The proceeds of recent spectrum auctions, even for 4G, have generally been disappointing to governments eager for new revenues. But the effects of global recession, the lessons learned from the 3G spectrum bubble in Europe at the turn of the century, and regulatory pressure to encourage new entrants and rapid broadband roll-out, have all depressed the takings in many areas. This was thrown into sharp relief by the recent Indian re-auction of GSM spectrum, as well as lacklustre results in LTE sales in some countries such as Germany.
However, this month has seen a significant exception with a huge sum raised from the Dutch LTE auction, and this has raised hopes elsewhere that, as operators become more desperate to secure mobile capacity, they will be prepared to pay high prices for the assets.
Four players acquired LTE spectrum licences in The Netherlands, delivering a €3.8bn windfall to the Dutch Treasury, far higher than expected. The winners in the Dutch sale were the three incumbent cellcos ‘ KPN, Vodafone and T-Mobile ‘ plus one new entrant, Tele2 of Sweden. The regulator has been insisting on supporting new players in successive auctions. The total paid for the licences was almost eight times higher than the government’s projected sum of €480m and KPN alone paid €1.35bn ‘ a decision which led it to cancel its dividend payment.
The bidding closed after running for seven weeks and left one candidate, the disruptive cableco joint venture of UPC and Ziggo, without spectrum. This group had previously acquired licences in the first Dutch LTE auction, which focused only on 2.6GHz. As seen in other European sales, the lower frequency bands ‘ the center of this sale ‘ have attracted higher prices because of their coverage capabilities, but with the relatively limited capacity available, smaller players have often been left in the cold (like E-Plus in Germany). The two cable operators said they pulled out when the prices got too high, raising question marks over their future wireless model.
The auction saw 41 licences sold, in the 800MHz, 900MHz and 1.8GHz bands. This was the biggest auction in the country’s history. Vodafone was the biggest spender, shelling out €1.38bn for nine licences; KPN paid €1.35bn for 15 licences; while T-Mobile spent €911m on 15 allocations and Tele2 paid €161m for just two. The franchises will run until 2030.
The huge sums raised in The Netherlands have raised the hopes of treasuries round the world. The UK, in particular, may now have a better chance of hitting its targets for the new year’s 4G spectrum sale, and beyond that, analysts believe it could make as much as £1bn ($1.5bn) from the auction of military airwaves in 2014, Meanwhile, India’s government is looking for at least INR200bn ($3.7bn) from the next round of spectrum transactions.
The UK government confirmed on Monday that it would proceed with the auction of Ministry of Defence spectrum, probably in summer 2014, as part of its long term strategy to boost broadband availability and capacity by opening up underused frequencies. The 2010 government spending review recommended that 500MHz of public sector spectrum should be released by 2020 for mobile communications, and the MoD ‘ which controls about 75% of these airwaves ‘ will act on the proposals first.
The spectrum on offer will be below 15GHz and much will be suited to mobile access or backhaul. Some analysts told The Financial Times that the spectrum could fetch £1bn. Chancellor George Osborne said in the recent autumn financial statement that he aimed to raise £3.5bn from spectrum, to help reduce national debt. The first test of whether his targets are realistic will come in the new year with the sale of 800MHz and 2.6GHz 4G licences.
The MoD has in the past loaned its spectrum for certain uses, such as communications for the London Olympic Games. Philip Dunne, the minister for defence equipment, support and technology, commented: ‘We hope that the sale will help drive the roll-out of new generation networks and universal access to broadband, both of which are vital to the UK’s prosperity.’
Over in India, the government said it expects to complete its next round of auctions by March and aims to raise at least INR200bn. This is despite the fact it has had to reduce the reserve prices for 1.8GHz spectrum after licences in key metro areas like Delhi failed to sell during the first auction in November, because of high base costs.
In that round, the federal government raised only INR94.07bn ($1.71bn), well short of its target of INR280bn. On Thursday, it cut the starting prices by 30% for the areas which received no bids – Delhi, Mumbai, Karnataka and Rajasthan. In the new process, the Department of Telecom also plans to sell 12 slots of 1.25MHz in the 900MHz band in the Delhi and Mumbai circles, and 10 slots of 1.25Mhz in the same band in Kolkata. It is not clear what it will do with CDMA spectrum, for which there were also no bids, and which some operators want repurposed for GSM.
The 900MHz band is already in use for GSM but licences are up for renewal starting in November 2014. The base price for one slot of 1.25MHz bandwidth in 900MHz has been fixed at twice the starting price for 1.8GHz.
The Department of Telecom plans to take back some 900MHz licences and replace them with alternative frequencies, although the cabinet has now decided to allow operators to retain at least 2.5MHz of the 900MHz spectrum, in line with similar processes in other countries, beyond 2014 to sustain service continuity. Previously the carriers would have been left with far smaller amounts, which they argued could have led to a poor experience for users. They will now be asked to pay the same price that emerges from the auction, to keep their frequencies beyond the renewal date.
Telenor – which lost its GSM franchise in Mumbai when the Supreme Court cancelled 122 licences, originally awarded in 2008, after a corruption scandal ‘ said it is looking at taking part in the forthcoming sale even though it stayed away last month. However, CEO Jon Fredrik Baksaas commented: ‘The 30% discount is a good target, but I think prices will have to be reduced even further.’