Google controls Motorola Mobility and Microsoft is not only making its own hardware but could take a major interest in Dell. But as the software giants chase Apple’s integrated platform and race to become device suppliers, the conflicts of interest with their operating system partners may not be the only problem. The shadow that Motorola cast over Google’s most recent quarter; accusations of inaccurate demand forecasts from Nexus partner LG; and previous Microsoft adventures with its Danger acquisition ‘ all these suggest these giants do not necessarily understand how to run a consumer gadgets business.
Amid a generally strong set of fourth quarter results, Google’s Motorola subsidiary was a dark spot, posting a loss of $353m ($152m excluding one-time items) and dragging its parent down. Despite recent restructuring, the net loss had grown from the year-ago figure of $80m ‘ when Motorola was still independent ‘ while revenue had fallen to $1.51bn from $3.4bn then. The results were affected by Google’s decision last month to sell Motorola’s home set-top box business to Arris Group ‘ as a result of that planned sale, the search giant moved the results to its discontinued business section.
In addition to the Arris deal, Google has been slimming down its handset unit and seems set on turning it into a center of innovation and a few high end devices, rather than a full-blown cellphone provider, perhaps to minimize the conflicts with larger Android partners, notably Samsung ‘ increasingly dominant in the Google platform, and also an important Nexus vendor. While LG, Asustek and others are also making co-branded gadgets for the Nexus line-up, which is currently Google’s most significant hardware activity, Motorola has not been invited to the party.
Despite all the cuts, Google CFO Patrick Pichette warned that results from Motorola would continue to be “variable” as it works through the reorganization process and continues to write down intangible assets. He said the firm is still working through a product pipeline of 12-18 months before Google’s ‘reinvented’ device strategy fully kicks in under Dennis Woodside, now in charge of the handset unit. However, while Google CEO Larry Page stressed the new approach to product development as he tried to look positive about Motorola, Pichette insisted the subsidiary was not set to become merely an R&D hub but would make a profit in time. The search firm “isn’t in the business of losing money with Motorola’, he commented.
It is not just the Motorola strategy where Google is looking shaky as a hardware vendor. Its latest Nexus launch, the Nexus 4 with LG, marks the shift of the own-brand strategy to target the mass market rather than developers or Android hobbyists. The handset, while well reviewed, has suffered from persistent shortages, which LG and Google are blaming on one another ‘ which in itself hints at weaknesses in the search leader’s ability to run a volume gadget business efficiently.
And LG’s claims, that Google does not know how to forecast demand, have a ring of truth for a software house trying to adjust to a high volume, low margin game ‘ one where it is reported to be prepared to launch an even cheaper product, a rumored $99 cellphone with Asus.
In mid-December, Google apologized to customers for non-availability of the Android smartphone and put the blame on its newest hardware partner’s ‘erratic’ supplies. This week, LG turned the tables, saying Google misjudged demand. The Korean firm needs a hit handset to help it win market share in a sector increasingly dominated by Apple and Samsung. It says it is now ramping up production of the Nexus 4, but its director of mobile communications in France, Cathy Robin, told local website Challenges that the supply problems have been down to Google’s miscalculations. The Nexus 4, with an unsubsidized price of $299, certainly targets a wider base than previous Nexus models, but Robin claims Google based its forecasts on experience with previous devices.
Many observers think the $299 price tag has been achieved with heavy subsidies from Google, as it moves from positioning Nexus mainly as a developer showcase. If so, this would see Google, like Amazon, changing the rules of the mobile device game, because these firms make their profits from advertising or media sales, not hardware per se. That will create future challenges for the device makers themselves, already under huge margin pressure. However, if Google ‘ like Microsoft ‘ does plan to subsidize its key partners’ gadgets in order to gain share, it needs to get its forecasting right.
The extent to which Microsoft subsidizes its key partners’ devices to gain uptake for its platforms ‘ Windows Phone and now Windows RT ‘ is a controversial topic too. But the complexities of the Windows giant’s device strategy could get even more tangled if it takes a holding in Dell. It has already launched its own Surface tablet, taking on other Windows RT products from long established partners and prompting at least one, Samsung, to axe an RT launch in the US. It has to balance its close alliance with Nokia with the need to extend the Windows Phone ecosystem to other suppliers too, yet it may also unveil its own handset. And a Dell deal could add another twist to the saga.
If, as widely rumored, Microsoft invests $1bn to $3bn in Dell, as part a return to the private sector by the PC maker, it would have a hardware partner even more captive than Nokia and could heavily influence its device and software choices. Dell is close to agreeing a leveraged buy-out by Silver Lake Management with part of the funding coming from the software giant, according to Bloomberg sources. The move could give Microsoft greater expertise and supply chain contacts for expanding its Surface range, but it would also be investing in declining businesses like traditional PCs, and in a company that has been struggling to remain competitive. It would also strain its relations with other hardware partners even more than it did with the launch of Surface RT.
The danger is that Microsoft is tying up with a growing list of hardware partners with their roots in declining form factors, and which have struggled to adjust to the ‘post-PC’ world ‘ Nokia and Dell in particular. Dell’s track record in new devices, with repeated failures in smartphones and tablets, does not inspire confidence that the Windows firm would be investing in a platform to bolster its position in innovative creations. Instead, it would look like two floundering firms trying to shore one another up as their core business collapsed around them. PC shipments are forecast to drop for the second year in a row in 2013, having fallen by 4% last year while tablet sales increased by 72% in 2012 according to JPMorgan. ‘The entire PC ecosystem is in a world of hurt right now, and it’s uncertain whether the PC market returns to a growth market,’ Israel Hernandez, managing director at MKM Partners, told Bloomberg. ‘They both have a vested interest in making sure the PC market can once again survive.’
Some analysts believe Dell is going private partly to have greater flexibility to exit PCs, and that Microsoft’s involvement would be geared to preventing a major OEM from dropping out of the Wintel space. Negative as that sounds, some give the firm more credit for shrewd alliances, remembering its $150m injection into Apple, which helped save that firm’s life in 1997. While Microsoft may have lived to regret that outcome in the post-PC landscape, it has certainly had a good return on its investment in what one analyst remembered being a ‘a pity infusion in a near-bankrupt company’.