Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 November 2012

Orange says rivals have failed to end subsidies in Spain

The Spanish operators’ attempt to lead the charge to cut ties with subsidized handsets appears to have failed. Orange’s Spanish unit says it will continue to grab market share in the recession-hit country as long as Vodafone and Telefonica try to reduce reliance on offering cheap devices (upfront at least).

Operators are keen to find alternatives to subsidies to lure users to sign contracts ‘ financing deals for smartphones and lower monthly fees are among the tactics used, while France’s Free Mobile has gone as far as to challenge the practice in court.

But the free or low cost handset is a powerful attraction, especially when consumer spending is squeezed. ‘There’s no need to end subsidies,’ Jean Marc Vignolles, CEO of France Telecom’s Orange Spain unit, told Bloomberg. ‘I have not personally seen any evidence that our two competitors have benefited from such a radical move. They’ve suffered commercially.’

Telefonica and Orange, the first and second cellcos in Spain, both stopped subsidies earlier this year but have since softened on the policy. During its quarterly earnings call this month, Telefonica executive chairman Cesar Alierta defended the policy, saying the carrier was stepping up ‘the focus on quality as a key lever to reduce churn’ in its mobile operations, by reducing subsidies but promising better quality of experience and long term value. However, revenues in the Spanish wireless unit were down by almost 20% year-on-year in the third quarter, even though there were improvements to churn and postpaid ARPU.

Vodafone Spain has been less inclined to stick with its strategy. It said it will reintroduce subsidies for smartphones after losing over 639,000 customers in the second quarter. The other two Spanish cellcos, Orange and TeliaSonera’s Yoigo, saw their market share increase in Q2, gaining 80,240 and 58,069 customers respectively, while Telefonica lost 830,000 subscribers between April and August, according to Reuters. As well as those two smaller cellcos, broadband operator Jazztel is offering a smartphone worth more than €200 for no upfront fee on contracts of just €5 a month, if subscribers take a bundle of fixed and mobile services.

Vodafone is now swinging the other way, claiming its break with subsidies was only an experiment. It reinstated some subsidies in May and will now offer them on all smartphones, with some new models, including the iPhone 5, carrying no upfront fee on contracts from €35 a month (or less if the mobile deal is added onto a broadband contract).

Telefonica and Vodafone are also adopting bundling to win new users. The former started offering its Movistar Fusion bundles in September, combining voice, mobile, broadband and pay-TV. And last week, Vodafone Spain launched new packages that combine fixed nad mobile internet, voice, text messaging and cloud services. This is the strategy that will allow Vodafone to get serious about ending subsidies again. ‘We no longer talk about whether or not subsidies would work,’ a spokesman told Bloomberg. ‘We now believe the key issue is to provide our customers with all services and a handset at a very competitive price.’

Alexander Wisch, an analyst at S&P Capital IQ Equity Research, pointed out that Telefonica has a greater incentive to pursue the subsidy-free route because of its urgent need to improve profits and cash. ‘Other operators including Orange are grabbing market share. Telefonica is aware of that but its priority is to conserve cash,’ he said. ‘I don’t think this is sustainable in the long term, but in the short term it is definitely good in terms of cash conservation.’

In September, Orange Spain gained 24,660 mobile customers, increasing its market share to 21.21% of customers, from 21.07% in August. Telefonica lost 253,520 mobile customers and its market share fell to 36.96%, while Vodafone lost 178,300, reducing its share to 27.42%, according to Spanish regulator CMT. Orange may boost its share further by acquiring Yoigo from TeliaSonera, though Vignolles said: ‘We’re not in a rush either to buy Yoigo and we shouldn’t buy it at any price.’ Yoigo had 6.11% share of the mobile base in September.