Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 November 2012

AT&T gets a 4G vision at last with Project VIP

Verizon Wireless has always claimed the spoils as the LTE pacemaker in the US. Its 4G roll-out has been highly strategic and one of the world’s most advanced, while AT&T has been seen to be a 4G follower, arriving later than its rival and with a less articulated strategic plan. It has convincingly changed that perception now, unveiling its $14bn dollar Project Velocity IP (VIP), which includes acceleration of LTE deployment and fiber-to-the-node, as well as a stepped-up focus on business services.

On the wireless side, the carrier will expand its LTE network to cover 300m POPs by the end of 2014 (99% of the population). The more interesting information focuses on the make-up of that network. It will boost the trend for creating dense high capacity networks using small cells in the public network as well as indoors ‘ a popular concept among carriers worldwide, but one that has so far, in terms of real deployments, been driven by Asia. Early US network upgrades have stuck to traditional cell sizes, but Sprint recently said it would adopt Alcatel-Lucent’s lightRadio as part of a 4G small cell strategy from 2013, and now AT&T says that it will purchase 40,000 small cells in 2013-14, compared with 10,000 new macrocells.

It will also give a significant fillip to DAS (distributed antenna system), a technology which has often been perceived to have been sidelined by femtocells and carrier Wi-Fi as a method of brining wireless data coverage indoors. It has always been more prominent in carrier strategies in the US than elsewhere, with Verizon being a significant deployer, and AT&T will include 1,000 DAS systems in its new network.

The $14bn budget will be split between $8bn for wireless initiatives and $6bn for wireline. Total capital spending, including VIP, will be about $22bn for each of the next three years. The wireline U-Verse network will cover 75% of current customer locations, or 57m people in AT&T’s coverage region, by the end of 2014.

The carrier’s current LTE roll-out is in its 700MHz spectrum but it will chase its capacity and coverage targets by knitting together a range of different frequencies using techniques like carrier aggregation, which will be an important part of the LTE-Advanced standards (AT&T has previously said it will start to deploy LTE-A from later in 2013 in new cells, and it can also be supported in existing LTE base stations via a software upgrade). AT&T has acquired a patchwork of spectrum over the past year or so. Despite failing in its biggest bid for a strong spectrum position, last year’s plan to acquire T-Mobile USA with its AWS and PCS holdings, it has turned to multiple small purchases which fall beneath the radar of antitrust suits. While Verizon has made the bold spectrum move with its purchase of AWS licences from four cablecos and Leap, AT&T has concluded about 40 smaller transactions, gaining additional 700MHz frequencies ‘ including unpaired ones from Qualcomm, which will be used to add downlink capacity using carrier aggregation. It has also added spectrum in AWS and 30MHz in the neglected WCS band in 2.3GHz, and it is eyeing further 700MHz licences which Verizon put up for sale after its cableco deal, even though that would see AT&T ending up with 700MHz holdings in three currently incompatible areas of the band.

But acquiring spectrum wherever it can find it is essential to make Project VIP a reality, even if AT&T, like most carriers, will never again have the ideal situation of holding national harmonized spectrum in just one or two bands. However, capacity is king, and John Donovan, AT&T’s senior EVP of technology and network operations, said the LTE expansion program would rely heavily on a “densification” of the system to increase spectral efficiency, reduce cost of ownership, and support additional services ‘ including VoLTE and Rich Communications Services ‘ as well as better indoor penetration.

Deploying a diverse mixture of spectrum bands and of network technologies, AT&T hopes to leapfrog Verizon and stay ahead of Sprint, which has started to roll out LTE as part of its Network Vision project, also a multimode, multiband roadmap relying on a combination of frequencies and cell sizes. “Our small cell strategy is aggressive,” Donovan said. “We will not just deploy LTE small cells but also across other technologies such as UMTS and HSPA+.” As one of the world’s leading exponents of carrier Wi-Fi to offload traffic from 3G, it is unsurprising that Wi-Fi also features heavily in AT&T’s plan. Although executives largely steered clear of the ‘HetNet’ word, Donovan said small cells integrating both LTE and Wi-Fi would start to be deployed in 2014, with the different air interfaces being linked to a common core ‘ along with the aggregated multiband activities, these changes show AT&T moving towards a true heterogeneous network.

The operator is well aware that investing in new networks purely to improve the customer experience in existing applications will be an unprofitable exercise ‘ the new capabilities and capacity must be harnessed for new revenue streams. The cellco is already a leader in attaching non-consumer connected devices to its networks, enabling services such as machine-to-machine and smart grid, and on its LTE systems, it will focus primarily on growth in four key service areas.

According to AT&T Mobility’s CEO Ralph de la Vega, the first will be the Digital Life home security and automation service, which will launch commercially early next year and is expected to deliver margins of 35% to 40%. Second is an expansion of the mobile premises solution business. This is currently a simple offering ‘ a home phone that uses the wireless network to complete calls, effectively ‘cutting the cord’ and allowing AT&T to penetrate homes where it has no wireline coverage. Future versions of this offering will allow users to add the home phone to their family talk or shared data plans and will add data services.

The third growth area will be mobile payments. AT&T is part of the Isis joint venture with T-Mobile USA and Verizon Wireless, which has started trials in two cities using NFC technology. And fourth will be the connected car. AT&T believes that by 2016, 53% of new cars in the US will be connected.

Project VIP effectively means the end of real investment in DSL and indeed, where users still have copper lines, AT&T increasingly recommends the use of LTE for fixed access if fiber is not available. (It does use DSL for the last mile for its U-verse fiber system in most areas, but is defocusing on standalone copper lines). It says wireless, fiber-to-the-node and business networks deliver 81% of its revenue and are collectively growing at 6% a year, so it is clear where the investment priority must lie, but at the start of 2015, one-quarter of AT&T’s wireline base will still not have U-verse, which points to another strategic significance for LTE investment, to stop defection of DSL customers. While it may be efficient for AT&T to move to an IP-only system, critics say it will be a blow to rural users and to local CLECs which rely on the larger firm’s network ‘ factors which may attract FCC scrutiny or even encourage AT&T to sell off its DSL business as Verizon did.

But the future is fiber/wireless, plus the creation of new revenue streams to run on those IP platforms, as Project VIP clearly illustrates. The initiative certainly provides a more coherent plan, embracing all AT&T’s key businesses, than previous roadmaps, and should boost confidence that Verizon is not the only carrier with a vision. However, question marks always hang over execution when it comes to AT&T, and CEO Randall Stephenson was keen to stress that the firm had learned from past mistakes, including a tendency to rush to support changes before the network was ready. VIP is not a sudden and high risk turnaround but the “logical extensions” of existing strategies. “We are very confident in our ability to execute this plan,’ he said. His reputation, and even his job, will rely on that confidence being justified.