Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 December 2012

Shift in smartphone pricing will transform competitive landscape from 2013

Nearing the end of the year always prompts thoughts of how the world will change in the coming year, and one report focused the mind in terms of the smartphone landscape of 2013 and beyond. The shift of these devices from the premium market to the midrange has been gathering pace, but by 2017, over half will be priced below $150 as devices commoditize and growth is focused on emerging economies, and only one-third will be over $250. This is just one prediction on these lines (from Informa), but the trend is clear to all. The question is how the major vendors will adapt to a world where the smartphone is a low cost consumer item.

Some answers are obvious ‘ greater influence for local, low cost suppliers in the major areas of adoption, such as India and China; greater reliance by established brands on putting their brand and user experience on ODM hardware; the search for new premium form factors to boost profits. Knock-on effects will include the acceleration of carriers ending subsidies, as consumers find the upfront price tag of a smartphone easier to swallow.

The trend will certainly benefit Android, which was conceived as a platform that could be adapted for all kinds of hardware designs and price points by different vendors. And Samsung will be well placed to profit from the shift in emphasis, since it is well accustomed to serving low cost as well as premium segments, and to pushing one year’s luxury design down to be the next year’s cheap gadget.

Nokia used to be good at that too, but its declining scale have made its supply chain less well suited to the mass market, and it is stuck with a Windows platform which is decidedly high end in concept. The same is even more true of Apple, which could have decided to stick with premium users ‘ in whatever form factor it could attract them ‘ but has recently been chasing mass market share. Other vendors have deliberately abandoned the lower cost markets to focus on expensive smartphones ‘ Motorola Mobility, Sony Mobile and to some extent HTC ‘ and now face a new dilemma, between staying at the premium end, which will mean making a splash with new formats such as tablets and hybrids, or adapting their components and margins yet again to return to the midrange.

That will be tough, though, since the mass segment they vacated in the hunt for better margins has been quickly filled by the up-and-coming big brands, mainly from China ‘ ZTE, Huawei and Lenovo are all coming up from the white label and featurephone sectors with the promise of top end specs at mass market prices.

Huawei seemed to rub salt in Nokia’s wounds this week when it announced it was opening its latest handset R&D center in the former leader’s back yard in Helsinki, Finland. Huawei will open a smartphone development site ther, part of a program to double the size of its R&D activities in Europe, and perhaps tap into some former Nokia talent.

Huawei plans to expand its R&D staff in Europe to 14,000 people over the next 3-5 years, from around 7,000 today. It says it will invest €700m over five years in the Finnish location, its eleventh research center in Europe and the second to focus on devices rather than network infrastructure. But the Chinese firm’s handset business, which last year accounted for about 20% of its revenue, grew 37% year-on-year in 2011, far faster than its other businesses. The new team will work on a user experience to overlay Android and Windows Phone, not just hardware.

All these trends will continue to make it difficult for the struggling second tier players ‘ LG, Sony Mobile, RIM and HTC ‘ to reverse their fortunes and start to steal share back from Samsung, while simultaneously fending off Huawei. But perhaps the biggest challenges face the former titans of the handset space, Motorola Mobility (now Google) and Nokia, while there are even storm clouds on the horizon for Apple.

Some of Motorola’s problems are long standing ‘ since it failed to find a convincing follow-up for its RAZR smash hit; got burned with a race into the ultra-low cost market; and ended up lossmaking and over-reliant on one key customer (Verizon) to keep it relevant in Android. Its shareholders were saved by Google’s desire for more patents, but having acquired Motorola Mobility, the unit has a new set of problems. There is continuing uncertainty over whether the search giant will hang onto the hardware activities now it has the patents (it is already selling off the set-top box unit), and despite Google’s claims to be running its new subsidiary at arm’s length, in reality the parent’s own challenges have a direct impact on its handset division.

Motorola’s freedom of movement in taking on rivals is severely constrained by two Google imperatives ‘ to minimize the extent to which the losses and overheads of Motorola skew its own results, and skew its services-based economics; and to avoid conflicts of interests with other Android partners, especially those, like Samsung, which have greater power to drive Android growth than Motorola itself.

