It has really been a long time coming, but now at last there are signs regulators are edging towards allowing use of white spaces freed up by analog TV switch-off for broadband services. In the UK, Ofcom has just published a framework specifying how white spaces should be run within existing UHF spectrum used for digital terrestrial television (DTT), while an EU project to develop a prototype will conclude at the end of the year. That will coincide with the deadline for completion of digital switchover in most EU countries, although Ofcom seems to be going its own way, though with a similar set of specifications.
White spaces are parts of the radio spectrum in the UHF band that have been allocated to a service but not used in a particular location. The space has been freed up by digital switchover, since digital transmissions at higher signal strengths can be packed into smaller channels. The challenge is to allow these white spaces, whose availability varies between locations according to allocations in the area, to be used without interfering with terrestrial TV or other services. This partly explains the slow pace of evolution of a white space framework.
Ofcom has launched a seven-week consultation to allow feedback on its technical specification for wireless communication protocols between the devices, and the communications protocols between the devices and databases. The objective is to minimize the impact of interference, although why Ofcom is not exploiting the work that has been done by the EU is unclear. The Ofcom specification proposes statutory instruments including a draft interface requirement (IR) document, and a draft voluntary national specification (VNS).
But this does seem to duplicate work that has been done by the EU’s COGEU (Cognitive radio systems for efficient sharing of TV white spaces in European context) project, which is part of its Digital Agenda for Europe actions aimed at establishing a common EU policy for radio spectrum. This project is also contributing to the IEEE 1900.6 Working Group on Spectrum Sensing Interfaces and Data Structures for Dynamic Spectrum Access and other Advanced Radio Communication Systems. This standard will enable a common approach to exploiting white spaces without interfering with existing services.
The essential idea of the EU scheme is to enable end devices to negotiate via a broker, which allocates available spectrum according to needs or perhaps willingness to pay. COGEU has also developed a system of spectrum trading in which white spaces are assigned for free access in given areas, but with a secondary market run by a broker that allocates remaining spectrum according to needs and the reasons for requiring bandwidth.
This accords with the latest thinking on use of white spaces, and expands on Ofcom’s ideas of having ‘white space devices’ (WSDs), usually routers, capable of detecting the presence of unused areas of spectrum. The original US idea was that WSDs would be equipped with databases listing all TV stations in the area, so that they would know the areas of spectrum to avoid in order not to interfere with them. But this was rejected as impractical, partly because the US allocates spectrum regionally in an entirely different way from the UK and most of Europe. So here more focus has been made on a detect and avoid process, operating in real time, by accessing external databases that are continually updated, which is what Ofcom is now proposing.
These databases will be funded by the industry, and designed to ensure that a given slice of spectrum is not already being used in the region of a device requesting to use it. This means in turn that such devices must share information such as their power and precise location with the database, which in turn will inform the device which bands it can transmit data in. The spectrum Ofcom is dealing with is in the range 470 MHz to 790MHz.
This then serves as a framework for white space applications, with one being rural Wi-Fi access. This could use large Wi-Fi cells, perhaps exploiting a version of the standard developed by Microsoft called WiFi-NC (Narrow Channel), which works a bit like OFDM in so far as it splits the spectrum up into small chunks. The operation is very different in that instead of using a conventional Wi-Fi radio, it has an array of tiny, low-data rate transmitters and receivers. Each of these broadcasts and receives in a different, narrow, range of spectrum. They are then bundled, in effect multiplexed, together, to provide the throughput of a normal Wi-Fi radio, but with the ability to switch between white-space frequencies far more efficiently.
It also operates at the lower frequencies and therefore greater range and penetration of digital terrestrial, rather than the 2.4GHz and 5GHz, of conventional Wi-Fi. This has the potential to turn Wi-Fi into a powerful access technology that may prove more efficient than 4G for delivering mobile broadband services, although these are early days.
Another interesting application for white spaces could be large events, which require spectrum on a temporary basis locally for accessing video and broadband, where again 4G could find it hard to cope. The EU’s COGEU has developed Program Marking and Special Event (PMSE) specifications designed to enable high QoE for broadcasting at large events, exploiting the aforementioned secondary trading model to allocate bandwidth.
It remains to be seen whether white spaces will revolutionize wireless services as its advocates predict, changing the whole way spectrum is managed and allocated, leading to continuous recycling to ensure that none is wasted. But the techniques that overcome the limitations, such as the uncertainty over availability of spectrum in a given area, suggest it could play a major part in broadband delivery, or those two opposite use cases, remote communities, and large events where there is temporarily high contention for bandwidth.
Rethink Research recently published a comprehensive report on global White Space Devices deployment, including forecasts, technical analysis and regulatory updates. For more information, go to www.rethinkresearch.biz/wsds or contact [email protected].