Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

31 January 2013

Apple fails to win more damages from Samsung

Judge Lucy Koh, who presided over the landmark Apple-Samsung patents trial last summer, has ruled that the Korean firm did not ‘wilfully’ infringe Apple IPR. The iPhone maker was using the accusation to chase an increase in the $1.05bn damages awarded by the jury in San Jose last year, though that judgement does stand. The post-trial ruling is now complete and overrules the jury’s opinion that Samsung was guilty of wilful infringement. That could have pushed damages as high as $3bn though Apple was pursuing an extra $500m. Koh said there was not “sufficiently strong” evidence that Samsung had caused Apple harm through anti-competitive behavior, and that the jury’s calculation of damage costs was reasonable. She also denied both parties a new trial.

The ITC will review its preliminary decision that a number of Samsung’s products infringe on Apple-owned patents. The Commission will be reviewing the case “in its entirety’, but part of the dispute will also be sent back to ITC Judge Thomas Pender, who made the original ruling, for review. He decided that Samsung infringed on two of Apple’s patents, but discarded two others, and recommended a product ban should the full ITC panel confirm his judgement.One of the patents centers on the detection of a headset by a smartphone and the other allows the mobile device to show an image on a multitouch screen with an additional, translucent image over the top. A final decision on the case, which was originally due to be announced in March, will now have to be pushed back further due to the review.

The ITC has also voted to investigate whether Ericsson has infringed Samsung’s wireless patents following a tit-for-tat complaint filed by the Korean giant in December. Samsung is seeking a USITC order blocking Ericsson from importing some products into the US. Ericsson said: “We filed multiple patent infringement lawsuits against Samsung in November after Samsung refused to license our patents on the same fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory terms that its competitors have accepted. We anticipate that the ITC will resolve the claims in our favor.” Ericsson’s own ITC complaint against Samsung is still pending.

Meanwhile, Adaptix is the latest to file a patent complaint against Ericsson at the ITC. Acacia Research, a large patent-holding firm, acquired former base station maker Adaptix for $160m a year ago. It owns three US patents related to wireless base stations.