As carriers step up the pressure to end their reliance on device subsidies ‘ and come up with more creative ways to lure postpaid customers ‘ these payments were still weighing hard on the profits of the US carriers. The subsidy issue was prominent in Verizon’s fourth quarter figures and in AT&T’s predictions for its own (which will be announced on Thursday after the close). The more the large cellcos’ businesses shift to smartphones and tablets, the more the upfront cost of those devices eats into their profits ‘ and the more urgently they will seek alternatives, with implications for their relationships with key suppliers like Apple.
Smartphone subsidies hit Verizon’s fourth quarter earnings, which fell to 45 cents per share, missing Wall Street forecasts. It is usually the iPhone-reliant AT&T which complains most loudly about the profit squeeze from subsidies, a factor that is driving cellcos such as T-Mobile USA and others round the world to seek other ways to attract high value users. But this time Verizon was feeling the pinch too, partly because the expensive iPhone is an increasingly important part of its own smartphone base.
In Q412, there was an accelerated shift towards smartphones in Verizon Wireless’s footprint. The mobile joint venture with Vodafone added a record net figure of 2.1m contract subscribers, with 87% signing up for smartphones. The operator sold 6.2m iPhones in the period, half of them the LTE model, and it activated 7.3m LTE devices. At the end of the year, smartphones accounted for 58% of the total postpaid base of 98.2m subscribers.
These devices drive greater data usage and more expensive tariffs, and operators make their money back over the life of the lock-in ‘ but with a top end model, sometimes not until well into year two. In the short term, rising numbers of high end handsets puts pressure on profits, a factor which figured in a warning to investors, made earlier this month.
So it came as little surprise that Verizon’s margins fell in the quarter. Wireless operating income margin was 24%, down from 31.8% in the third quarter of 2012, while wireless EBITDA margin was 41.4%, down from 42.2% a year earlier and 50% in Q312. Verizon expects the latter figure to rebound rapidly and to be close to 50% for the full year.
‘It’s a big upfront cost on smartphones and a short term hit,’ Avi Greengart, an analyst with Current Analysis, told Bloomberg. ‘They have to offer enormously expensive phones at affordable prices to move customers onto higher priced plans.’ Some carriers, such as TMo and Spain’s Telefonica, are experimenting with offering alternative incentives such as financing plans or cheaper data deals, to reduce the impact of subsidies.
However, there are upsides to smartphone growth of course, notably in postpaid revenues. The carrier no longer reports ARPU, but instead measures average revenue per account (ARPA) because of the importance of its shared data plans. Postpaid ARPA rose by 6.6% year-on-year thanks to rising data usage, reaching $146.80, though even this figure was just below analyst expectations. Total wireless revenues were $20bn for the quarter, up 9.5% year-on-year, and offsetting a 1.5% sales decline (to $10bn) on the wireline side.
Overall, Q412 sales rose by 5.7% to $30bn for the group, which posted a net loss of $1.9bn, largely because of a pre-tax charge of $7.19bn related to severance and benefit expenses and pension liabilities. The impact of Hurricane Sandy was also cited. A year earlier, Verizon made a loss of $212m. For the full year, Verizon’s revenues totalled $115.8bn, up 4.5%.
CFO Fran Shammo said on the analyst call that sales of the carrier’s Share Everything shared data plans continued to exceed expectations. New smartphone customers who want a subsidized device now have to sign up for these plans, which allow a bucket of megabytes to be shared across up to five registered devices. As users add more gadgets, they move up the tariff tiers, Shammo said and Verizon captures a larger percentage of total connected devices, with tablets currently being the most important non-phone category.
Verizon Wireless activated 7.3m LTE devices in the fourth quarter, up from 4.5m in Q312. It now covers 273.5m POPs with LTE, or roughly 89% of its US footprint, and expects to complete its LTE roll-out by mid-year. About 23% of Verizon’s retail devices now have LTE radios, but they now account for nearly half of its data traffic, the carrier said recently.
