Despite strenuous efforts to reassure US regulators, Huawei and ZTE could still be blacklisted from critical telecoms contracts. A draft report from the US House Intelligence Committee, which has been probing security issues around Chinese vendors, recommends that the two giants should not be allowed to operate in the US because of their suspected links to the Chinese state, and the potential for security risk. However, many observers are claiming the findings are unsubstantiated and commercially or politically motivated, arguments that are naturally deployed by the two vendors themselves.
The Committee, which published its findings today after an 11-month investigation, said the two companies could not be trusted to work without being influenced by the Chinese government. It criticized both vendors for being vague about their relationships and regulatory interaction with state authorities and failing to address US concerns during recent hearings.
Therefore it is warning telecoms operators to look elsewhere for their infrastructure deals, and also called on the US intelligence service to provide more information to the private sector about the potential espionage threat. It also wants any mergers and acquisitions involving the two companies to be barred.
This is a draft report and the Committee does not have power to enforce its recommendations, but they will certainly carry weigh as they effectively gave official endorsement to allegations that Chinese equipment can be used for espionage ‘ even though the vendors deny any such dangers, and many observers think the real agenda is commercial rivalry between the US and China. “This puts an established intelligence community stamp on the idea that these are companies that pose a potential serious threat,” Stewart Baker, a former US Homeland Security Department official, told Bloomberg. “They are going to be treated more harshly than other multinationals for the foreseeable future.”
Huawei and ZTE have denied all allegations of present or past espionage, including a report from the BBC that they installed code capable of spying in some equipment. They have also faced, and denied, accusations of bribery, corruption, discrimination and copyright infringement. The Committee will refer the second set of allegations to the Justice Department, Homeland Security, and other US government bodies.
The report was more damning about Huawei than ZTE, claiming the committee had received “credible allegations from unnamed industry experts and current and former Huawei employees suggesting Huawei, in particular, may be guilty of bribery and corruption, discriminatory behavior and copyright infringement.” However, it produced no hard evidence. ZTE was not accused of any illegal behavior.
Huawei customers in other countries will be assessing any risk to their own security. The UK is an important European foothold for the Chinese firm, which has router deals with broadband providers like BT and TalkTalk, and a mobile contract with MBNL, the infrastructure venture which supports Everything Everywhere and 3UK. Tim Clement-Jones, a member of the UK House of Lords and until recently one of Huawei’s advisors in the country, warned firms against overreacting. “In my view, I’m very sceptical about the way the US plays this, and most of all Republican congressmen,” he told ZDNet. “I’ve sat through many meetings [covering Huawei’s activities] and I think that a lot of this is pure anti-competitive behaviour in the US. They skewed the whole inquiry. They got their facts wrong.”
Meanwhile, the European Commission is delaying its own investigation into Huawei and ZTE, according to Reuters, due to the fact that no formal complaint has been received from a stakeholder. The EC probe concerns allegations of state subsidies and product dumping. It was, unusually, initiated by the European authorities themselves, rather than by an accusation from a rival firm ‘ sources say European vendors like Ericsson, Alcatel-Lucent and Nokia Siemens were unwilling to act since they have significant businesses in China which could face retaliatory measures. The move to delay the case could ease tensions between the European Union and China, its second largest trading partner.
Many analysts believe the committee findings reflect politics rather than security issues. “This is not a problem that is unique to Huawei and ZTE. In fact, if there is a problem, it’s a problem with everybody,” David Wolf, CEO of Wolf Group Asia, told IDG. And Ovum’s Matt Walker said: ‘It’s election season. Voting is less than one month away in the US and the China threat is a potent political issue in the US nowadays.’
Robert Syputa, principal analyst at Maravedis-Rethink, said: ‘My thinking is that the claim of security threats should be rigorously tested, which as far as I am aware has not happened. I think, therefore, that this is part of the reaction to deterioration in America’s balance of trade and growing national debt that is using security as a means to deny open competition. To a large extent, north American equipment suppliers have already seen declines in business due to higher costs and lack of focus. While America has continued to contribute to development of WiMAX and LTE, the leadership role has become diluted by more extensive international participation in standards groups and technology development.’
The report nonetheless puts intense pressure on the two vendors, though both have still stated they will continue to chase US contracts and to restore their reputations. While Huawei, in particular, has expanded rapidly in other areas, and gained strong footholds in European LTE roll-outs, it has been effectively barred from similar US deals, most famously a share of Sprint’s Network Vision modernization project. In this, it reportedly got to the final round of the contract before Sprint changed its mind under pressure from government agencies. Huawei’s VP of external affairs, Bill Plummer, recently told GigaOM : ‘We were the most competitive offering for Sprint in terms of technology and total cost of ownership, but non-market forces dictated the result.’
Huawei’s main US customer has been Clearwire, and it has been forced to rely mainly on handsets in order to forge links with north American cellcos like MetroPCS. ZTE has faced similar challenges. Both vendor deny any current or past involvement in spying or other Chinese government activities, and some see the US hostility to Chinese kit as motivated by commercial defensiveness, rather than national security.
