Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 November 2012

Apple, Amazon and Microsoft boost tablet profits though models differ

Apple and Amazon are increasingly butting heads as both look to offer an integrated hardware/software experience. Amazon is more advanced in cloud services and creating a compulsive purchasing process, while Apple is stronger in a controlled app store and user interface. But the two giants are becoming more similar, and now are both even playing in the same device category, the smaller tablet attached to the content store.

And they are coming closer together in their margin expectations too ‘ while Apple has always looked for hefty profits from hardware, Amazon disruptively launched its Kindle Fire with virtually no margin attached, assuming it would driver higher purchases of content, apps and even physical goods than the Amazon apps on third party devices and PCs (an argument already borne out in ebooks by the Kindle ereaders). But with the second generation Kindle Fire HD, Amazon is squeezing more margin out of the hardware itself, while Apple is also demonstrating how a mini-tablet can actually be more profitable than a higher priced full-sized slate.

According to new teardowns by IHS iSuppli, the iPad mini and Kindle Fire HD both carry bills of material (BoMs) which allow for higher margins than the vendors’ previous tablets. An entry level iPad Mini has a bill of materials of $188 plus another $10 in manufacturing costs (excluding software, royalties and other costs). The model retails for $329, making the device a little more profitable, on a percentage basis, than entry level iPad when it was released in March.

Meanwhile, Amazon has reduced the BoM on the Fire considerably with the HD. IHS calculates that the low end Fire HD has a BoM of $165, plus $9 in manufacturing costs. The product retails for $199. By contrast, the original Fire was had a cost of $201.70 but sold for the same price. Since Amazon’s stated objective was only to break even on its hardware, it has considerable latitude to reduce tablet prices to gain market share and drive more content sales.

‘Amazon’s strategy with the Kindle Fire HD 7-inch tablet is not really to make money on the hardware itself,’ said Andrew Rassweiler, principal analyst of teardown services at IHS, in a statement. “Rather, the idea is to create a product at a compelling price point and then get a lot of consumer traction in order to put Amazon content and the Amazon online store into consumer’ hands.”

Also squeezing the BoM of its tablet is Microsoft, whose first own-brand slate, the Surface RT, carries higher margins than a comparable iPad, claims the teardown firm. The entry level model, wtih 32Gbytes of NAND flash memory and an optional Touch Cover, has a BoM of $271.00 plus $13 in manufacturing cost. That places it squarely against the iPad HD, and like Apple, Microsoft is after strong hardware profits, despite its software heritage and lack of device track record. With a retail price of $599, the Surface RT with Touch Cover generates higher profits than the low end iPad HD, as does the Cover-less model at $499. And the cover is the kind of feature which will drive users to opt for a more expensive variant, even while costing Microsoft only about $17 a unit despite its many chips (which include a Freescale microcontroller and an Atmel touchscreen controller). The Surface RT runs on the Nvidia Tegra3 processor and uses a wide variety of Samsung chips too.

Of course, Microsoft still has to convince users to pay $499 or more for an unproven device. It lacks a convincing integrated content store like Amazon’s, or a hardware reputation, and so is making the ambitious move of relying on an operating system and apps base, to create a business model that delivers high profits from a combined device/media offering.

In that effort, a crown jewel will be the Xbox brand, which represents Microsoft’s only successful hardware platform to date, and is also becoming its premier platform for multiscreen content and cloud services. According to The Verge blog, Microsoft also plans to join Apple, Amazon and Google in the 7-inch tablet sector with a product to be called Xbox Surface, optimized for gaming and with tight integration with the Xbox store and user experience. It would run its own modified OS based on Windows RT and a custom ARM processor. If the report proves true, that would see Microsoft emulating Amazon in several ways ‘ taking advantage of the lower consumer expectations of hardware functionality in the 7-inch space to reduce costs and maintain margins; and fully optimizing the user experience for specific content (games rather than ebooks).

Microsoft is also widely expected to announce its own smartphone next year and according to The Wall Street Journal, it is working with Asian component suppliers on its own smartphone design but has not decided whether to go into mass production. Microsoft declined to comment, but CEO Steve Ballmer told the newspaper: “We’re quite happy this holiday going to market hard with Nokia, Samsung and HTC. Whether we had a plan to do something different or we didn’t have a plan I wouldn’t comment in any dimension.”

At the launch of Windows 8 recently, Ballmer told the BBC: “We have committed ourselves on a path where we will do whatever is required from both hardware and a software innovation perspective and the cloud innovation perspective in order to propel the vision that we have’, fanning the flames of speculation that Microsoft would add a smartphone and other devices to its new Surface tablet range, especially if partner devices such as the Nokia Lumia range disappoint ‘ though it is highly questionable that Microsoft could do better in terms of market and carrier impact.

Microsoft’s other advantage is its presence in the enterprise, and this will be one way it can get close to carriers, which are also seeking greater corporate influence. For instance, the software giant has announced a partnership with Japanese cellco NTT Docomo to develop services for corporate users of Windows 8 tablets (whether Microsoft’s own or others), which will be sold under the Docomo Xi 4G brand.

