The UK’s much delayed auction of 4G spectrum began this week, with seven bidders involved. The process is a complex and secret one and is likely to take several weeks to conclude, but will pave the way for new networks to be built out from around April, introducing competition for the only major current supplier of LTE services, EE.
Regulator Ofcom is offering an unprecedented amount of spectrum (250MHz), in the 2.6GHz and 800MHz bands, though the start date is as much as four years later than many had hoped, at least for the higher frequency licences. Previous auction dates were missed because of a series of legal challenges and disputes over how frequencies will be distributed, putting paid to the WiMAX community’s hopes that an early sale ‘ before LTE technology was ready ‘ could seize the UK’s 2.6GHz band for the older standard.
Finally, Ofcom got past all the challenges and achieved a regulatory compromise, though it will certainly not raise as much money as its predecessor, Oftel, did during the 3G auctions of over a decade ago. These raised £22.5bn in a frenzy of over-bidding that will not be repeated in these more cautious times, even with seven contenders. The total reserve price is set at £1.3bn this time, though the government is expecting to raise about £3.5bn.
Ofcom told the BBC: ‘Delays have been caused by a number of legal challenges and threats of future litigation from various companies seeking to defend their own commercial positions. These started as early as 2008 when we had originally planned to auction the 2.6GHz band of spectrum. However, regardless of this, the spectrum that we are auctioning could never have been used for 4G until this year, not least because the digital switchover needed to complete first to create the 800 MHz capacity.’
The regulator recently agreed to a ‘fast-track’ approach to clearing the 800MHz band for mobile services, partly to quell outcry from Vodafone and Telefonica over EE being allowed to launch LTE services ahead of the auction, by refarming its 1.8GHz GSM spectrum. It is the only UK cellco to have this increasingly popular LTE frequency option, though it is offloading about 25% of its holdings to the fourth cellco, Hutchison 3.
As well as these four mobile carriers, the other bidders are British Telecom, via its subsidiary Niche Spectrum Ventures; Hong Kong based PCCW, via its subsidiary HKT; and MLL Telecom, a UK-based network services supplier. It is highly likely that the four mobile operators will get the 800MHz airwaves, which will be perceived to have the highest value because they support rapid coverage at affordable cost.
BT will reportedly not bid for this spectrum as it is mainly focusing on rural broadband, and the same is likely to be true of MLL, whose existing services are in higher bands and which would lack the deep pockets to take on the big firms in a race for 800MHz. MLL designs, builds and manages bespoke mobile networks and infrastructure for UK operators as well as public and private enterprises and wants to supplement its existing 32GHz and 40GHz frequencies. CTO Peter Jennings told Mobile Europe: ‘We are not looking to launch competitive networks. We will use additional spectrum to build the infrastructure which enables operators to enhance services, do their job most efficiently and to help reduce their opex.’ In particular, it will focus on small cell and HetNet backhaul.
PCCW participated in an earlier UK auction, of 3.4GHz TDD spectrum, putting this into the UK Broadband initiative, which recently launched TD-LTE in central London.
The process itself is a version of one created in the 1990s for the privatization of London Regional Transport, and is known as a ‘combinational clock’ auction. According to Ofcom this ‘is designed to achieve the most efficient outcome – putting the spectrum in the hands of the bidders who value it most highly, while also ensuring they pay a competitive price.’
Each bidder can submit multiple bids for as many, or as few, of the 28 lots as they choose. They bid to win a combination of lots, not individual ones, and no player knows what the others are bidding. An operator could bid two different sums for a single lot, depending which others it would combine with. Telecoms consultancy Coleago told The Guardian newspaper that each contender will spend between £3m and £10m on advisers and lawyers to decide which combinations and prices to bid. About six rounds will take place each day. Ofcom works out the best combinations of bids and then how much each winning firm should pay using a ‘second price rule’ similar to that on eBay.
While all that is going on, EE has stolen a march on rivals by launching LTE first and has even announced its first MVNO, cellphone retailer Phones4U. However, Phones4U will not offer LTE services until later in the year ‘ initially its MVNO agreement will be confined to 2G/3G and those offerings will go live in March under the brand LIFE Mobile. There are about 90 virtual mobile operators in the UK, and EE is the market leader in powering them. Phones4U will market its own offering via its 600 high street stores.
Also from EE, the carrier is already modifying its controversial tariff structures for its new LTE network, which will be live in 35 towns and cities by March. The other cellcos, assuming they all win licences in the auction for 2.6GHz and 800MHz spectrum, are expected to go live from April onwards in selected markets, so the early mover is likely to be tweaking its offer in readiness.
At launch, EE’s pricing was criticized for taking advantage of its temporary monopoly by charging premium rates. Its new range of plans offers lower rates for moderate users, but charges far higher fees for data hogs. It has not offered customer numbers for LTE so far, but is clearly trying to lure as many new subscribers as possible before its rivals enter the space.
The days for snapping up those desperate for 4G speeds at a premium price are over, and EE is looking to lure mass market users, and to lock them in so they cannot leap quickly to new challengers. In an offer that expires at the end of March ‘ before other cellcos go live ‘ there are several entry level options including 500Mbytes of data, with unlimited calls and texts, for £31 a month on a two-year contract. Upfront charges for devices can be as low as £30 and this represents a saving of £90 across the lifetime of the contract compared to the current cheapest LTE tariff at EE.
The cellco also said that it will launch a 20Gbytes plan for ‘super-users’ (currently less than 1% of its 4G base), which will come in two variants – SIM-only for £46 per month on a 12-month contract, or £61 per month for 24 months with a subsidized handset. These prices will increase to £61 and £76 respectively for new customers who sign up after the end of February.
‘It’s fair to say that EE has attracted a fair degree of criticism not so much for the price of its 4G tariffs, but rather on the amount of data bundled at each level,’ said Matt Howett, a telecoms analyst at Ovum, in a research note. ‘In the end it has gone for the middle ground and priced services at a premium, but not at levels completely inaccessible to the mass market.’