Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 December 2012

As STMicro pulls out of STE, can anyone threaten Qualcomm in LTE next year?

For several quarters, mobile devices have been the chief ‘ sometimes virtually the only ‘ driver of growth in the semiconductor industry. Yet recent times have seen a flight away from this market, with Texas Instruments, Freescale, Analog Devices and now perhaps STMicro moving their attention from smartphones to the internet of things ‘ an area expected to deliver even higher growth from next year, and less dominated by Qualcomm. Of course, other companies have entered the space, namely Intel and Nvidia, while yet more are pushing up from low end handset chips to the superphone space, including Broadcom and MediaTek. It will certainly be a time of flux for the handset chip providers in 2013, and one which two spin-offs from broader semiconductor giants, ST-Ericsson and Renesas Mobile, may struggle to survive.

The break-up of the struggling ST-Ericsson joint venture, has been rumored for the past year, and it seems one of its parents, STMicro, will make the first move. The European silicon giant is going through a major rethink of its strategy as it faces weak demand and rising Asian competition in many chip markets, and aims to sell its stake in STE next year.

The firm said it wants to offload its 50% stake by the third quarter to help boost its profitability. STE has been a drag on profits since it was formed in 2009 from the merger of Ericsson Mobile Platforms and STMicro’s existing mobile venture with NXP. Meanwhile STMicro’s CEO, Carlo Bozotti, has presided over a 60% decline in share price since he took over eight years ago.

Now he says the current cost cutting program at STMicro will boost operating margin quickly to a targeted 10%, as the firm works to slash opex to $600m to $650m per quarter by the start of 2014. As part of that process, STMicro says it is now in talks with Ericsson about its exit. Ericsson said in a statement it will work with its partner to find a ‘suitable strategic solution’ for the venture.

As ST-Ericsson’s position comes under rising pressure from Qualcomm’s dominance and new mobile players like Nvidia, its co-parent is focusing on other areas where it sees more growth, such as machine-to-machine sectors.

It is unlikely Ericsson would buy out its partner since mobile processors are non-core to its business, which is focused on infrastructure and, increasingly, services and carrier IP platforms. In April, STE said it would eliminate 1,700 jobs and transfer some product development to STMicro to cut costs.

The venture could attract a new partner, or a complete buy-out, from a company which needs integrated modem/processor technology ‘ if this could be acquired at a low price, given that STE’s customer roster for its new Thor, NovaThor and ModAp platforms remains short. All-in-one SoCs with the processor, GPU and baseband on one chip are the biggest growth area in smartphones as they reduce cost and power consumption, and this has led to a scramble for integrated elements so that other players can challenge Qualcomm’s dominance here. Nvidia bought baseband technology with Icera, though has not fully incorporated it with its processors yet, while Intel did the same via Infineon Wireless.

Broadcom, which is edging towards an integrated SoC for the high end, might also look to accelerate its efforts with an acquisition. But for now, STE’s CEO, Didier Lamouche, insists the current turnaround strategy will not change in light of STMicro’s decisions. In a statement, he said STE would continue to develop full mobile platforms as well as tapping into its particular expertise in LTE modem capabilities, especially in the TDD flavor for China. “We have been executing steadily and aggressively on our strategy and delivered on our commitments,” he said. ‘We have started to deliver integrated ModAp platforms to our lead customers and testing in-the-field of our cutting edge LTE modem, as well as introducing a disruptive technology for the mobile market as we committed earlier this year.’

The NovaThor single-chip modem/processor system, which is implemented in STMicro’s advanced 28nm silicon-on-insulator CMOS process, is now sampling. But as well as having to cope with the new level of uncertainty about its future ownership and manufacturing deals, STE is growing short of time to turn its advanced new technologies into gold. In the third quarter it announced a net loss of $190m on sales revenue of $359m, with debts to its parent companies of $1.39bn.

One of the problems for STE, and any vendor challenging Qualcomm, is that the number of slots available is shrinking as a percentage of the smartphone market. Apple and Samsung are increasing their shares, and neither are major buyers of external silicon. Apple uses Qualcomm modems and its own processors, though this begs the question of whether the firm will need a single-chip solution in future, especially for rumored low end iPhones. That could see it acquiring or licensing modem technology to integrate with its A6 CPU, or ‘ as some have speculated ‘ turning to Intel for a combined Atom/Infineon system, in return for guaranteed manufacturing capacity. For now, though, Apple is a closed door for SoCs, while Samsung is increasingly relying on its own processors and modems.