Microsoft, Apple, Amazon and Google may be prioritizing on increased sales of their content, apps and advertising, but they will not sniff at device volumes either. According to IDC’s latest calculations, worldwide tablet shipments reached 27.8m units during the third quarter, up 49.5% year-on-year and 6.7% on Q212. The iPad remained in the lead with 14m units in Q3, up from 11.1m a year earlier, but its market share is in sharp decline in the face of Android. Android shipments were up to 13.8m from 7.5m a year earlier. The iPad still had just over half the sector (50.4%), but that was down from almost 60% (59.7%) in the year-ago quarter and 65.5% in Q212. Android was up 9.3 percentage points year-on-year to 49.6% of the total, with Samsung the leading Android vendor, selling 5.1m units, followed by Amazon on 2.5m and Asus on 2.4m.

“After a very strong second quarter, Apple saw growth slow as both consumer and commercial (including education) shipments declined, and rumors of a forthcoming iPad mini began to heat up,” said Tom Mainelli, IDC’s research director for tablets. “We believe a sizeable percentage of consumers interested in buying an Apple tablet sat out the third quarter in anticipation of an announcement about the new iPad mini.’ There will be some cannibalization, then, though that may not worry Apple given the high profits attached to its smaller offering. The fairly high price of the mini will still leave Android vendors room to build share in Q4, while Microsoft will start to play too.

It is clear that Amazon is determined to undermine Apple’s leadership in tablets with integrated media, and so far at least, the iPad maker has not resorted to the law courts as it has with number two slate maker, Samsung. Both firms are likely to accelerate their product cycles and widen their distribution in a bid to gain market share.

Consumers will no longer have to wait a full year (or more) between new iPhones and iPads. Only days after the new iPad mini shipped, rumors are already circulating about the next tablet models ‘ not just the much discussed upgrade to the full-sized model, expected around March, but another 7.9-inch variant. This one will sport its bigger cousin’s RetinaDisplay screen, say Chinese supply chain sources.

These report that AU Optronics, the manufacturer of the current iPad Mini’s non-Retina screen, is working on a high resolution display for the successor device, with resolution of 2041 x 536 pixels ‘ the same as the current 9.7-inch iPad HD. On the smaller footprint, that would equate to higher pixel density (over 300ppi versus 264ppi on the HD).

The new mini could be released along with its larger stablemate, but more likely after the summer of 2013 ‘ but many expect Apple will not wait for 12 months to update its line. Indeed, some investors feel it is essential to continued growth that the firm turns out new models more quickly and creates a more multi-faceted portfolio to compete with Samsung’s. An HD iPad mini might be a defensive move ‘ worrying to backers accustomed to seeing Apple always settting the agenda. Many criticisms of the smaller iPad have centered on the rather grainy 163ppi display, which contrasts poorly with the displays of the iPhone 4S and 4, and the larger iPad.

Apple always had a difficult balancing act once it launched a second tablet, and the lower end screen was one clear way to maintain differentiation, keep the larger model more desirable, and avoid excessive cannibalization. Not that the latter is as problematic as it would be for some vendors with less supply chain discipline ‘ recent teardowns suggest that the smaller iPad actually carriers a higher margin than its stablemate, so if new users pick a mini over an HD, it does not hurt Apple’s profits.

The other reason to upgrade the screen on a subsequent mini is to make a clearer contrast with other smaller tablets. There are few signs that consumers outside the iDevice base are convinced by Apple’s claims that the extra 0.9-inches on its screen size make a huge difference to the experience, and this is significant for a gadget that is mainly designed to attract non-traditional Apple buyers. Charging a higher price than Google and Amazon for a device with the same or lower screen quality is tough for Apple when seeking to appeal outside the base which is blindly loyal to its user interface and software.

Meanwhile, a clear criticism of Amazon’s small tablet strategy is that, for a device designed to achieve mass market share at low cost, it does not have wide distribution. Amazon just launched the Kindle Fire HD in some European markets, but it is always cautious about international adventures. This is partly, of course, because its business model relies on supporting the hardware with a full store and integrated user experience, and that is easy to get wrong once multiple languages are involved. However, the retailer is reportedly poised to take on the massive Chinese market, and has won government approval there to sell its Kindle ereaders and tablets. It could go ahead and launch them as early as late November.

Citing an unnamed source close to Amazon China, QQ Tech says the devices will launch with access to the US store, but a Chinese language tablet and shopfront will follow next year. Users of the new Paperwhite ereader have reported finding a Chinese language user guide on the product, which mentions that aftersales service is available from Amazon China provided the gadget was purchased from an authorized dealer in the country.

