Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 December 2012

BT may re-enter mobile market with bid for UK’s 2.6GHz spectrum

UK wireline incumbent BT is to bid in the upcoming LTE spectrum auction, it emerged just after regulator Ofcom announced the closing of applications to take part in the sale. The agency will publish a full list of participants in a few weeks’ time, but it is clear that BT, plus the four mobile operators (EE, Vodafone, Telefonica O2 and 3UK) have all paid their £100,000 deposit to take part.

Ofcom on Tuesday gave participants a six-hour window to submit their applications and produce the £100,000 upfront fee. Applications will now be reviewed and those cleared to bid will be revealed late this year or early in 2013, ahead of the auction. The auction will start in January and probably last for several weeks, with operators expected to start rolling out LTE networks in their new frequencies from mid-year. EE (formerly Everything Everywhere) is already turning on commercial LTE services in the UK, using its refarmed 1.8GHz GSM spectrum.

It has been unclear whether BT, which sold its mobile arm (formerly Cellnet, later O2, and now part of Telefonica) in 2001, and since then has relied on MVNO deals to provide wireless services. Even now, it seems unlikely the incumbent would go head-to-head with the cellcos in conventional mobile services, given how overcrowded the UK already is. Instead, it might use spectrum for specialized or vertical services, or merely as an asset.

Five years ago – when the UK looked as though it would be Europe’s first country to auction 4G spectrum in 2.6GHz and WiMAX was the main available technology option ‘ BT hinted heavily that it would bid for licences and deploy a WiMAX network. The carrier raised hopes in the WiMAX community that BT would manage to acquire significant amounts of spectrum and would then choose to implement WiMAX in it, assuming a Sprint-style mantle as an 802.16 mobile broadband trailblazer, for Europe.

However, WiMAX’s moment passed in the UK when the auction, originally mooted for 2007, was repeatedly delayed by regulatory disputes and legal challenges, with most of the large cellcos opposing an early sale ‘ partly to regain the momentum from WiMAX by waiting until their preferred LTE technology was available.

BT’s WiMAX plan, in those days, would have given it the influence of an early adopter, and its roll-out would have been mainly to fill in gaps in its wireline broadband and support enterprise applications. The same thinking on applications could still apply today (though with LTE). Another option, increasingly popular with new wireless entrants, would be to create a wholesale network to support small service providers and to offer offload services for the cellcos.

However, BT’s obligations to deliver broadband to remote areas does not seem to be part of the strategy. According to the Financial Times, BT is only interested in the high capacity 2.6GHz spectrum, not the 800MHz digital dividend band, despite its suitability for providing broadband to rural areas. BT has been trialling unlicensed options for this purpose, notably white spaces in the TV spectrum.

There is also speculation that some private equity firms could be bidding, with a view to acquiring spectrum as an asset and creating a secondary market after the auction. The UK has been the most advanced of the major European economies in supporting new EU rules allowing spectrum trading.

The UK government will be pleased that there is at least one additional bidder beyond the four cellcos, since this could push up the price. In November, Ofcom set a reserve price of £1.3bn for the total sale of 2.6GHz and 800MHz spectrum but the Treasury has said it expects the auction to raise a total of £3.5 bn (€4.3bn). This would be a far cry from the £22.5bn raised in the UK’s 3G auction in 2000. However, many experts believe even the £3.5bn is unlikely to be achieved.

James Barford at Enders Analysis told the BBC: ‘Auctions are always very difficult to predict. What I would say is that if you look at the European auctions of LTE and expect the same prices in the UK, ours should raise about £2.5bn. I wouldn’t say £3.5bn is beyond the realms of possibility, but it is a little hard to see. It was the same mobile phone companies, or least their parent firms, who participated in the European auctions as will do so in the UK.’

Milan Sallaba, head of telecoms strategy advisory at KPMG, added: ‘Each of the existing UK mobile network operators is under significant pressure to upgrade their networks to 4G, but most of them are having a tougher time making money from mobile data. Unless additional credible contenders emerge and join the bidding, the auction may bring in less than the £3.5 billion expected by the government.’ He calculates that the German LTE auction in 2010 raised the equivalent of £50 per capita, which would equate to £3bn in the UK, though the recent Irish sale netted £689m or £146 per head.

Meanwhile, EE is expanding its 1.8GHz LTE service to a further 17 towns and cities across the country by March 2013 and has increased the capacity in the existing networks. The carrier said it switched on 4G in three more towns last week and will activate a further four this year, bringing the total to 18 (ahead of the original target of 16). By the end of the first quarter of 2013, LTE will be available in 35 towns and cities in the UK. EE is also upgrading its 3G network to DC-HSPA, which will be in place on 40% of its network by year end.

Once the auction bidding kicks off, operators could have access to €3.5bn of low interest funding from the European Investment Bank (EIB), according to The Daily Telegraph newspaper. Recently, the EIB announced a loan of £350m to EE to upgrade its antenna network to improve LTE coverage. This year, the UK has pledged an extra £1.6bn to the EIB, whose remit is to support infrastructure and development projects across Europe.