AT&T was yet to announce its own figures as we went to press, but last week it had already prepared the ground with a shock warning that it would take a $10bn charge. While this was related to pension schemes, the carrier also cited the subsidy issue, like its arch-rival, as well as the impact of Hurricane Sandy. AT&T said in a filing with the SEC that it expects to take a non-cash, pre-tax charge of about $10bn related to actuarial gains and losses on pension and post-employment benefit plans. The loss of about $12bn will be offset by an asset gain of $1.9bn.
AT&T also said in the filing that it will suffer the penalty of high smartphone sales in its fourth quarter. Having crowed over those sales, which totalled 10.2m, ahead of announcing its Q4 results on Thursday, it now warns that the high subsidies on the products will create ‘near term pressure’ on operating income, margins and earnings per share. AT&T has been particularly affected by the subsidy impact since launching the iPhone exclusively in 2007, since it remains more reliant on this smartphone than its rivals, and Apple devices come with the most hefty subsidies.
AT&T also cited Hurricane Sandy as a negative factor in its Q412 performance. It expects a reduction in operating income of about $175m as a result of storms, mainly affecting its mobile unit. It has massive pension liabilities, many stemming from its historic position as the US’s monopoly carrier. The obligations rise in an environment of low interest rates because the present value of those future payments goes up. In 2011, AT&T recorded a non-cash charge of $6.3bn for adjustments to its pension and post-retirement benefit plans.
Despite the quarterly shortfall, AT&T is on the acquisition trail, both for yet more LTE spectrum and also ‘ more surprisingly ‘ for possible footholds in Europe.
On the spectrum front, it has bought up yet another slice, this time from the rump of Alltel. Regional carrier Alltel was acquired by Verizon in 2009 but the CDMA giant had to divest certain markets, which were bought by Atlantic Tele-Network, retaining the Alltel brand. Now AT&T is to acquire that business for $780m, a sum which is mainly justified by its prey’s spectrum licences rather than its 585,000 customers on CDMA networks (incompatible with AT&T’s own) in rural areas of Georgia, the Carolinas, Illinois, Ohio and Idaho.
AT&T is paying a sum almost four times higher than Atlantic shelled out for the Alltel remains, even though the rural player has lost 215,000 customers since that deal. Those who remain will be gradually transitioned over to AT&T’s networks, and the spectrum ‘ in 700MHz, 850MHz and 1.9GHz bands, covering 4.6m POPS ‘ can then be refarmed for expanding the cellco’s own rural 3G and 4G coverage. Since AT&T’s bid to buy T-Mobile USA, mainly to bolster its LTE spectrum capacity, failed, it has been making up for that disappointment by acquiring a motley collection of smaller carriers or spectrum licences, including the bulk of the US’s usable frequencies in the unloved 2.3GHz WCS band, which it plans to use to boost capacity using supplemental downlink techniques. AT&T had previously acquired 79 of the 105 Alltel markets Verizon was forced to divest in 2009.
And the operator may also have its eyes focused on the other side of the Atlantic. Carriers from the Americas know that the eurozone crisis offers the potential of some bargain prices in the region and America Movil has already taken stakes in KPN of the Netherlands and Telekom Austria, and is said to be eyeing a broader footprint. Now AT&T is reported to want European purchases too.
Although western European markets are more saturated and over-competitive than those in the Americas, they are ripe for consolidation and low cost acquisitions or stakes could be available. And the region still has high potential for innovative and high value data services, for consumers, enterprises and M2M customers.
Despite the dismal track record of US and Asian operators’ M&A adventures abroad, AT&T is said to be scouting around for deals, though sources indicate it is not in a hurry, and a Wall Street Journal report only says an acquisition could ‘come by the end of this year’. Apparently, AT&T executives are interested in countries where there is a weak mobile network, often a fourth player, to snap up.
Candidates could include KPN’s units in its home country or Germany; Hutchison 3’s subsidiaries in the UK or Italy; or Telefonica’s O2 holdings in Germany or the UK, which the Spanish giant is rumored to be considering for offload in order to reduce debt (it has already undergone an IPO of O2 Germany, though this week it denied claims it would pursue a similar route in the UK). Another UK possibility could be a takeover of, or stake in, the biggest cellco, EE, a joint venture between Deutsche Telekom and France Telecom. There has been persistent speculation that either or both partners might sell out its share in EE.