Chinese launch has been in the works for at least a year ‘ in October 2011, Marc Onetto, the firm’s SVP of worldwide operations, said the company was in talks with the country’s government about introducing the Kindle family. Five devices have now been approved ‘ reportedly the Kindle Keyboard, Touch, Paperwhite, Fire HD and Fire. These will face tougher competition than in the western markets where Kindle dominates its space. There are many Chinese tablets and ereaders at different price points, and several local etailers have broad content platforms, including ecommerce major Dandang, which launched an ereaer for $79 in July, and Baidu, which like Amazon is creating its own Android-based OS, software store and branded devices.

One trend that will worry Apple ‘ because it is one of perception as much as reality ‘ is a rising school of thought among analysts and investors, that it is losing its creative edge. The markets widely credit Apple’s innovation and ‘magic’ with its huge success, often underrating more prosaic, but equally significant, skills such as effective supply chain management and strong retail channels. The death of Steve Jobs inevitably sparked a debate about whether innovation would survive, and worryingly for the company, some are focusing on the iPad mini as a supposed example of the failure of Apple’s creativity impulse ‘ perhaps because Jobs famously criticized the small-sized tablet concept, even though he was later converted and current product launches are still devices conceived on his watch.

But in the latter years of Jobs’ reign, there were already some question marks over whether Apple was innovating quickly enough, or clinging to a single success story like a bigger version of Motorola’s RAZR saga. Apple needs to think more creatively about its tablets, says one commentator, Doubleline Capital’s Jeffrey Gundlach, a famed bond investor. He expects the current downward slide in Apple’s stock ‘ albeit from a record breaking $705 high ‘ to continue for some time, and blames the company’s apparent loss of its legendary ability to innovate, or at least to turn others’ innovations into magic.

Gundlach told CNBC that the stock price, which has fallen by over 20% since September 19 (to $558 on Wednesday), will go as low as $425. Echoing the thoughts of many outside the Apple fan base, he said he was struck by the “obsession” with Apple’s stock. “It seems like every meeting I have, everyone owns it,” he said, adding that he started shorting the stock in April at $610. He particularly believes the iPad mini is an example of the lack of innovation. “Once you start just changing the size of your products, I really think you’re not exactly innovating,” he said.

But other analysts have been far more positive about the possibly belated moves to diversify the range. Topeka Capital’s Brian White said in April that the stock price could reach $1,000 because “an ever expanding portfolio of innovative products” was driving “Apple fever’. The iPhone maker needs to turn that wildly optimistic forecast into reality, in terms of expanding its portfolio for increasingly segmented user bases, if not in terms of the stock price. If it fails to do so, Amazon will be in front of the line to take advantage, even ahead of Samsung and Google.

Android powers 75% of smartphones:

Android powered three-quarters of smartphones shipped during the third quarter, according to IDC’s latest figures. Device shipments with the Google operating system reached a record high of 136m units, 75% of the total of 181.1m smartphones. Android enjoyed 91.5% year-on-year growth, well ahead of the growth rate of 46.4% for the sector as a whole. “Android has been one of the primary growth engines of the smartphone market since it was launched in 2008,” said Ramon Llamas, IDC research manager for mobile phones. “In every year since then, Android has effectively outpaced the market and taken market share from the competition.’ Apple’s iOS, by contrast, saw Q3 shipments of 26.9m, a jump of 57.3% on the year-ago quarter, taking 14.9% share. This could improve in Q4 with the full impact of the iPhone 5. BlackBerry slid to a share of just 4.3%, down from almost 12% the year before, with shipments down from 11.8m to 7.7m. Symbian nosedived from 18.1m units to 4.1m and a share of 2.3%. Windows Phone had just 3.6m shipments or 2% share in Q312 but that was still a 140% year-on-year rise. Ballmer said Windows Phone’s growth will accelerate now WP8 has been launched, with greater harmony with the new Windows 8 (the two share a code base and user interface). CEO Steve Ballmer said at an event in Israel: “With the work we have done with Nokia, HTC, Samsung and others, there is now an opportunity to create really a strong third participant in the smartphone market. We’re still relatively small … I expect the volumes on Windows Phone to really ramp quickly.”

Foxconn cannot meet iPhone 5 demand admits chief:

Apple’s Taiwanese contract manufacturer, Foxconn, is not producing new iPhone 5s as quickly as the vendor needs, claiming the design is a complicated one to produce to the high quality standards imposed by Apple.

Terry Gou, chairman of Foxconn’s parent company Hon Hai, told Reuters: “It’s not easy to make the iPhones. We are falling short of meeting the huge demand.” Although he did not specify the iPhone 5 ‘ and the firm is still churning out 4S and 4 models ‘ the newest addition is running short in many markets, and adopted a new slimline form factor. Many customers now face 3-4 week leadtimes for delivery of their handsets.

He added: ‘We still can’t meet Apple’s quality standards. Market demand is very strong, but we just can’t really fulfill Apple’s requests.”

Last month, an unidentified Foxconn official told The Wall Street Journal that producing the latest iPhone was ‘very complicated’ and that was causing supply issues. He said the smartphone was “the most difficult device that Foxconn has ever assembled’. There are more components than in older models, including the LTE baseband and a new, smaller Lightning port, and all these elements have to be packed into the thinner casing.