Governments are embracing LTE as a flexible and relatively economic solution to providing broadband to unserved rural areas. However, some carriers go a step further and see LTE as a fixed wireless option not just where users lack any high speed connectivity, but also as a way to replace DSL with a more modern and profitable infrastructure.
Vodafone is defocusing on previous efforts to buy or partner with DSL networks and says it will use LTE as a common fixed/mobile platform in Germany, India and elsewhere. The big two US carriers are also interested in accelerating the turn-off of DSL, as they pursue a future entirely built on fiber+wireless.
This was clearly seen in AT&T’s Project VIP network plan, unveiled last fall. This represents massive investment in accelerating 4G and fiber-to-the-node roll-out, but the carrier also said it planned to use LTE to compete in areas where it does not have fixed lines, and to save on the cost of continued investment in DSL.
Project VIP effectively means the end of real investment in DSL and indeed, where users still have copper lines, AT&T increasingly recommends the use of LTE for fixed access if fiber is not available. (It does use DSL for the last mile for its U-verse fiber system in most areas, but is defocusing on standalone copper lines). It says wireless, fiber-to-the-node and business networks deliver 81% of its revenue and are collectively growing at 6% a year, so it is clear where the investment priority must lie. AT&T last month petitioned the FCC to update its rules so that wired or wireless IP systems can be considered as a replacement for the traditional copper phone-line system.
But at the start of 2015, one-quarter of AT&T’s wireline base will still not have U-verse, which points to another strategic significance for LTE investment, to stop defection ofDSL customers. While it may be efficient for AT&T to move to an IP-only system, critics say it will be a blow to rural users and to local CLECs which rely on the larger firm’s network ‘ factors which may attract FCC scrutiny or even encourage AT&T to sell off its DSL business as Verizon did.
At the Citi investment conference before the holiday, CTO John Donovan was asked if he believed LTE could be a substitute for low to medium-use DSL services. He said AT&T preferred to expand the footprints of its U-verse broadband and IPDSLAM (high-speed internet access and VoIP) networks, but he indicated LTE could play a fixed broadband role.
“We anticipate LTE will be a broadband coverage solution for a portion of the country. We just haven’t yet gotten to the point where we’ve got enough experience under our belt to know exactly what that footprint is going to be. But there’s no question as we extend ourselves from 75% of the footprint to 99% of the footprint in a region that we’re going to be using LTE for some of that broadband,” he said.
Meanwhile, Verizon’s balance is a different one, thanks to its far-reaching cross-network deal with a group of cablecos. However, it is starting to market LTE as a fixed broadband option under its FusionHome brand. At the Consumer Electronics Show, Taiwanese vendor Wistron was showing the LTE access point and router that Verizon Wireless is selling for this service. This is intended for residences in areas where the cablecos’ Docsis and the telcos’ VDSL are not available and is in direct competition with the two satellite broadband providers, ViaSat and EchoStar’s Hughes Networks.
The Wistron-made box, which Verizon calls a Cantina, must be mounted outside the home to get the best LTE reception. MoCA coax connects it to a supplied Wi-Fi router inside the house and devices link to the router via Wi-Fi (802.11n now, but 11ac later this year). Up to four wired and about 20 Wi-Fi devices inside the home can connect to the router, more than enough for most homes or small businesses.
The cost is dependent upon how much data the subscriber uses and discourages high level Netflix or YouTube consumption. The speed is the same on all plans (5-12Mbps downlink, depending on distance from the tower, and 2-5Mbos uplink). The monthly rate ranges from 10Gbytes for $60 to 30Gbytes for $120, all with two-year contract. Verizon has many variations on these plans, which seem to change from time to time.
The equipment and service are not at all mobile, in fact, not even portable. Verizon sells a movable broadband service, which uses its tiny Jetpack box. Up to five users can connect via Wi-Fi. However, the data-usage per monthly price is less than with the fixed Cantina.
With the satellite broadband services and Verizon both taking away subscribers, it seems that slow basic DSL’s days are numbered. However, the lifetime of products and services are longer than we think ‘ look at the millions that are still using dial-up when they could upgrade to satellite or LTE broadband. It’s a start, however, and at least gives most US households more choices when selecting a broadband service provider. It also makes faster broadband available to millions of homes that can get no broadband or only very slow broadband ‘ about 20 to 25 million unserved or underserved residences.