Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 January 2013

CES: Will the new form factors favor Intel, Qualcomm or neither?

The Consumer Electronics Show may have had fewer knockout mobile device launches than in recent years, but the future shape of the portable gadget was still a dominant topic of discussion. Manufacturers showed off shapes and sizes from the weird to the futuristic, all aiming for that perfect design ‘ convertible, phablet, ultrabook, even phone/ereader mash-up ‘ which would capture the consumer imagination as the notebook and iPhone once did. Also feverishly pushing their favored solutions for that hybrid computer/smartphone space were the chip providers, looking for new segments amid the commoditization of handsets and slow decline of PCs.

Intel and Qualcomm vyed for attention at the Consumer Electronics Show’s opening day in Las Vegas, with the former outlining its roadmap for low power smartphone, tablet and ultrabook chips, while the latter adopted the theme of ‘born mobile’ for CEO Paul Jacobs’s keynote speech. Intel’s challenge is firmly centered on gaining mass market acceptance for its ‘ultrabook’ design, as the standard for hybrid devices. Partners launched ultrabooks in various incarnations in Las Vegas, many featuring touchscreens, detachable tablets or other features borrowed from the smartphone world and increasingly de rigeur for the PC industry too.

Intel’s problem, of course, is that its chief stronghold, in Wintel PCs, is declining in volume, while that of Qualcomm, the smartphone, is still growing, even if margins are falling and competition rising. Intel is entering the handset processor space just as those pressures are taking hold, and is unlikely to build significant share ‘ which is presumably factored into the plan, as long as the chip giant can use the mobile chip partnerships it does secure as a springboard for a powerful entry to the smartphone’s larger-screened cousins, tablets and phablets. The strategy involves sneaking up on tablets from behind, and combining those gains with the natural base in ultrabooks, using its near-exclusive in the x86 version of Windows 8, and its tightening ties to Android, as levers.

But that approach comes with many risks, including the failure of W8 in tablets, or user preference for the ARM-based RT version; the difficulties in dislodging Qualcomm and Nvidia with their early lead in slates; and a poor outcome for ultrabooks. At this early stage for all these segments, there is plenty to play for ‘ the iPad and Kindle Fire are not the end of the story for tablets, but the start. Hence Intel’s hail of announcements at CES, covering all its bases.

The stand-out items focused on harnessing the 22nm process to reduce power consumption across the range, especially for a new smartphone platform geared to emerging markets. Mike Bell, general manager of the mobile and communications group, and Kirk Skaugen, general manager of the PC client group, shared the honors in showing off the forthcoming products, indicating the move towards common approaches from desktop to pocket.

Other announcements centered on a 22nm quad-core system-on-chip for tablets, and support for a wider variety of form factors within the ultrabook category, as the range of convertible touchscreen/PC designs widens confusingly.

“The best of Intel is coming to a mobile device near you,” said Skaugen. “We are set to deliver the biggest increase in battery efficiency in Intel’s history with fourth generation Intel Core processors, while adding broad new human interfaces to computing devices through touch, voice, facial recognition, and gesture-based interactions. We’re also significantly extending the performance and power savings in Atom processors as we accelerate our mobile offerings in an unprecedented fashion in 2013.”

Targeted at entry level smartphones for emerging economies, Intel unveiled a low power Atom platform, formerly codenamed Lexington, together with a reference design, and said this had already been adopted by four partners ‘ Intel’s original handset OEM, Lava International of India; African operator Safaricom; Lenovo and Acer. The platform features the Atom Z2420 processor with Hyper-Threading Technology, supporting 1.2GHz clock speed, 1080p hardware-accelerated codec, and the Intel XMM 6265 HSPA+ modem with dual-SIM capability (crucial for emerging markets).

Bell also detailed the upcoming Atom Z2580 processor platform (formerly known as Clover Trail+), targeted at high end and midrange smartphones. This includes a dual-core processor with Hyper-Threading Technology, and a dual-core graphics engine. It promises to deliver up to twice the performance of the current Atom Z2460 platform.

The next generation Atom SoC, codenamed Bay Trail, will harness 22nm and 3D transistor processes, and will be available before year end. This will be optimized for tablets and will double the performance of the current offering in this category, making it the most powerful Atom to date, nudging towards Core levels of horsepower while operating at low power and in SoC designs.

Intel is also adding low power capabilities to Core. A few months ago it said it had added a new line of processors, with 10-watt design power, to the forthcoming fourth generationCore family, and now this has been squeezed to 7-watts, and the low power options will be added to the current third generation too. These chips will target thin, light convertibles and ultrabooks in particular. Models slated to incorporate the new chips include the Lenovo IdeaPad Yoga 11S Ultrabook and a future ultrabook detachable from Acer, both planned for this spring and promising all-day battery life.

