Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 November 2012

Analysts brighten on RIM despite another federal loss

As usual, it’s been a week of mixed fortunes for RIM, which lost another contract in one of its critical markets, the US government, but saw some softening of analyst criticism of its make-or-break platform, BlackBerry 10.

On the plus side, the influential analyst Peter Misek of Jefferies, who has often led the criticism of RIM, took a more positive line on BB10, following RIM’s belated announcement of a firm launch date ‘ January 30, which at least allayed fears that it would delay its new OS further, perhaps as late as March or April.

Misek said in a research note that he was seeing a more positive response from mobile operators than he had predicted and that a survey ‘indicates developed market carriers have a much more positive view of BB10 than expected’. As a result, he raised his price target on RIM’s shares sharply from $5 to $10, and improved his rating on the shares to ‘hold’ from ‘underperform’.

RIM CEO Thorsten Heins said this month that BB10 was being tested by more than 50 operators, whose approval is vital to a strong profile for new RIM smartphones. Carriers are looking for alternatives to counterbalance Android and iOS, and while Windows Phone is the obvious candidate, traditional RIM supporters like Verizon Wireless have also said BB10 could be cast in the role as well.

Misek’s note said the operators’ unexpected confidence could lead to ‘greater carrier shelf space and marketing support’, though the optimism is relative ‘ he rates BB10’s chances of success, which presumably means reversing RIM’s plummeting market share, as ‘20% to 30% probability’. According to IDC, RIM’s third quarter global smartphone market share slipped to 4.3%, from 11.8% a year earlier.

“Thanks to our strong partnerships with global carriers and a growing ecosystem of developers, we believe our customers will have the best experience possible with BlackBerry 10,” Heins said in a statement. “We are looking forward to getting BlackBerry 10 in the hands of our customers around the world.”

But the US government agency which investigates aeroplane accidents is dropping BlackBerry, citing reliability issues ‘ a harsh blow for a vendor which has differentiated itself on its robustness and security. The National Transportation Safety Board said it would switch to the iPhone 5, saying on a federal website filing that its BlackBerry devices have been ‘failing both at inopportune times and at an unacceptable rate’. The 400-person agency ‘requires effective, reliable and stable communication capabilities to carry out its primary investigative mission and to ensure employee safety in remote locations,’ it added. This is the latest in a series of defections by federal organizations, once an easy target for RIM.