Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 January 2013

HTML5 will creep up on mobile users during 2013

A large number of web majors have decided that, in the mobile environment at least, they need more than a single strong service ‘ a search engine, browser or social network ‘ and instead require a full platform encompassing all those elements, running on a slimmed-down Linux OS but centered on HTML5 and web services. This approach has many advantages ‘ no reliance on Google; a rapidly evolving developer base and toolset available for limited investment; the ability to harness an existing brand and extend it into every area of the web experience.

The disadvantages? It is tough to differentiate unless the provider already has a strong presence with consumers and developers (Baidu yes, especially in Asia; Tizen, no, for instance). There are far too many such platforms to survive and the winners will need relationships, often difficult ones, with mobile vendors or operators. The big opportunities here will be to ally with firms that do not have their own strong mobile web platforms and have a common interest in differentiating themselves ‘ emerging market carriers and OEMs will be key. The other problem for a firm with limited presence in the native OS space is how quickly users really will embrace the online-only, cloud-connected HTML5 experience, and if they do not, how the new platforms will find a route to the mass market.

Facebook’s high profile U-turn, from planning to rest its whole mobile strategy on an HTML5 platform, to rejecting the standard almost out of hand for the near term, hit the web technology hard. Despite its presence on a huge percentage of new browser devices, the bulk of consumer usage remains focused on native apps, and the standard itself is incomplete and, in some areas like codecs and WebRTC, contested. HMTL5-driven platforms attached to popular brands like Mozilla will help accelerate the adoption of browser/cloud services, often with users hardly noticing the shift in their behavior from apps and downloads to streaming and remote access. On non-handset devices, this will be particularly true, as these support a different way of working and users will often import some habits and products, such as Ubuntu perhaps, from their PCs. As tablets, cloudbooks and other large-screened items account for an increasing proportion of mobile data usage, HTML5 will increase its importance.

However, hybrid habits and platforms will rule for some years yet, and here Google has the advantage, if it succeeds in converging its Chrome OS cloud-based system with Android in a clever way. Apple is adding more cloud capabilities, sometimes reluctantly, to iOS, and has become far more aware, under Tim Cook’s leadership and recent restructuring, of the need to refocus on the web. Its influence will help shape user behavior, but may also, ironically, make some loyal iDevice users recognize that there are more alluring cloud experience to be had outside the Apple corral. In a world defined by openness and blurred boundaries between platforms, the Apple brand will have its toughest challenge yet to keep users loyal to a tightly closed environment.

So what of the new challengers ‘ Tizen, Baidu, Alibaba, Jolla, Ubuntu, Mozilla, even HP’s webOS? They all share some things in common ‘ HTML5, Linux (some still retaining elements of Android), a focus on new device form factors and new cloud services. Only those with strong browsers or search engines will have the power to reach out directly to power consumers. Others will rely on being adopted, whether branded or not, by OEMs and operators with strong market reach ‘ and that does not mean being Samsung’s fifth OS, supported as an option to irritate Google or satisfy one particular operator.

Full commitment by the likes of Samsung, of course, is important, given the consumer and developer reach of the big brands. But Samsung’s support did not save the carrier-driven LiMO OS, now folded into Tizen (along with the Intel/ Nokia platform MeeGo). Samsung is backing Tizen too, and may merge it with its own bada system, but for now this looks like a counterweight to Google and a contingency plan for future cloud devices and for new sectors like the connected car. Android and, increasingly, all three Windows releases (WP8, RT and W8) will remain the heart of Samsung’s mass market strategy at least in 2013-2014.

The Chinese handset makers are looking for differentiation as they move out of white label land and start to make an impact as full smartphone providers. Their coming of age was highlighted by Huawei’s successful launches of top end devices at CES, and by the progress of Lenovo, leaping into second place in its home market behind Samsung and hoping to harness awareness of its ThinkPad brand among affluent western buyers. Like Samsung, they will keep the safe bet of Android at the heart of their handset strategies but are likely to be more imaginative when it comes to carving out their own user experience on emerging device types. For instance, ZTE will introduce a European smartphone running the Mozilla OS this year and may also bring the device to the US, according to US CEO Cheng Lixin. ‘We closely monitor the ecosystem and how it evolves,’ Cheng said.

