Clearwire has accepted a slightly upgraded offer for full control from Sprint, at $2.97 per share. Up from the original bid of $2.90, the new proposal values the transaction at $2.2bn and has been approved by Softbank of Japan, which is seeking approval for its own bid to buy 70% of Sprint for about $20bn.
The Japanese operator is said to have strongly favored the full takeover of the Clearwire joint venture, which has huge stocks of 2.5GHz spectrum, in which it runs WiMAX and is building out TD-LTE. Softbank is also deploying TD-LTE in Japan in the same band, and is part of a roaming and device initiative with Clearwire, China Mobile and others. Its influence, even before the deal with Sprint is finalized, is likely to have made the US cellco give greater priority to Clearwire within its complex 4G network and spectrum strategy.
Sprint currently owns 52% of Clearwire, though does not have majority voting rights, and has won over other major shareholders including Intel, BrightHouse and Comcast, which own 13% between them.
However, smaller investors may be less impressed. The deal has already provoked a challenge from one, Mount Kellett Capital Management, which owns 3.6% and last week said the initial $2.90-a-share offer ‘grossly’ undervalued Clearwire’s stocks of spare spectrum. Those frequencies could greatly increase Sprint’s capacity for mobile broadband and for offload from its main LTE network. And Crest Financial, which owns about 3%, filed a lawsuit to block sale to Sprint and is now seeking to extend that to a class action.
Many analysts were surprised the price was not pushed up higher still, with some speculating it would have to top $5 to reflect the spectrum’s value.
“Sprint’s Network Vision architecture should allow for better strategic alignment and the full utilization and integration of Clearwire’s complementary 2.5GHz spectrum assets, while achieving operational efficiencies and improved service for customers as the spectrum and network is migrated to LTE standards,” said Sprint and Clearwire in a joint release. They said the merged firm will deploy TD-LTE in line with Clearwire’s current plan while Sprint will continue with its own multiband FD-LTE plan. But Sprint is expected to decommission Clearwire’s network over time, reported Reuters.
While the merger will help Samsung ‘ the only vendor in common to both operators’ LTE projects ‘ consolidate its US position, it could put even more pressure on Huawei, which is a supplier to Clearwire but was excluded from Sprint’s Network Vision program at the eleventh hour, because of pressure from government agencies citing security concerns.
Some still believe the transaction is not really about Sprint wanting Clearwire’s operations ‘ despite the two companies’ intense six-year history together ‘ but about hedging its bets on spectrum and preventing Clearwire from looking for partners elsewhere, notably in an alliance with Dish. Sprint’s first offer for full control came hard on the heels of the FCC allowing Dish Network to run terrestrial LTE in its AWS-4 mobile satellite spectrum, and if the TV provider is serious about becoming a cellco, it will have to move quickly. The FCC has ruled that it must cover at least 40% of the US population in areas covered by its spectrum over the next four years, and 70% within seven years. Dish, with its plans to go straight to LTE-Advanced, and its content alliances, could be a thorn in the side of Sprint’s bid to close the gap with Verizon and AT&T in mobile broadband, but it almost certainly needs allies to achieve that ‘ to increase capacity and coverage, through spectrum or network sharing, or acquisition.
Before the Clearwire deal, Sprint was reported to be interested in a sharing arrangement with Dish, but this is now unlikely to happen, and more recently, Clearwire and Dish were regarded as natural partners, and actually to have a deal on the table, held up only by delays in the FCC’s approval (which were, in turn, largely caused by Sprint’s concerns over interference to the PCS H Block, which it hopes to purchase next year).
Satellite and spectrum analyst Tim Farrar is one who sees Sprint’s latest decision as just a move in a game of spectrum chess between Softbank, Clearwire, Dish and AT&T, all scrabbling to turn once-neglected bands into mobile gold. A Sprint-Clearwire merger could force Dish into the arms of AT&T, argues Farrar.
Analysts are also discussing how Sprint, heavily influenced by Softbank, will deploy the Clearwire spectrum once it has acquired it, however reluctantly. Many expect to see a shake-up of Clearwire middle management and a more dynamic approach to network roll-out, and particularly a move to join the small cell trend so favored by Softbank. Analyst and industry consultant Robert Syputa commented: ‘The deployment strategies held steadfast by Clearwire over the years, that of using macrocell base stations, and small cells only as the rare exceptions, have flown in the face of what the industry was moving towards and what Softbank and a few others have claimed was absolutely necessary for success in the >2.2GHz bands.’ We can expect that strategy to change once the Sprint/Softbank/Clearwire deals are finalized, and the US 4G landscape will shift once more if Dish succeeds in finding its own friend, whether AT&T or perhaps T-Mobile/MetroPCS.