The Committee held a three-hour hearing last month, and its members criticized both Chinese firms for being vague in their answers to questions about whether their equipment could be used to spy on US companies and citizens. At the end of that session, chairman Mike Rogers said: “I can say that I am a little disappointed today. I was hoping for a little more transparency…. Other inconsistencies worry me greatly.”
But during the hearing, Huawei SVP Charles Ding said: “Huawei has not and will not jeopardize our global commercial success nor the integrity of our customers’ networks for any third party, government or otherwise.” ZTE also denied the charges, saying that the reported ‘back doors’ in the kit were actually software bugs, commonly found in such equipment.
Huawei is particularly under scrutiny because of its close ties to the Chinese government, and its sometimes obscure structure. In a TV interview last month, Rogers signalled the attitude of his committee, saying: “If I were an American company today…and you are looking at Huawei, I would find another vendor if you care about your intellectual property, if you care about your consumers’ privacy, and you care about the national security of the United States of America.’
The company has made various moves to reassure government agencies or to challenge the accusations, challenging US authorities to produce any evidence publicly; pledging to expand its investment in R&D and other facilities in the US; and offering access to its internal structures and records. It was even reported to be going further and seeking a listing on a US or international stock exchange, which would open up its accounts and ownership structure, and could even create a separate unit to deal with the US, behind a security firewall. However, the company denied Reuters reports that it had contacted investment banks about the possibility of an IPO, and such a listing would not address all its critics. After all, ZTE faces much of the same hostility, even though it is listed on the Shenzhen and Hong Kong stock exchanges.
In the wireless world, even if Huawei gains the confidence of authorities, its timing will be poor for this generation of upgrades. All four national cellcos now have their suppliers lined up for LTE and 3G/4G network modernization projects ‘ with Ericsson and Alcatel-Lucent in pole position – so Huawei would have to wait for a second wave of deals, while combating its rivals’ incumbent status, or hope to catch a newcomer like, potentially, Dish Network. And in a broader sense, Huawei has missed out on the realignment of the north American wireless vendor space, following the demise of Nortel and Motorola Networks, and the rising power of Cisco in the core ‘ an opportunity which, by contrast, Samsung has exploited.
For all these reasons, its response to the report was furious. ‘The outcome was predetermined,” William Plummer, Huawei’s VP of external affairs, told The Wall Street Journal. “The political agenda was one of poking China in the eye and holding hostage an innocent, independent, employee-owned company.’
The Chinese commerce ministry and foreign ministry also responded to the report, with the former warning that it could harm wider trade relations between the two countries, where many tensions already exist. A spokesperson for the commerce ministry added that the committee was violating the US’s ‘long held free market principles,’ and that its report was full of groundless and subjective conjecture.
ZTE’s director of global affairs, David Dai Shu, also weighed in, saying: ‘It is noteworthy that, after a year-long investigation, the committee rests its conclusions on a finding that ZTE may not be ‘free of state influence’. This finding would apply to any company operating in China. The committee has not challenged ZTE’s fitness to serve the US market based on any pattern of unethical or illegal behavior.’
He added that the investigation should also have carried out the same probes into western and other telecoms suppliers (a move that did happen in India, which has been similarly suspicious of possible links between Chinese suppliers and the state). He said in a statement: ‘Given that virtually all US telecom equipment is produced in China, in some measure, the committee’s narrow focus addresses the overall issue of risk to US telecom infrastructure so narrowly that it omits… the suppliers of the vast majority of equipment used in the US market’
ZTE has proposed a ‘trusted delivery model’ to allay concerns, which would see the vendor transferring hardware, software, firmware and other structural equipment to an independent third party threat assessment laboratory with US government agency oversight. The committee said it had not ruled out such a compromise.
Huawei has also initiated a concerted effort to gain more business with tier one cellcos in India, another country where authorities have mounted security probes against Chinese suppliers. It has set out a five-year plan which will involve investing $2bn in India. According to Economic Times, Huawei India’s CEO Cai Liqun said: “We have to get more business from tier one companies like Bharti Airtel, Vodafone and Idea Cellular, and recover the investment done in the Indian business.” The vendor suffered a blow to its Indian base when the government cancelled 122 GSM licences ‘ two of the large holders, Sistema Shyam and Uninor, were Huawei customers. The general uncertainty caused by this saga and other regulatory delays has made operators cautious about spending on their networks, and there has also been government pressure on using Huawei and ZTE because of security concerns.
Cai said his firm is going through a process of optimizing operations and improving internal capabilities to be better prepared for future growth. “It is also an opportunity. We optimized our organization by putting more good resources toward tier one companies,’ he said in the interview. It will particularly focus on the holders of BWA spectrum, such as Reliance Industries and Bharti Airtel-Qualcomm, since they will be deploying TD-LTE, a technology where the Chinese suppliers are in a strong position.
The Indian telecom equipment sector’s revenue dropped last year, despite 3G roll-outs, to $21.7bn from $21.9bn in 2010-2011.