Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 October 2012

ITU kicks off process of rethinking Frand licensing

Governments and standards bodies have taken a keen interest in the Apple/Android patent lawsuits round the world, particularly the issues they have raised about how standards-essential IPR should be licensed. On Wednesday, Apple, Motorola Mobility and other players argued these points at the ITU (International Telecommunications Union).

The ITU said progress had been made, though the issues are complex and there will be more rounds of discussion. The ITU hosted a meeting of vendors plus regulators and academics. Its standardization bureau chief Malcolm Johnson said there was ‘heated debate’ and added: “Today’s event has gone a long way to help clarify the positions of various stakeholders in determining the effectiveness of Frand commitments and the impact of litigations surround standards-essential patents.”

While patents which are essential to standards are subject to Frand (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) licensing, they have been deployed in the recent IPR wars. Samsung, Motorola/Google and others are strong in this area, while Apple is not ‘ Nokia won a significant victory over the iPhone maker last year thanks to a similar mismatch. However, there is far less latitude to dictate terms for a patent subject to Frand, or to seek to bar offending products.

One of the issues debated in various courts is whether companies should be allowed to bid for injunctions at all when the IPR at issue cannot be worked around while remaining compliant with standards. In other arguments, some have said Frand rules are ineffective in the modern IPR world. According to the ITU, this is one of two main issues which are still unresolved, the other being the definition of ‘reasonable’ in Frand.

Google’s Motorola subsidiary has sought injunctions against Microsoft and Apple, citing standards-essential patents. It has also argued that a reasonable rate for licensing such IPR would be 2.25% of the sales price of the full product. Microsoft, Apple and Cisco ‘ all major IPR holders, but with less IPR in mobile standards – have all opposed that view. Such claims take the industry well away from previously stated targets of getting patents royalties down to about 5% of handset price in future, to enable lower cost devices.

‘The average selling price approach wrongly permits the patent holder to collect value unassociated with its contribution to the standard,” argued Apple’s chief intellectual property counsel BJ Watrous. “Using the ASP of the end user product as the royalty base is discriminating against companies like Apple who sell high value products.”

The talks will continue at lower level through the week and in future though any resolution is likely to be far off, given the commercial and political interests at stake. “Any attempt at providing market players with clear, transparent, effective and up-to-date patent policies and guidelines’ would work to the benefit of the industry as a whole,” Johnson said. “The ITU will not interfere with bilateral negotiations. However, I believe clarification in this regard could be a significant contribution from the ITU in addressing the current difficulties.”