Much will depend on whether the Windows trio succeeds in becoming the de facto alternative to Android on large-screen devices, or whether cloud gadgets become sufficiently popular in this device generation to create a major role for the web OSs. Verizon Wireless CEO Lowell McAdam said in a recent conference session that it was good for the industry to have ‘three or four robust operating systems like that … When you get a little bit more variety you get a little bit more innovation.’ While developed market players like Verizon tend to mean Windows and BlackBerry when they talk about third and fourth OSs, those in emerging markets, where the smartphone battle lines are not fully drawn, may well be attracted to something newer and more susceptible to their influence, in important areas such as local language, and efficient browsing or streaming even on low end connections (compression of 30% to 90% is a feature of the mobile browsers from Baidu, Opera and Nokia).

However, the shift to cloud-oriented platforms and habits will be, as we have seen, will be a gradual process. Organizations like Ubuntu and Mozilla can afford to play a long game since they are effectively extending existing brands to make a mobile play, This is vital since, like Microsoft itself, they cannot be left stranded on the melting PC iceberg ‘ but they do not need to gain a huge mobile presence overnight. Newcomers like Tizen and Jolla have a more urgent need to net at least a few high volume OEM or carrier deals to ensure any impact at all. While Tizen remains reliant mainly on Samsung, unless Intel, its other main backer, decides to do something radical, Jolla is looking to Chinese partnerships.

China is the first port of call for every new platform, because of its huge smartphone base, its growth rates, its eagerness to embrace standards it can shape itself, and the weakness of Google there. However, the local players are grasping the initiative, leaving little space for outsiders, and now they are looking beyond their own borders, raising the very real prospect of a Chinese OS going global and being the ‘next big thing’ after Android and iOS. This likelihood will be underestimated by Wall Street for years, because most challengers will first move into high growth emerging economies, where the hold of the big two mobile giants is confined to a relatively small sector of the population ‘ the US will be the last place to feel the impact of Baidu, Aliyun and others, but when it does, it will see that these platforms have captured the attention of precisely those mobile markets which are overtaking the US in size and potential. For instance, Telefonica is the most committed carrier backer of Firefox Mobile, and the Spanish giant is pushing it particularly as a web-friendly option for new smartphone users in high growth markets like Brazil.

This scenario was highlighted last week by a deal to strike fear into Google’s heart ‘ its Chinese arch-rival partnering with a major operator to put a non-Google browser at the heart of the Android experience in fast growing markets. Baidu, which already overshadows Google in China and has released its own mobile operating system, has announced a deal with Orange (exclusive for the first year) to create an enhanced browser for Android handsets, to be pushed out in the carrier’s extensive territories in Africa and the Middle East.

This could be the kind of breakthrough Baidu has been seeking to spearhead the expansion of its mobile web services, notably its search engine, beyond its home market. Like Opera, the main provider of mobile browsers embedded in emerging market handsets, Baidu knows that creating a distinctive platform for a cellco’s own services is a key way to gain market reach in emerging economies ‘ where operator branded devices and platforms are more common. In turn, this will help such software houses to compete with Google by preventing it becoming the default user experience throughout the Android ecosystem.

This is Baidu’s first global operator agreement. The new browser is already available in Arabic and English, and a French version is in development. Importantly, it will be pre-installed in many devices, as well as being available to download. It will be pushed out to Android devices across Orange’s African footprint through this year. At least Android, if not Google, is still involved in this deal. Indeed, Orange says it is seeing significant increase in demand for smartphones, especially Android ones, in the MEA region ‘ in Egypt, for instance, Android device sales doubled in the second half of 2012 on Orange networks. (The first operator to launch the platform is Mobinil, Orange’s unit in Egypt. But Orange has an MEA mobile base of almost 80m and ‘lie Girard, senior EVP for group strategy and development at the carrier, values the region at $100bn with the highest growth rate in the world. The carrier aims to double revenues from its emerging market footprint – mainly in MEA – from €3.4bn in 2009 to €7bn by 2015).

However, having established the claims of its ‘more affordable and a richer browsing experience’, Baidu will look to expand into a full platform, sidelining the Android OS altogether, as Mozilla ‘ originally Android-based ‘ has done in the upcoming Firefox Mobile.