Ever since Ericsson exited its handset joint venture with Sony, it has been expected to make a similar move at its other key JV, ST-Ericsson. The mobile chipmaker has been suffering prolonged financial and reorganization problems, and has now admitted it is ‘currently working with an external advisor in order to ensure the best possible future’ for the firm.
Of course this will renew speculation that the Swedish vendor is poised to sell out of the unit it formed with STMicro in February 2009, though the unit’s statement said: ‘Both STMicroelectronics and Ericsson support ST-Ericsson in its transformation work and remain confident that the company has a strategic position in the industry to enable the device ecosystem.’
It reminded the markets that the firm is in the midst of a radical strategic plan, announced in April, and remains ‘in the middle of executing on company transformation aiming at lowering its break-even point.’ However, analysts seized more readily on another sentence in the official statement: ‘It is natural for the parent companies to continuously review the strategy of the company.’
A report in French newspaper Les Echos sparked the statement, and it said one option was for STE to be broken up and sold off in pieces, perhaps based on key activities in connectivity, power management and software architecture. Other pieces of the business could be moved back into the parent companies. The paper’s sources say a decision is expected before the end of this year.
STE was set up nearly four years ago to merge STMicro’s mobile chip venture with NXP, with Ericsson Mobile Platforms (EMP). This aimed to create an entity with greater scale and product range, to compete with Qualcomm and others, as well as a unit that could focus specifically on mobile chips, rather than being just a small part of either parent’s broader activities. But the unit has struggled with delayed product releases; slow migration from legacy to new platforms; loss of market share to Qualcomm and newer challengers like Nvidia, especially in the important high end smartphone and tablet segments; and the decline of lead customer Nokia.
Positive points like a strong position in China’s TD-SCDMA and TD-LTE markets have failed to offset these negative trends and the company has failed to get back to profit. In July it announced a Q2 loss of $318m, greater than the year-ago figure of $221m, on revenue down to $344m from $385m a year earlier. Such performance has sparked impatience about the slow turnaround progress, from investors in both parents, as well as speculation that Ericsson would sell out, or that the whole unit would be snapped up by another chip vendor, with AMD, Nvidia and Intel all whispered as candidates.
AMD is an obvious rumor, since it has failed to come up with an offering for the smartphone market and is thought to be looking for ARM-based partners. Companies which are weak on the modem side could also benefit from STE’s huge experience in this field, and the venture’s main platform, NovaThor, combines the baseband and processor in the same way as Qualcomm’s Snapdragon ‘ an increasingly important trend as handsets get smaller and more power efficient.
Nvidia acquired Icera, and Intel bought Infineon Wireless, to fill the modem gap, but both might be keen to add further to their platforms, though Intel is unlikely to take on an ARM-based solution just when Atom is starting to gain mobile ground. The best candidate could be an up-and-coming Chinese or Taiwanese chipmaker in need of higher end products and a quick route into 3G, LTE and tier one OEMs. Mediatek and Spreadtrum would be obvious examples, as well as Huawei-backed HiSilicon, while Clarke also cites Rockchip, Xincomm, Leadcore Technology and Nufront, as tipped by EETimes.
CEO Didier Lamouche took the helm on December 1 2011, moving from the post of COO of STMicro, and is the third CEO since the 50:50 venture with Ericsson was formed in February 2009, replacing Gilles Delfassy. Delfassy took over in September of the same year, replacing Alain Dutheil, who returned to his previous role (also as COO at STMicro) after steering the merger. When Lamouche took over, the official STE statement was upbeat, saying the JV would now ‘enter a phase with prime focus on proliferating design wins and scaling up and delivering volume, with the objective of translating its new portfolio into sustainable profitability and growth.’
But this will be an uphill path, though one analyst firm does hold out hope for STE. Strategy Analytics says in a recent study of the mobile processor market that NovaThor saw 28% sequential growth in the second quarter of 2012, reaching STE’s highest shipments in four years. However, Qualcomm gained 48% share by revenue and was also the clear leader in unit terms. The other top five players Samsung, MediaTek, Broadcom and TI.