any victories Motorola can win will strengthen its parent, and the whole Android platform, against Microsoft royalties and Apple litigation.

Microsoft and Motorola are also fighting in various courts in the US, including at the International Trade Commission (ITC), with the Windows giant citing nine of its patents. Their battle was kicked off when the Windows giant filed suit at the ITC two years ago, citing nine of its patents.

Native Office could coincide with next iPad

Microsoft will finally launch native Office applications for iOS and Android in March. Microsoft product manager Petr Bobek told a press event in the Czech Republic that the long awaited products would come to the two leading mobile OSs, plus Symbian.

Microsoft is not confirming the news at a more corporate level, telling CNet: “Office Mobile will work across Windows Phones, Android phones and iOS, and we have nothing additional to announce today about retail availability of the new Office.” OneNote and Lync are likely to be the first cross-platform offerings, with Word, Excel and Powerpoint to come.

An unveiling in March would probably coincide with the debut of the next full-sized iPad, if Apple sticks to its current cycle, and that could give the new apps a powerful launch platform ‘ showing Microsoft’s belated recognition that it may profit more from extending popular software to third party platforms, than keeping everything close to home in order to differentiate Windows alone.

Indeed, a press release, also issued in the Czech Republic, indicates that Android and iOS versions will appear at the same time as native Office for Microsoft’s own ARM-based Windows variants, RT and Windows Phone 8, giving those systems no time advantages. Web versions of the apps are also reportedly on their way.

The timing also means that, despite the obvious appeal of a larger screen for Office use, the first Windows RT tablets, due towards the end of the year, will miss the apps. However, the iPad is the leading slate and likely to remain so despite the debut of Microsoft Surface and other models ‘ and is increasingly finding its way into large enterprises. Therefore Microsoft has already risked losing impatient users to rival productivity platforms, having been supposedly releasing native Office apps for the iPad ‘soon’ for about a year. Apple has now released its own iWork suite.

Google and Microsoft expand hardware activities

Google and Microsoft are both chasing the dream of controlling the whole mobile web experience ‘ devices, services and software platforms. Microsoft Surface may be lurking, but Google is well ahead with its Nexus strategy, even though the precise role of Motorola Mobility’s handsets remains uncertain.

Google is set for a major expansion of its co-branded Nexus range, with plans to chase real market share rather than using its devices mainly as a showcase for its interpretation of the Android experience. Rather than working with one partner at a time, most recently Samsung, it will have multiple models to offer, working with several manufacturers, partly to counter fears of favoritism towards its own handset maker, Motorola Mobility. The latest Nexus is reported to be coming from LG.

“We challenge all our partners that want to work with us on a Nexus product to push the envelope,” Patrick Brady, director of Android partner engineering for Google, told CNet.

This could be a useful boost for the Korean firm, which struggles to grow its profile and sales in the shadow of Samsung and Apple, despite some innovative devices. Providing a Nexus has traditionally delivered little in terms of volumes but allows the OEM to ride on Google’s marketing and developer machine, and to run new Android releases at the earliest stage. Thus Samsung, which hardly needs yet another handset, has been enthusiastic about its Galaxy Nexus products, and LG stands to benefit even more from Google’s patronage, since it is still trying to be accepted in the top tier of smartphone makers.

As with most Nexus models, the new one will be an adapted version of an existing device, in this case the new LG Optimus G. It should make its debut at the end of October, according to CNet sources, and will run the upcoming Android 4.2, well before the Optimus G itself, or other Android handsets, sport the latest update. This shows Google pursuing its traditional aims for Nexus, to generate Android community chatter and win over developers. But broadening its range of hardware partners also indicates that, in 2013, Nexus will be promoted as a top tier mobile brand in its own right.

According to Modaco, the modified Optimus G will run on Qualcomm’s Snapdragon quad-core processor, and like the original ‘G’ will feature 2Gbytes of RAM, a 1280 x 768 True-High Definition IPS display and 8-megapixel camera. The main differentiating feature will be wireless charging, but high end users will not like the non-removable battery and the limited storage (no microSD slot and only 8Gbytes to 16Gbytes of internal storage).

Just as LG gets its place in the Google sun, its larger compatriot is becoming even more indispensable to Nexus, despite the conflicts of interest between Samsung ‘ with its ability to drive sales of Android devices without Google services ‘ and the search giant. Perhaps the latter is trying to keep Samsung loyal by promising it a special place in the Nexus platform, with the attendant benefits such as early access to some Android technologies. Whatever the politics, Samsung is likely to produce the next Nexus tablet.