To make things worse, while companies may see hope in the rise of alternative handset suppliers, some of these, too, are aiming for baseband and even processor self-sufficiency, as seen at Huawei’s HiSilicon unit.

As well as the power of Qualcomm, that is another reason why there is so little breathing space for other chip providers despite the growth in smartphones. STE is not the only one suffering ‘ Renesas Mobile, which also has a parent in deep transition, was one of the first to deliver an integrated LTE/processor offering, but has been very quiet about actual sales, though its 4G modem has been certified by AT&T and NTT Docomo. VP of sales and marketing Manfred Schlett told EETimes that products are coming, but they are not yet commercial, and admitted “LTE design-in opportunities are still quite limited’. Following a single-chip, dual-core ARM A9-based apps processor, combined with its LTE/3G modem, Renesas Mobile will announce this year a quad-core, single-chip multi-standard LTE modem/apps processor based on dual ARM A15 and dual A7 cores. It says it will come into its own when LTE hits the mass market, but as at STE, it needs that to happen quickly to rescue its fortunes, especially with its parent firm undergoing intense financial turmoil. Its urgency is increased because it opted to focus entirely on LTE and does not have a 3G /CPU offering, which Schlett says would have made it into ‘just another apps processor/modem company ‘ like ST-Ericsson or MediaTek’.

As to MediaTek itself, it is trying to break away from being ‘just another’ modem company, and to push itself into the high end, taking a direct hit at Qualcomm Snapdragon. The Taiwanese firm is the second largest cellphone baseband vendor thanks to its huge presence in low cost Chinese handsets, but has been steadily expanding into higher value 3G and 4G products. It has now joined the race for quad-core mobile apps processors, sampling a quad-core processor, integrated with a multimode modem, ahead of its US rival.

MediaTek’s general manager for business development, Finbarr Moynihan, said this is the first single-chip combination of quad-core processor and baseband, though Qualcomm will not be far behind, having unveiled its own quad-core/modem offerings last week. But the Taiwan company says it will get to market first. Its system-on-chip, based on the ARM A7 processor core, is called the MT6589 and is sampling now, with mass production scheduled for the first quarter of 2013. Moynihan says that the company has a customer shipping handsets including the new chip in January, while Qualcomm’s alternative will start sampling in the second quarter of next year, with volume production scheduled for the second half of 2013.

The initial customer could be assumed to be targeting China Mobile, since the first SoC, fabricated using a 28nm process, integrates a multimode HSPA+/TD‐SCDMA modem. It also includes a graphics processors based on the PowerVR Series5XT core from Imagination Technologies.

MediaTek is the fastest growing smartphone chip supplier ‘ it says its shipments in this category have risen more than tenfold this year, from 10m units in 2011 to 110m units. Much of that growth has rested on the company’s single-core MT6577 and dual-core MT6577 chips, targeted at the entry level and midrange, sub-$200 smartphone sector. But with the new chip, MediaTek aims to move up the value chain.

Meanwhile, just as MediaTek is building on its mass market volumes to shift up the value chain, Broadcom said this week that it is also moving up from its traditional midrange market to sample LTE basebands, and eventually integrated app processors too.

CEO Scott McGregor told investors: “We need to be there. We’re not there today’, though he warned that market growth in 2013 would be ‘muted’. Broadcom expects to tape out 50 new SoCs in 2012. ‘This is the engine of Broadcom’s growth, a large part of what you get for spending $2bn in R&D,’ said McGregor. The company wants to add higher margin elements to its traditional stronghold in combo handset chips, which incorporate Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, GPS, NFC and other combinations of radios ‘ and where Marvell and TI are also powerful.

However, these chips are low cost (about $3 to $6 per handset), while the baseband/processor product is typically $10 to $30. ‘We have the opportunity to quintuple revenue per platform, so it’s an imperative to put together all the technologies in the smartphone,’ including the processor SoC, power management unit and RF, McGregor added. ‘We believe the vast majority of all phones will integrate [basebands and apps processors] over time.’