Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 December 2012

Clearwire bid will boost Sprint’s viability as a third way in American 4G

Rumors and intrigue continue to abound in the bid to create a viable third 4G player in the US. Most of these focus on the alliances Sprint may make to strengthen its ability to challenge the big two. It is bidding to take full control of its Clearwire venture, even before the closure of its tie-up with Japan’s Softbank, and could also form a pact with pay-TV operator Dish Network, which has just got permission to roll out LTE in its mobile satellite spectrum.

Permission for Dish to build terrestrial LTE in its AWS-4 frequencies came from the FCC this week, despite clashes with Sprint over possible interference with adjacent frequencies. Those disputes could actually lead to network or spectrum sharing agreement between the two firms, as Sprint builds the power base to challenge Verizon and AT&T. Key to this effort will be approval for Softbank of Japan’s plan to take a 70% stake in the US cellco, which will bring funds and expertise to its LTE plans.

Dish has got the critical FCC approval it needs to become a cellular operator, with the green light to deploy terrestrial LTE services in its mobile satellite or AWS-4 spectrum at 2GHz. This has the advantage of being further away from GPS receivers ‘ the factor which scuppered a similar LTE/satellite plan from LightSquared ‘ but it is close to the PCS H block which is likely to go to Sprint when it is auctioned next year.

The FCC also set the wheels in motion for that sale, and to mitigate interference risks, denied Dish’s request to keep the higher transmission power allowed in satellite bands when it deploys LTE-Advanced. That would have increased the value of the spectrum by allowing Dish to build a more powerful and cost effective network ‘ many analysts still question the company’s commitment to building out 4G and believe, now the bands have approval to be refarmed for mobile broadband, it will sell on the licences, perhaps to Sprint.

Also, after heated discussions in recent months, Dish eventually agreed to designate the lowest 5MHz of its uplink spectrum (2000-2005MHz) as a guard band to protect the H Block, provided that safeguards were guaranteed to ensure that the remaining 15MHz of its uplink spectrum (2005-2020MHz) can be built out as fully and quickly as possible.

‘Following a more thorough review of the order and its technical details, Dish will consider its strategic options and the optimal approach to put this spectrum to use for the benefit of consumers,’ said SVP and senior counsel Jeff Blum in a statement following the FCC decisions.

Meanwhile, Sprint may have got its way over transmit power levels in Dish’s network, but it has other challenges to face. One is to boost its spectrum position further for 4G, and that has led it to bid to buy out its fellow shareholders in Clearwire, offering $2.1bn to take full control of an entity which is rich in spectrum, though short on financing.

While Clearwire was initially the focus of Sprint’s attempt to pre-empt the big two US carriers in 4G, by rolling out WiMAX before LTE was market-ready, once that strategy failed the two firms have had a fractious relationship. When Sprint unveiled its own LTE roll-out plans, as part of its ambitious Network Vision project, it seemed to be sidelining Clearwire. However, the failure of a proposed deal with LightSquared and the general US dash for spectrum has made the smaller company’s plentiful holdings in the 2.5GHz band far more attractive.

Sprint recently said it would not make a firm decision about Clearwire until the completion of its agreement with Japan’s Softbank, which plans to take a 70% holding in the US carrier. However, it has now accelerated its plans. These will need both US regulatory and Softbank approval, but the latter is likely to be forthcoming ‘ the Japanese cellco is already a veteran in building out 4G in different bands including 2.5GHz TDD spectrum similar to Clearwire’s.

Sprint is now offering $2.90 a share for the 48.3% of Clearwire that it does not already own, which values the venture around $4.2bn and represents a 5% premium on its closing stock price on Wednesday (though a 20% premium on its price on Monday, since the price has leapt on the Sprint takeover rumors). Some analysts think it will have to up the price, given the value of the spectrum holdings.

Shortly after the Softbank deal was announced in October, Sprint bought a small stake in Clearwire to give it majority equity control, though this did not give it full control of the operations and spectrum, which are run by a committee. The main shareholders which will need to sell their stakes to Sprint are Intel and Comcast, thought to hold about 12.4% between them, plus BrightHouse Networks. The other founding partners in the joint venture, Google and Comcast, have already sold their shareholdings.

Sprint has sent its proposal to Softbank for review, according to an SEC filing today. The US firm said last month that it would delay a proxy statement describing the Softbank deal until December 21, which, it now seems, was necessary to enable the Clearwire talks to continue to resolution.

Despite the disputes with Dish, Sprint may end up partnering with the satellite player.
An alliance between the two firms would potentially create cooperation in a key area of mobile spectrum, and increase the attraction of Sprint’s ragbag of frequencies. The deal under discussion would boost Sprint’s spectrum position by giving it access to Dish’s currently unused frequencies, either for a fee or a revenue share. This could be a conventional network sharing or roaming deal, or Dish could step back from building out at all and leave that to Sprint, which can support a range of bands and air interfaces via its Network Vision flexible base station architecture.

Dish has always said it needs a partner to be viable, if it looks to be a full mobile carrier rather than simply adding wireless access to its TV offerings. It would also enable it to get into the market earlier than 2016, the date when it expects its LTE-Advanced network to be ready for use. Its CEO Joe Clayton said: ‘We speak with everybody’, although discussions with partners were on hold while Dish waited for its FCC ruling. ‘We are open to spectrum hosting opportunities with other spectrum holders who can’t or don’t want to build a network for their spectrum,’ a Sprint spokesperson told Bloomberg.