Intel said the fourth generation Core would deliver the ‘most significant battery life capability improvement in Intel history’, with up to nine hours of continuous battery life, while offering five times the performance of an Nvidia Tegra 3.

“The fourth generation Core processors are the first Intel chips built from the ground up with the Ultrabook in mind,” Skaugen said. “We expect the tremendous advancements in lower-power Core processors, and the significant ramp of touch-based systems will lead to a significant new wave of convertible Ultrabooks and tablets that are thinner, lighter and, at the same time, have the performance required for more human-like interaction such as touch, voice and gesture controls.” He showed off an ultrabook detachable reference design, codenamed North Cape, which converts into a 10mm tablet and can run on battery for up to 13 hours while docked.

He added: ‘We’ve literally gone from inches to millimeters on this ultrabook journey’, and claimed about a dozen ultraslim designs were in development.

Over at Qualcomm, which also aims to rule the hybrid territory between the handset and the laptop, CEO Jacobs outlined a world where everything is connected and ‘born mobile’, in his pre-show keynote address. That means being connected via mobile devices, anytime and anywhere, he explained, and his two-hour presentation focused on how Qualcomm was enabling the trend, and on the importance of a broad ecosystem of partners ‘ Steve Ballmer, CEO of Microsoft, with which Qualcomm has a particularly close development relationship, came on stage to talk about Windows Phone and Windows RT (Jacobs had taken over the plum pre-show keynote spot from Microsoft, which did not take part in CES this year).

Other guests, designed to demonstrate the wide range of people who benefit from mobile technology, included Archbishop Desmond Tutu (by videolink), the band Maroon 5, Sesame Street’s Big Bird, film director Guillermo del Toro and Star Trek actress Alice Eve.

Jacobs said: “We’re all part of what we’re calling ‘Gen M’ now, the born mobile generation. We’ve all really come to expect and demand devices … in the palm of our hands.” Qualcomm chips and software would power a vast range of gadgets such as health monitors and cars, he said, demonstrating various examples, including the Vuforia augmented reality platform, which allows applications to ‘read’ using text recognition, and the latest developments in the firm’s wireless electric car charging initiative.

However, Qualcomm’s core business in smartphones and tablets was not forgotten, with the main product launch ‘ of two new high end Snapdragon processors, the 800 and 600 ‘ focused firmly on consumer products and the fight with Intel. The larger of the two chips promises a 75% performance leap on current S4 Pro models, and supports integrated LTE and 802.11ac fast Wi-Fi. It includes the Krait 400 quad-core CPUs, with each core running at 2.3GHz ‘ ‘faster than many laptops’, Jacobs said, in a pointed dig at Intel ‘ and supports the next wave of HD video, Ultra HD, and Qualcomm’s iZat all-in-one location system. It also incorporates the Adreno 330 GPU and Hexagon v5 DSP. Low power consumption is aided by the move to a 28nm process.

The Snapdragon 600 for high end smartphones tops the performance of the S4 Pro by 40% at lower power with a Krait 300 quad-core CPU clocked at up to 1.9GHz, a new Adreno 320 GPU and support for LPDDR3 memory. The chips are sampling and should ship in commercial devices in the second half of the year. Steve Mollenkopf, Qualcomm’s COO, said in a statement that the company already had more than 50 design wins for the 600 and 800 processors.

The big challenger to Qualcomm in the tablet segment has so far been Nvidia with Tegra 3, thanks to the firm’s early leap into quad-core processing which ‘ whether or not it is strictly necessary in a mobile product ‘ gained the newcomer a huge degree of profile. However, it is far too early for Nvidia to declare itself a king in the tablet chip space ‘ that sector is fluctuating and new market demands are already emerging, notably the low cost of a fully integrated baseband/CPU system-on-chip, Qualcomm’s speciality. Nvidia is racing to fill that gap by integrating the modem technology from its Icera acquisition, but it will also have to adapt cleverly if consumer preferences, in terms of form factor, change. Intel could quickly go from outsider to kingpin should the mass market embrace the W8 ultrabook convertible, while price competition among smaller tablets will start to benefit the Chinese chipmakers.