The most likely (and sensible) role for Motorola in future would be as a center of development and innovation in device form factors and mobile user experiences, allowing Google to enhance its expertise in these areas and boost its current bid to reassert control over the Android UE. However, while an R&D remit has been confirmed at the handset unit, the role of being a showcase for the Google Android experience, and deliver an integrated hardware/software product, Apple-style, has largely gone to the Nexus activity. And that has, so far, excluded Motorola. Samsung, HTC, LG and Asus have all had slots in the Nexus line-up, and Sony Mobile has been rumored for one too. But giving Motorola too large a role would, again, risk alienating other OEMs.

Given the ambiguous value of Motorola’s smartphone business to its new parent, it is unsurprising that Google is mainly focusing on tapping into the IPR and the engineering expertise, and otherwise cutting costs to the bone. This week, it continued to slash costs, in line with plans to limit Motorola’s reach in terms of geographies and range of products ‘ to the extent that many question whether it will continue to exist at all as a conventional handset maker, morphing entirely into an R&D center.

In its latest moves, Google is pulling its subsidiary out of South Korea and transferring several factories to contract manufacturer Flextronics. It also appears to have virtually exited India, having shut down its website there earlier this month. Even before the acquisition by Google, Motorola had significantly reduced the number of geographies where it was actively selling its products, focusing mainly on the Americas and China, though last year there were some moves to expand again in Europe.

Now it has signed a deal with Flextronics to take over its Chinese factories in Tianjin and run its Brazilian facility in Jaguariuna. Employees and assets will transfer to Flextronics once the arrangement closes, expected in the first half of 2013. The agreement includes a manufacturing and services agreement between the two companies for Android mobile devices. Financial terms weren’t disclosed.

‘The agreement with Flextronics is an important step forward for us in transforming our overall supply chain into a competitive advantage for Motorola Mobility,’ said Mark Randall, SVP of supply chain and operations.

Press reports in India indicate that Motorola has also suspended operations at its manufacturing location in Chennai. And it has confirmed it is shutting down handset R&D, sales and marketing activities in South Korea, with the loss of 500 local jobs. ‘The changes in Korea reflect our plans to consolidate our global R&D efforts to foster collaboration, and to focus more attention on markets where we are best positioned to compete effectively,’ Motorola said in a statement.

In August Google announced plans to reduce the Motorola Mobility workforce by 20% (about 4,000 jobs). And according to Reuters, it has received several offers for the set-top box unit, including one from UK set-top vendor Pace, and several private equity firms.

Nokia, too, has been slashing staff and costs recently as it tries to adjust its structure and overheads to the new realities of being a falling star, and no longer a market leader. However, it is unlikely to follow the strategy of rivals like Motorola and shrink itself into a premium smartphone niche. Its strengths remain in the midmarket, in terms of brand recognition, product design and channels to market. That is why it is ironic that it should be using the mobile OS that is perhaps the most focused on the high end, and that mismatch is a challenge for Nokia going into 2013.

It clearly is determined to continue to address its core midmarket, which provides an essential, if dwindling, revenue base while the firm struggles to make its mark at the high end. Every time it launches a bighitting Lumia flagship, that is accompanied by a more modest version for the mass market, often shipping first in a major Nokia emerging market like India. Recently, for instance, it announced a version of its top end Lumia 920 for China Mobile, while also unveiling the decidedly midrange Lumia 620, which has an unsubsidized price of $249 compared to the 920T’s $700-plus.

And Nokia reportedly put intense pressure on Microsoft to accelerate the release of ‘Tango’, the version of Windows Phone 7 for lower specified handsets, last year, and is likely to keep this strand alive despite the advent of WP8, which is not backwards compatible. Taiwan’s Digitimes recently reported that Nokia would still be ordering Tango handsets from ODMs well into 2013, rather than upgrading its midrange models to WP8 in emerging economies, and could even develop WP7.5 further as a midtier OS in its own right.

