Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 December 2012

Nokia and Apple go head-to-head, and this time Nokia can win

Specialized personal navigation device (PND) makers have been hit hard by the arrival of smarpthone-based mapping systems from Nokia, Google and others. But as the fiasco of the Apple Maps launch shows, it takes considerable time and investment to build a navigation platform and the iOS maker may be looking to accelerate the process by acquiring TomTom ‘ as others are speculating that Nokia could take its success with mapping software into specialist devices and fully fledged in-car systems. Such trends could position Apple and Nokia against one another, but this time in a war that the Finnish vendor can certainly win.

In the week that Google Maps returned to the iOS App Store ‘ after Apple replaced it with its own offering as the default option on iDevices ‘ Apple CEO Tim Cook insisted in his first TV interview as chief that his firm was ‘putting the weight of the company behind correcting’ the problems. That weight might include spending some Apple cash on TomTom, the Dutch navigation specialist whose data the US company already uses in its mapping app.

TomTom’s shares rose by the highest amount in eight weeks on the reports, sparked by a research note from Hans Slob, an analyst at Rabobank International. He told clients he thought there was a ‘30% chance’ of an Apple takeover bid, designed to correct problems in iOS Maps more rapidly than an internal team could do.

However, other analysts thought the probability was far higher, given the rising challenge not only from Google, but also the broad uptake of Nokia’s location technology. Based on its Navteq purchase, the system has recently been adopted by Microsoft, Amazon and several auto makers, and Nokia has extended its Windows Phone application into a platform-neutral cloud service, as well as adding new features to its related Drive software, targeting TomTom’s heartland on the car dashboard.

Slob wrote in his note: ‘TomTom needs the cash from Apple, and Apple needs the knowhow of TomTom.’ He added that the deal would be a ‘royal way out’ for the Dutch company’s founders, who will be looking for an exit strategy as the firm comes under mounting pressure from smartphone rivals. However, as recently as October, CEO and co-founder Harold Goddijn insisted the company would stay independent.

When Apple looked to sever its mapping ties with Google, it introduced its own application but subsequently was forced to issue an apology for its many errors. The system draws on data from several sources including TomTom, Waze, Yelp, and NASA. This week, Google launched the much anticipated new version of its Maps app for iOS 6. There had been speculation that it would back away from such a move, for fear of a direct confrontation with Apple, should the iOS firm seek to block the software from its App Store. However, given the tide of use anger about iOS Maps, that move now seems unlikely.

And the dent to Apple’s infallible image has opened up important opportunities for Nokia, which is finally waking up to the need to put its few remaining crown jewels ‘ particularly Navteq and its imaging technologies ‘ at the heart of its strategy. It is already designing Windows and non-Windows handsets which focus heavily on the latter, particularly PureView and could even take the next step and create a wireless connected PureView camera, on the lines of Samsung’s Galaxy Camera (see separate item).

Perhaps counter-intuitively, there seems to be a nascent revival in the idea that consumers want single-purpose, optimized devices for functions like photography, navigation and media playing, rather than cramming all those applications into huge, multifunctional smartphones. Even the tablet is often succeeding because it can deliver a more specifically tailored experience than a handset for TV viewing/interaction, shopping and reading. As well as the general fall in the price of electronic gadgets, users will be encouraged to invest in multiple products by the operators’ rising tendency to allow a ‘bucket’ data allowance to be shared between them, rather than insisting on a separate contract for each cellular connection.

If the trend proves to be more than a shortlived fad drummed up by gadget makers eager to sell more products per head, it could lure Nokia into a new-look personal navigation device sector. The latest version of its Drive software, for instance, aims to replicate the experience of a fully featured embedded vehicle navigation system, so a step towards designing or branding the hardware too is not inconceivable.

Nokia is getting closer to the auto industry, licensing Maps to several big names, and it has not only broadened its location platform to the cloud with the launch of Nokia Here, but also included many of the specialist driving capabilities which are missing from general purpose smartphone apps. Aaron Dannenbring, VP of product management for location and commerce, told GigaOM that many of the latest additions are designed to bridge the gap which still exists between a dedicated in-vehicle satnav and a mobile app ‘ for instance, greater use of 3D, spoken street names, the ability to tailor route preferences, and multitasking. And the map flow is seamless, as they are vector-based, generated from data points rather than by loading map images into the screen, and preloaded at the start of the journey to save battery and get round the problem of unreliable cellular connections for in-trip streaming (as long as GPS is visible).

Whether or not Nokia decides the PND is due for a revival, it is clearly gunning for TomTom’s role as the provider of location data and software for cars, stealing a march in the rising smart vehicle space, where the market is far more open than the smartphone space. Nokia’s future should lie in taking its core technologies, whether hardware or software, and pushing them into relatively untapped sectors, or those where Apple is weak. The cloud-based Nokia Here shows the way, and a strong offering for auto manufacturers would build on that nicely, setting the stage to create future, more generic data/location platforms for the internet of things.