The heart of modern mobile network planning is to distribute intelligence throughout the network from edge to core, so that every cell can adjust automatically to changing data demands. This is the dream of self-optimizing networks ‘ a term which is quickly replacing the more prosaic self-organizing networks when discussion turns to SON. Networks must not only be able to organize themselves efficiently to maximize responsiveness and minimize interference, but they must go a step further, optimizing themselves on a minute-by-minute basis to different levels and types of data traffic.
While SON ‘ by either definition ‘ is increasingly an element of serial releases of the 3GPP platform, most operators will have to go significantly beyond the bare standards to achieve this optimized network nirvana and deliver the promised quality of service benefits to their users ‘ not to mention the operating cost savings to their own bottom lines. Major vendors and some smart start-ups have been focusing on the challenge, and it is no surprise that Cisco has been taking a keen interest. The networking giant clearly sees itself as the king-in-waiting as the mobile network moves to all-IP, and is determined to increase its standing with cellcos by increasingly providing everything they need except the base stations (and even there, it plans to launch 3G/4G metrocells in the near future).
More importantly, though, it will build on its existing strengths in the core and edge routers, and on its Starent packet core acquisition, to infiltrate other parts of the mobile infrastructure. As it says itself, it aims to add the ‘crucial network intelligence layer’ to modern cellular systems. Aiding that effort is its latest acquisition, of Israeli start-up Intucell, which recently achieved high profile thanks to a contract with AT&T (already working closely with Cisco in the small cell arena where SON will be most essential). The IP giant will pay about $475m in cash for the software house and incorporate it into its Service Provider Mobility Group. The deal is expected to close in Cisco’s third fiscal subject to the usual closing conditions and regulatory approval.
Intucell has developed ‘dynamic SON’ software to allow cells to respond more flexibly to shifts in data and signalling traffic, according to time of day and other criteria. It sprung from Israel’s rich wireless R&D soil to take a different approach to the flexibility challenge, with SON techniques designed, in effect, to allow the cell to ‘follow’ the user. The firm, which two years ago raised $6m from venture capitalists Bessemer Ventures, also has locations in Singapore and the UK and last year added AT&T to its first public customer, Israel’s Pelephone.
The aim is to turn the traditional static cellular network into a self-aware, fluid creation, whose cells constantly expand or contract according to the capacity required, as users move around the system. Such techniques will form part of SON developments which will come to fruition in the LTE-Advanced standard, and will be vital for viable small-cell HetNets, but Intucell has been working to steal an early march by working with existing and conventional networks. The results may be less dramatic than with a specifically designed HetNet, but already promise significant customer benefits such as higher average speeds and greater reliability of call quality.
Intucell’s software identifies cells where capacity is, at least temporarily, being underused. It then signals neighboring base stations to seize some of that excess resource, effectively expanding those cells while shrinking the original one. Because the platform can retune in real time, it can move beyond a situation where operators plan largely according to pre-determined rules ‘ such as certain hours of the day being busy in a given region ‘ and can respond dynamically, and even forecast, to some extent, how traffic patterns will change in the coming minutes and hours. For instance, it can track the direction in which a particularly active user or group of users is moving. Intucell claims its tools can reduce dropped call rates by 10% and boost overall data capacity through the network by between 30% and 50%.
‘Until now optimizing a radio access network has been sort of a type of witchcraft,’ Intucell CEO Rani Wellingstein said in an interview in 2011 as the firm came out of stealth mode. ‘Engineers would typically retune networks on a weekly or a monthly basis. That kind of model was good for when traffic was not so dynamic, but today congestion is moving dynamically through the network.’
All this makes it clear why Cisco is interested, and the larger company’s resources will be welcome to give carriers confidence in entrusting such vital functions to a start-up solution, as well as accelerating development to turn an exciting technical vision into reality ahead of rival efforts ‘ and potentially influencing future standards for SON. Kelly Ahuja, general manager of the Cisco Service Provider Mobility Group, said in a statement: ‘The mobile network of the future must be able to scale intelligently to address growing and often unpredictable traffic patterns, while also enabling carriers to generate incremental revenue streams.’
After something of a hiatus in its characteristic serial acquisition spree, during 2011’s reorganization, Cisco burst back on the M&A scene in later 2012 with the purchase of TV software maker NDS for $5bn. CEO John Chambers told the firm’s analyst day in New York late last year: ‘We have gone too long without any major M&A. You will see us more active in the M&A side.’ He claimed that leaving money on the table during the restructuring period had deprived Cisco of perhaps 1% of additional revenue.
That caution is over now, but while we may see the firm making more $1bn-plus purchases, like those of NDS and Meraki ($1.2bn), rather than its traditional small start-ups, it is also likely to be less scattergun in its choices than in the past. Most of the M&A strategy will focus around building up two key growth areas, intelligent carrier networks and cloud platforms ‘ with those two businesses sometimes converging. To gain greater carrier presence, it will look to add functionality to its main router platforms, particularly in software defined networking (SDN); and to push into the cellcos’ gateways and even their access networks, via small cells, carrier Wi-Fi and HetNet controllers.
Late last year, Cisco bought policy management specialist Broadhop, also for its Service Provider Mobility Group, adding another element to its ONE programmable network platform. ONE will provide a comprehensive network management system as part of the strategy to surround the classic routers with intelligence. In just four weeks, Cisco acquired not only Broadhop but
cloud-based enterprise network provider Meraki; Cloupia, which automates converged data center infrastructure; and Cariden, which makes network optimization tools for ISPs. Broadhop was the eleventh purchase in 2012, with others including NDS, vCider (data center virtualization); ThinkSmart (Wi-Fi location); Virtuata (data center security); Truviso (network management); ClearAccess (provisioning mobile devices); and LightWire (routing and switching). Earlier this month it also invested in virtualization firm Parallels.
If Cisco is looking out for further start-ups in this field, its eye could light on California-based Vasona Networks, whose take on mobile network optimization targets congestion in individual cells rather than reshaping traffic across the whole network. It recently came out of stealth mode, claiming a new level of precision in the way it tunes traffic on a cell-by-cell basis. This brings yet another technology to the challenge of optimizing networks, along with various forms of transcoding, policy management, traffic shaping and so on. CEO Biren Sood says that most
optimization techniques either work from the mobile core, prioritizing or offloading whole classes of data, or they are subscriber-based, following users around and controlling their traffic regardless of network conditions at the time.
‘We understand the nature of the cell, and we understand the capacity of the cell,’ he told GigaOM. ‘With that understanding we can get the right bits to the right applications in the most efficient way.’ The system sits between the RAN and core and monitors the congestion level of each cell as well as the inbound and outbound traffic streams to those cells. When one looks set to get too full, Vasona’s tools start to adjust the traffic flow, perhaps by prioritizing video streaming over downloads, or culling extraneous information from a video.
Bessemer, the initial investor in Intucell, seems to be getting a taste for this market, having also backed Vasona, in a $9.8m round shared with New Venture Partners. Sood says the Vasona platform is already in use in a handful of global mobile networks but none has gone public yet. However smart, however, it will face significant challenges to get a strong foothold for its approach. Cisco is building its armory rapidly; the major infrastructure vendors all have their own SON and traffic shaping tools; Citrix recently burst into the field by acquiring ByteMobile; and many traffic management specialists are extending their offerings into broader mobile optimization systems, including Aircom, Allot, Openet and Sandvine, plus SON pioneers such as Airhop and Celcite. Taking a different, but related tack are the mobile video caching specialists such as Vantrix and Skyfire.