However, even Tango remains a compromise in the truly mass market. What Nokia still needs is an OS to sit between Windows Phone and Series 40 and provide a viable alternative to Android for the first time smartphone user or the Symbian refugee. It cancelled various projects in this area, including the impressive-sounding Meltemi, although recently rumors abounded that it would create another Linux-based OS, after it posted an advert for Linux experts to work on ‘exciting new products for ‘mobile phone technology’.

If Nokia does produce a new, low end OS ‘ which would also likely take over S40 in time ‘ this would probably be one of the new-look browser-based platforms, similar to Mozilla’s Firefox Mobile OS. These are well suited to low end webphones ‘ as seen in Telefonica’s embrace of the upcoming Mozilla system for a launch in Brazil. And Nokia has been an advanced innovator in technologies to reduce the burden of mobile internet processing on the device, by carrying out much of the hard work in the cloud.

Such a platform could really put wings under Nokia’s undersung handset jewels, the Asha range of featurephones. The Finnish vendor said, when it launched the most recent models (205 and 206) that it was ‘reinventing the featurephone’, and for once the marketing talk was not wrong. In reality, these devices are not featurephones in the conventional sense, but have access to the app store, full web capabilities, a camera integrated with social networking features, and so on. With a souped-up web OS of its own, rather than the ageing S40, Asha could be a serious challenge to Android in the markets where the Nokia brand ‘ along with its concentration on localized content and its expertise in imaging and location ‘ still counts for more than the multitude of names pushing Android devices.

At the other end of the scale, Apple has dilemmas of its own in terms of how far to push into the mass market. While it has made significant steps in this direction with iPhones distributed through virtually every carrier, and the iPad mini, these products are still not by any means ‘cheap’. But the difficult balance between volume and margin/premium image is only one of the many factors which may have been battering the Apple stock in a highly unusual way over recent weeks. The shares remain hugely valuable, at well over $500, but any signs of shaking confidence in the US’s golden company has a major knock-on effect on the sector ‘ and suggests that, slowly but surely, Apple will cease to be the mobile juggernaut it has been for the past five years.

One uncharacteristically negative analyst, Peter Misek of Jefferies, summed up the reasons behind the panic attacks on Wall Street, as he cut his target price for Apple’s stock to $800 from $900. He told clients the iPhone maker’s financial results for this quarter and the next should be well above analysts’ expectations, but nevertheless, there were looming factors of decelerating unit sales, price declines, and gross margin pressure from 2013. He expects one Apple response to center on speeding up the product cycle. The firm already introduced two new tablet models less than a year after the iPad HD, and Misek thinks it will abandon its one-a-year strategy for the iPhone too, and bring out the next version around June. This ‘iPhone 5S’ could feature a new super HD screen, perhaps using Sharp’s IGZO technology; improved camera and battery life; up to 128Gbytes of flash storage; and NFC technology, he speculates.

He also believes Apple will bite the bullet of collapsing smartphone prices and bring out a low cost iPhone priced around $200 to $250. Like the iPad mini, this would be designed to appeal to consumers for whom the main device is out of reach, but not to cannibalize the sales or brand quality of the primary offering.

A difficult balance, but one which Apple will have to strike skilfully if it is to remain a mainstream handset player as well as carving out growth in new form factors. As is so often the case, China will be a testing ground, and one factor which hit Apple stock last week was Nokia’s announcement of a deal with China Mobile for the first Windows Phone 8 smartphone in the country. Apple, of course, has repeatedly failed to secure an iPhone contract with the biggest Chinese cellco. While Nokia is no threat to Apple either in brand awareness or volume terms at the moment, it keeps sniping away at the iDevice maker, in a way it was not doing two years ago. The China win and the stark contrast between iOS Maps and Nokia Maps are just two examples which give some faint hope that the Finnish firm’s ability to wake up and be a thorn in Apple’s side after all may not be dead. A strong Nokia is needed to check the power of Apple and Google, and the general shift to commodity smartphones with neat web capabilities should play to the Finn’s strengths, forcing some innovative thinking from the big two.