As smartphones become a mass market, tablets are where the growth and margin lie in the mobile device world. No wonder, then, that the holiday catwalk will feature a rising number of slates in different shapes and sizes from the big names. Apple’s ‘iPad Mini’ should appear soon, Samsung already has a range of variants across its Tab and Note families, and now the Korean firm is set to provide a full-sized model to bolster Google’s Nexus portfolio.

Google entered the tablet space with the Nexus 7, created with Asus, going head-to-head with the Amazon Kindle Fire, in particular. Amazon itself failed to deliver a 10-inch model when it upgraded its Kindle family recently, though it is still likely to do so next year. But Google is poised to get there first, and with a smaller iPad expected too, the greatest rivals in the mobile world will take off the gloves and compete directly in both key slate form factors.

According to analysts at NPD DisplaySearch, supply chain sources indicate that Samsung will make the latest Google device, which will probably be a variant of the Tab 10.1 rather than the Note ‘ one of the few tablets which actually stands out from the crowd at the moment with its apps-loaded intelligent pen.

Samsung seems so confident that Nexus will add to its sales rather than cannibalizing Galaxy that it is even willing to share the key differentiators of its own hardware with the search giant. Google will take advantage of Samsung’s expertise in touchscreen displays and the ‘Nexus 10’ will boast higher pixel density than the iPad HD, at 299 pixels per inch and 2560 x 1600 resolution (the Retina iPad has 264ppi and 2048 x 1536 on a 9.7-inch screen).

This takes Google’s Nexus range into the premium segment, though as with other models, it shows the search giant following rather than shaping the market, picking off successful models in the mobile space and emulating them, as with Fire ‘ or merely commissioning its own variant, as with the Samsung Galaxy Nexus devices, modifications of the Galaxy S range. The main differentiator – apart from Google’s heavily branded user interface, which some see as a downside ‘ is that the Nexus products get to run new Android releases at the earliest stage, and so have served to encourage developer efforts.

This is vital in the battle with Apple’s huge apps base, of course, and Android tablets still labor under criticisms that there are too few applications optimized for their larger screens. While there are about 675,000 Android apps in total, Google refuses to divulge how many are adapted for tablets. However, it is trying to stimulate developer efforts this holiday season, posting a ‘tablet app quality checklist’ to highlight best practices for building software for the Nexus 7 and others.

It also makes an online sales pitch to programmers, making three key points ‘ bigger screens have been seen to drive greater usage of apps and more user engagement, leading to higher purchases, advertising eyeballs and in-app buys; users of tablet apps, especially games, are more likely to return than handset equivalents, and therefore generate more revenue over time; and the base of Android tablets is growing, bringing high profile products like Instapaper ‘ formerly iPhone-only ‘ to the Google platform.

Google is expected to expand the Nexus range in other directions before year end too, with a $99 budget tablet anticipated.

While the search firm is pointedly keeping Motorola out of the Nexus range for now, perhaps to reassure other OEMs, it is certainly paying attention to its hardware unit’s products and profits. It aims to accelerate the process of whittling down Motorola’s portfolio to reduce costs and make a bigger impact with selected devices. In the longer term, Google may sell on Motorola’s cellphones, or morph the subsidiary into Nexus, but for now it is maintaining the promised Chinese wall between the unit and Android.

Among the changes at Motorola under its new ownership is the end of the Webtop concept, which turned a smartphone into the brains of a PC or TV hub. The handset, notably the Motorola Atrix 4G, was docked using the LapDock accessory and then powered a notebook-like shell or thin client. This was hailed by some as the future of mobile computing, and an important differentiator for Motorola in the sea of Android handsets. But sales were disappointing, hit by AT&T’s pricing the phone and dock at $500. That extinguished the early enthusiasm of reviewers and now Google says it will be unnecessary to have such technology to bridge the PC/handset divide in future, since Android will have more features like those of PC desktops. This will become more true as PC and phone platforms converge ‘ Windows 8 and WP8 have a unified kernel; Chrome and Android are coming together; even iOS and OS X are sharing more features.

Over at Microsoft, the firm has finalized its joint venture with Barnes & Noble, adding to its integrated device/content armory by allying with Amazon’s direct rival. The venture is now called Nook Media after B&N’s ereader and tablet range, and is a subsidiary of the bookseller, not a separate company as yet.

“Microsoft and Barnes & Noble’s strategic partnership in Nook Media LLC will enable the companies to advance world class digital reading experiences to the hundreds of millions of customers they jointly serve,” said the official statement. The entity includes the digital and college businesses of B&N, and is backed by a $300m investment from the Windows company. Now the new structure has been approved, Microsoft may move forward with rumored products such as a ‘Microsoft Reader’ with an interface to the Nook store, though the first fruit is likely to be a version of the Nook app for Windows Phone 8.