Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 November 2012

Android contract seeks to reduce fragmentation

Android fragmentation continues to be one of the platform’s chief handicaps. It has not actually limited uptake ‘ in the third quarter, the Google OS achieved greater domination than ever before, admittedly in a period largely without a new iPhone. It ran on 75% of smartphones shipped, according to IDC reckonings, and almost half of tablets, while in China its smartphone share rose to a massive 90%, according to Analysys International. But as Google showed off the latest release, JellyBean (4.2), the proliferation of different versions and incompatible apps remains a frustration for users and developers, and a possible reason to look towards Windows Phone/Windows 8.

Mindful of this, Google has modified the Android software developer kit (SDK) to try to address concerns. New contract terms for developers specifically bar them from behaviors which could aggravate fragmentation. This is the first major update to the developer terms and conditions since 2009, in the early days of Android, and the first explicitly to mention fragmentation.

Section 3.4 of the new document reads: “You agree that you will not take any actions that may cause or result in the fragmentation of Android, including but not limited to distributing, participating in the creation of, or promoting in any way a software development kit derived from the SDK.”

As the operating system matures, the pattern of quickfire upgrades is likely to calm down, but many of the problems of apps running poorly on different OS versions are down to the undisciplined approach to updates in the Google ecosystem. Handset makers are responsible for keeping their devices up to date with new releases, but it can take many months for an updated version to reach the user base, and processes are often confusing, or held back by operator policies.

Carriers are often keen to encourage customers to buy a new phone in order to get updated software, rather than support over-the-air upgrades. So JellyBean is appearing on Google’s own Nexus devices at a time when some vendors have not yet supported its predecessor, Ice Cream Sandwich. According to Google, 54% of Android devices currently in use are running Android 2.3, which is two years old.

The search giant has trodden a difficult line between maintaining its open source credentials by giving partners a free hand ‘ what Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer this week branded ‘wild and uncontrolled’ ‘ and trying to impose rules to ensure a unified user experience. Its most extreme attempt at the latter came with the tablet-specific release, Honeycomb, where Google took leaves out of Microsoft’s book by restricting the OS to select OEMs and insisting on a common user experience. That action led to howls of protest that Google was betraying its promises of openness.