Meanwhile, the FCC continues to hunt for further sources of new mobile spectrum, and increasingly these will fall outside the traditional auctions and ownership structures of the established cellcos, and will be available to a large number of service providers through shared or unlicensed models.

The white spaces in TV spectrum are a good example, as it the 3.5GHz band, which the FCC wants to turn into a designated frequency for small cells, on a shared basis. The agency has issued more details of its proposals in this direction, though these would have to share space with incumbent users such as radar.

FCC chairman Julius Genachowski told a US Senate hearing on Wednesday: “Later today I expect my colleagues and myself to approve 100MHz of spectrum in the 3.5GHz band for broadband.” In its ‘notice of proposed rulemaking’, the agency repeated its enthusiasm for adding this spectrum to its targets for new mobile broadband capacity. The high frequencies are problematic for conventional cellular deployments because they have short range and poor indoor penetration, but provide significant capacity and are well suited to small base stations, many of which are deployed inside.

The FCC note said: “The 3.5GHz band appears to be an ideal band in which to propose small cell deployments and shared spectrum use. Deploying 10 small cells in a location in place of a single macrocell could result in a tenfold increase in capacity.”

Under the FCC proposals, priority tiers would be established within the 100MHz of spectrum, for federal and local government use. The incumbent government and satellite users would be in the top tier, and when their applications are using any part of the spectrum, all other users would be offline. The second tier would be reserved for hospitals, utilities, government facilities and public safety agencies, which would be given priority access in specified geographic areas. The third tier would be open to anyone ‘ established operators or other providers ‘ to deploy small cells, which would use the ‘spectral gaps’ between the public sector services. These firms would use a dynamic spectrum database, similar to the one set up for the white spaces in the TV band, to know when and where frequencies were free for their transmissions.

However, there will be no quick decisions. There will be a long period of comment and response to the recommendations, lasting well into next spring, and the FCC has not set a firm timescale for a final decision.

So far, T-Mobile USA has come out in support of the plan and kicked off a spectrum sharing trial with government users, but the two biggest carriers are concerned at the implications of having to share the band with other operators and with federal incumbents ‘ both the technical complexities, and the prospect of rivals gaining access to broadband capacity at low cost, when they have invested heavily in their own bands.

Grant Seiffert, president of the TIA (Telecommunications Industry Association) commented in a statement: ‘The FCC’s adoption of the NPRM is a commendable and significant step towards addressing the looming spectrum crunch and meeting the national goal of making 500MHz newly available for broadband use within 10 years. After careful and exhaustive planning to avoid harmful interference occurrences within and surrounding it, we believe that the 3.5GHz band could be used advantageously for small cell use, and that more efficient use of this band could help decrease congestion in other bands.’

Another innovative option may come from another holder of mobile satellite spectrum, Globalstar. The operator petitioned the FCC last month to allow it to use its MSS frequencies for LTE, in a similar way to Dish, but more creatively, it is also proposing a terrestrial low power service (TLPS) to be deployed before the FD-LTE system, which would offer mobile operators access to a private, licensed network for additional capacity ‘ but using the usually unlicensed 802.11 technology.

According to John Dooley, managing director at investment firm and Globalstar partner Jarvinian, the ‘private Wi-Fi’ plan would add 22MHz of vacant spectrum to 802.11 capacity, and claims the FCC is enthusiastic about the idea.

Globalstar is licensed to provide mobile satellite service in the ‘Lower Big LEO’ band (1610-1618.725MHz) for uplink and the ‘Upper Big LEO band (2483.5-2500MHz) for downlink. Under its proposals, the TPLS network would operate in the latter, which is next to the current 2.4GHz Wi-Fi airwaves, and would also use adjacent, and underused, ISM (industrial, scientific and medical) spectrum at 2473-2483.5MHz, which is licence-exempt. Existing Wi-Fi devices could access the new frequencies with just a firmware update.

For carrier partners, the advantage would be to support this huge base of devices while being able to offer better speeds and reliability than on free-for-all, and sometimes congested, 2.4GHz frequencies. “You have a network controlled service but you’re using what was otherwise a public standard architecture,” Dooley explained in an interview. The TPLS capacity could be licensed on an exclusive basis or to several partners, and the revenues would help fund the build-out of LTE in the rest of the Globalstar spectrum.

Despite all these plans and proposals, some industry majors think the FCC is not moving quickly enough in pursuing new frequencies and new spectrum ownership structures. This week, Apple, RIM and Ericsson led a group of hi-tech companies in sending a letter to Congress, urging lawmakers to open up more spectrum for mobile broadband. The group, called the High Tech Spectrum Coalition ‘ last seen lobbying for the TV white spaces to be opened up ‘ is now pushing for an incentive auction of broadcast TV spectrum soon and for more schemes for spectrum sharing with federal agencies. The coalition’s members also include Alcatel-Lucent, Cisco, Intel, Nokia, Qualcomm, Samsung and several trade groups

“Now is the time to ensure the incentive auctions are as robust and successful as possible at liberating spectrum,” the companies said in the letter. “We should also turn our collective attention on ways to reap the economic benefits of underutilized federal spectrum assets.” The letter was timed to coincide with the Congressional hearing in the House Energy and Commerce Committee on spectrum.