Like rival Nokia Siemens, Alcatel-Lucent aims to recover from a string of poor results by narrowing its focus, exiting non-core businesses and cutting costs. While its reorganization around mobile broadband has started to deliver results at NSN, which had a surprise strong quarter, ALU is still waiting for the elusive turnaround (though it did post smaller losses than analysts had expected).
The thinking is similar at the French firm, which is moving away from the end-to-end, one-stop shop messages of its past, and rivals like Ericsson and Huawei. Instead it will select aspects of the telecoms market where it can compete effectively, and pull away from other sectors, or adopt a channel sales strategy in others.
Much of the burden of the sharpened focus falls on CFO Paul Tufano, who was also appointed to head up operations in September, taking some of the day-to-day responsibilities away from CEO Ben Verwaayen. He said this time that product lines which cannot deliver decent margins will be ‘de-emphasized’, though neither he nor Verwaayen would comment on a target size for a slimmed-down ALU, or which units might be divested. Most analysts think submarine cable and enterprise telephony, which were recently put directly under Tufano’s control, will be first to go.
The firm will exit certain managed services deals, as previously announced, examining at least five contracts which are not delivering strong returns. This could, however, hit annual revenues by about €400m ($513m) eventually, although it would boost margins. ALU is also reviewing its overall operations in 45 countries to see if it makes sense to withdraw and use sales partners instead. In the wireless space, it will focus its efforts mainly on certain large markets, particularly the US and China, and ‘disengage where we can’t make a difference’, as Verwaayen put it. Of course, that could make the vendor dangerously reliant on a few customers or territories ‘ already, AT&T and Verizon generate more than 10% of its revenues, mainly thanks to their large LTE contracts.
The firm has so far been disappointed in a common way for ailing players to generate additional revenues ‘ via their patent portfolios. ALU has been pursuing this route, but the efforts have failed to deliver. An arrangement with patent broker RPX has been renegotiated, and ALU will sign other such partners, and said it will soon announce a senior appointment focused on this area.
Strong points in Q3 included the wireline business, which has benefited from rising investments in fiber broadband and strong European uptake of ALU’s VDSL2 and vectoring technology). ‘We are the only one in vectoring with anything deployed. I can think of only one order we missed in this domain in the past three months,’ said the CEO. Also, the IP division is still a success, with a 30.3% year-on-year increase in sales to €490m ($632m) in the quarter. The new 7950 XRS core router has landed six contracts, only one of which has been announced (with Verizon).
These upsides put more pressure on the mobile division to deliver more convincing results, despite the high profile of ALU’s LTE contracts in the US and its lightRadio small cell platform, which recently gained a deal at Sprint.
In Q3, sales fell 2.8% year-on-year to €3.6bn and the firm swung to a net loss of €146m, reversing year-ago profit of €194m (when the company benefited from a one-time tax gain). The Networks division’s revenues were €2.18bn, down 4.3% against the year-ago quarter, despite the strength of IP. The wireless division had revenues of €837m, down 18.9% due to cautious spending from service providers, while the wireline unit saw revenues up 26.3% to €389m.
Revenue for Software, Services and Solutions was €1.155bn, up 5%.
A major investor concern was cash. ALU burned though €1.03bn in the first nine months of the year, compared with €978m in the same period in 2011, despite a cost reduction program that will see headcount reduced by around 5,500. This concerned shareholders, and Verwaayen responded saying: ‘We are taking action to strengthen our balance sheet and we are reviewing a variety of options’, which will include the asset sales and a ‘reprofiling’ of the company’s debt.
Exane BNP Paribas analyst Alexander Peterc told Bloomberg: ‘Alcatel-Lucent is now a balance sheet story. This is a first signal to shareholders ahead of a significant dilution of equity holders. Asset disposals would, likewise, strongly diminish Alcatel’s future cash generation.’ He thinks ALU needs to make far more drastic cuts, axing an additional 10,000 jobs in order to compete with more efficient rivals. Bloomberg says ALU’s revenue per employee is €49,700, 14% less than NSN or Ericsson, even after the 5,500 job cuts announced in October.