Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 December 2012

Orange’s bid for Simyo highlights new wave of MVNO takeovers

In the early days of MVNOs, especially in Europe, there was a wave of low cost providers which subsequently got strong exits by selling themselves to the vey operators whose networks supported their disruptive models. Now the same process is happening again as carriers look to boost their market share, and their economies of scale, by snapping up smaller brands in the prepaid sector.

While the prepaid market can be a squeeze on conventional cellcos’ margins, it is important in terms of market reach, especially in a time of economic squeeze, when most growth lies at the low end. And prepaid units, or even ‘internal MVNOs’ like O2’s Giffgaff, can enable large players to target user bases which are normally closed to them, without hurting their core brands. That was seen in the US with Sprint’s Boost Mobile youth brand and then its purchase of MVNO Virgin Mobile to create a portfolio of low cost divisions, each addressing a particular segment.

Recession-struck Spain is one area where operators are preying on smaller rivals and on MVNOs ‘ which are sometimes, rather like no-frills airlines, actually owned by larger carriers. France Telecom Orange, having shown interest in Spain’s fourth cellco, Yoigo, it is now negotiating to buy an MVNO, Simyo, which is currently owned by KPN of The Netherlands.

A deal valuing Simyo at around €30m could be agreed by the end of the year, according to Spanish business paper El Economista. Citing unnamed sources, it said final details were being worked out.

Simyo is hosted on Orange’s Spanish network and currently has over 400,000 customers. As well as increasing its base in the country, a deal would avoid the loss of that deal ‘ Vodafone was reportedly also interested in the MVNO, but would presumably have transferred it to its own network as soon as possible.

Last December KPN sold its Simyo MVNO in France for a rumoured €20m, though not to Orange ‘ it was acquired by Bouygues Telecom, along with its 180,000 customers.

If Orange does acquire Simyo Spain, its base will increase to almost 16m, getting close to Vodafone’s 16.3m and improving its chances of hitting its previously stated aim, to become Spain’s second cellco after incumbent Telefonica Movistar. If it still goes ahead and bids for Yoigo, currently a subsidiary of TeliaSonera, it would certainly become the second cellco. However, it may face competition for that unit from Mexican giant America Movil or others.

KPN has been looking to offload its Spanish MVNO since last year, but the sale was postponed when technical problems relating to the use of Huawei equipment arose.

Also in Spain, Vodafone has launched a low cost services brand called Vodafone Yu. Yu aims to compete with Movistar’s Tuenti and Orange’s Amena brands and will offer three prepaid tariffs ‘ ‘Smart 8’, ‘Smart 12’ and ‘Smart 16’, targeting smartphone users.