To be fair, Nvidia is showing full awareness of how agile it needs to be. It not only unveiled Tegra 4 at CES, but also drew on its graphics heritage to try to associate itself inextricably in OEM and even consumer minds with gaming and other high-graphics applications. The firm went as far as to launch an own-branded gaming device, Nvidia Shield, not just to showcase the capabilities of its silicon, but to influence the user experience and educate consumers to opt for gadgets based on its chips, ‘Intel Inside’-style. In addition, it unveiled plans for a cloud-based gaming platform; and the GeForce Experience to auto-optimize gameplay.

The Android-based Shield is the first device bearing the company’s name and provides a console-style controller which can play Android and PC games as well as those which Nvidia is amassing within its own Tegra Gaming community, as it seeks to create a base of titles that are optimized for its own silicon.

Shield is still in prototype form, but could reach the shelves within a few months, with the vendor targeting a second quarter launch. CEO Jen-Hsun Huang said Shield brings together five years of work in processor architectures and cloud gaming, to provide a way to “play any device in any place on any screen…in an untethered way’.

Nvidia also talked about Grid, its new server rack to run gaming services, which it hopes to sell to cloud providers, cablecos and gaming firms as a dedicated back end system for web gaming ‘ for instance, pay-TV operators could launch new, premium games channels. Huang said: “We’re working with all of them,” Huang said. “Now they can get the Netflix of games. This is a new service that came out of nowhere for them.”

Grid indicates how companies need to think out of their traditional boxes to take advantage of changes in the market ‘ and given Nvidia’s strength in supercomputers, it may not be as big a stretch as it first seems.

Moreover, the Shield is an extension of Nvidia’s previous efforts to establish itself as the premium gaming platform and to create a superior experience on its own processors. Like Intel and Qualcomm, it has worked with developers to optimize applications, particularly those that showcase its particular expertise (in graphics). All these vendors have gone further in recent times, creating their own developer communities and investing significant resource in making software platforms run better on their silicon. Intel most famously extended that logic into advertising its benefits direct to consumers, with ‘Intel Inside’, a strategy it will now apply to mobile products as it signs up major OEMs like Lenovo. But the same thinking lies behind Nviida’s Shield and the Tegra Zone app it launched last year in the Google Play store, helping customers find games and other programs that will run particularly well on its chip. It even, in some cases, offers different features ‘ such as additional game levels ‘ if a user has a particular processor in their device, while some of the code optimizations will not even run on other chips. Qualcomm has similar efforts in games, connected home apps and other areas, centered on Snapdragon.

Educating consumers is a long and expensive process, however, and meanwhile, Nvidia will continue to chase market share in more mainstream devices, especially tablets. It claims it gained 10 big name tablet wins in 2012, including the Google Nexus 7, Microsoft Surface RT and Asus Transformer Pad and it will hope for even more with Tegra 4. The forthcoming processor is based on ARM’s latest Cortex-A15 architecture, upping the performance compared to the A9-based Tegra 3. The new platform also incorporates 72 graphics cores, six times the number in its predecessor.

One feature much emphasized by the chipmaker was HDR (high dynamic range), which rapidly takes two photos, one at high exposure and one at low, and combines them into a single, richer image. Nvidia claims Tegra 4 conducts this HDR process 10 times more quickly than the iPhone 5, and supports panorama.

Tegra 4, like its forerunner, supports Nvidia’s 4+1 design, in which a small fifth core takes helps regulate power consumption among the main cores. And it optionally integrates the Nvidia/Icera LTE-enabled i500 modem, which will sample this month to partners. This runs on eight processors and can deliver 1.2 trillion operations per second. The next issue for Nvidia to address is likely to be how far to try to integrate connectivity (Wi-Fi, GPS and so on) into its SoC, something Qualcomm has prioritized on its roadmap since acquiring Atheros, and which is already a differentiator for strong Wi-Fi players like Broadcom and Marvell, as they build their own processor businesses.

Samsung is another chip major with decisions to make about integration. Although it has extensive modem and some connectivity assets, it has made limited moves to tie these together tightly, and even its own handsets often feature third party chips. While Samsung does not touch Qualcomm in all-in-one SoC potential as yet, it talks up another aspect of integration ‘ providing OEMs with a complete platform including memory and displays, and other products from various parts of its empire.

Simon Woo, president of Samsung’s System LSI unit, said in a CES interview that the company was strengthening its position as a supplier to other phonemakers, increasingly tempting them with a full complement of integrated components comprising processors, memory chips and displays. ‘In the world, the only company that has logic, memory and display is Samsung Electronics,’ he told CES attendees.

The firm was also showing off its latest mobile processor. With Qualcomm and Nvidia battling over quad-core processor credentials at CES, Samsung trumped them both by unveiling an eight-core model in its Exynos range. The Exynos 5 Octa is targeted at mobile devices which are heavy on graphics and video but is also likely to expand Samsung’s reach into in-car systems, set-top boxes and other gear.

It uses a combination of high performance ARM Cortex A15 CPU cores and lower power, lower performance Cortex A7 cores to balance horsepower and battery efficiency. The A15 cores in the new Samsung chip can clock up to 2.5GHz and the A7 to 1.2GHz. There were no details on when the Exynos 5 Octa would appear in commercial devices though Samsung’s own mobile and TV units are likely to be early adopters.

And that raises the huge challenge which will face Qualcomm, Nvidia and Intel ‘ and smaller players ‘ in the quest to increase market share in mobile devices. This is one that their technology roadmaps do not really address ‘ the fact that half the smartphone market is controlled by two vendors which increasingly rely on their own silicon. That gives Qualcomm, not just Intel, an urgent need to see new form factors succeed, especially those backed by a wider range of vendors, including the PC suppliers. The Qualcomm takes on the ultrabook and the cloudbook are unlikely to be far away.

The diversification of mobile device form factors will be crucial in defining the shape of the vendor and processor landscape from 2013 onwards. The same is true of the diversification of mobile operating systems, as the Chinese vendors, in particular, look very happy to adopt Windows Phone, Windows RT, Firefox Mobile and the new Ubuntu OS alongside Android. This fragmentation must be harnessed for the benefit of the big processor makers, which work increasingly tightly with software majors to optimize their platforms for key OSs. Next week, Wireless Watch will examine how this will play out in 2013, and the clues seen at CES this week.

Mobile processor revenues:

Revenue from mobile apps processors rose by 77% year-on-year in Q312 in the tablet segment, and by 58% in smartphones, according to Strategy Analytics. Nvidia held its lead in non-iPad tablets (47% of the total), taking one-third of that sector and 17% of the overall tablet processor space. Overall $900m in integrated tablet processors sold in the quarter, but only 1% included basebands, limiting design wins for integrated parts from Broadcom, Mediatek and Qualcomm. In smartphones, Qualcomm took 42% of the $3.8bn market followed by Samsung with 27% and MediaTek with 12%. Then came Broadcom, ST-Ericsson and TI (which is exiting the market). Nvidia’s share of the smartphone sector remained flat, though it should make gains as it integrates LTE basebands into its SoCs. China’s Spreadtrum got 1.7% share in mobile processors while Intel had just 0.2% for Atom. Qualcomm’s share in the Android base dropped from over 60% in early 2011 to about 35%, while Mediatek saw tenfold year-on-year revenue growth for its smartphone apps processors.

Nokia cautious about launching Windows RT tablet
Fresh reports have surfaced that Nokia is working on a Windows RT tablet for launch in the first half of next year.

The Finnish firm certainly needs to diversify into new form factors to avoid becoming permanently reliant on a handset market which is commoditizing, and to gain some of the public attention that tends to buzz around tablets and convertibles.

However, it has to be even more careful than most vendors to avoid a launch flop, so it will need to differentiate its offering and get its launch timing and approach right. The features with which it is really starting to make its Lumia smartphones stand apart include location services, which could be harnessed effectively for a larger screened device, and imaging, which have less obvious relevance. However, Nokia is stuck with a reasonably vanilla user experience for WP8 ‘ and Windows RT in future ‘ because of Microsoft’s restrictions, so the success of a tablet will partly depend on whether the consumer base is enthusiastic for the new operating system at all.

Nokia is reported to have been discouraged from launching too early by lukewarm early sales of other vendors’ RT devices’ especially as it wants to focus holiday season resources and public attention on Lumia, and on WP8, where it has a better chance of standing out from the crowd than in tablets (its previous efforts in the hybrid PC/handset space have not been great successes ‘ remember the Nokia 770 Internet Tablet of 2005, and the Booklet 3G of 2009?).

According to Taiwan’s Digitimes, Nokia also postponed its tablet plans in order not to clash with Microsoft’s own Surface launch. ‘Nokia originally planned to develop a 10-inch Windows RT tablet equipped with Qualcomm’s S4 processor in first quarter 2012, with Compal to undertake ODM production and initial shipments of 200,000 units to test the market,’ the sources indicated.

CEO Stephen Elop certainly recognizes the need for swift action to take advantage of a possibly brief window when carriers urgently want a third OS to counterweight Android and iOS, but when HTML5 is not mature enough to fill the role. He said in a recent interview with CNet: ‘There’s been a marked shift towards this challenger mindset. We have to move with urgency. We have to have empathy and listen to our customers. How do we respond to consumer demand that we haven’t done as quickly as before?’