Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 February 2013

Microsoft’s new friends may push Nokia to a multi-OS strategy again

It was a week when Nokia seemed to have lost its seat at Microsoft’s right hand on two fronts ‘ the emerging market push, where Huawei led the charge (see separate item); and the ‘post-PC’ strategy, where Microsoft was investing in Dell. The latter deal may ‘ even if it is approved by Dell shareholders ‘ be more focused on cloud platforms than the mobile market, but it certainly arouses speculation that in tablets and other Windows 8 form factors, Microsoft is chasing even greater control than it has over Nokia in Windows Phone. That could see the Finnish firm’s influence confined to the handset, while in the more strategic W8/tablet space it had to fight for a hearing against Dell and the internal Surface teams. Such an outcome could see Nokia abandon plans of making Windows its top-to-bottom platform, and retaining the multi-OS approach it has had for years.

CEO Stephen Elop refused to rule out the idea of using Android when Nokia finally announces a tablet ‘ which could come at this month’s Mobile World Congress. And despite rolling out low end Lumia models with the stripped-down WP7 Tango OS release (see separate item), Nokia’s real emerging market momentum has centered on the Asha ‘smart featurephone’, which runs its 14-year old Series 40 embedded platform. This has actually proved more resilient than Symbian/Series 60, which has declined far more rapidly than the vendor foresaw. That gap at the entry level smartphone end where Symbian sat has forced Nokia to invest heavily in turning S40 into a smart, though non-open, platform delivering a similar web experience to a low end Android product (indeed, a better one in some respects, since Asha harnesses the same imaging and location technologies as some Lumias, and features Nokia’s resource efficient browser).

It is very believable that the Finnish firm, if it sees the advantages of its Microsoft marriage diminishing, will continue to develop its own mass market platform, moving elements of Asha S40 to an open Linux kernel and creating one of the HTML5 browser-based OSs which are set to disrupt the mobile space, especially in emerging economies, from next year. Nokia could work with one of the existing options ‘ Sailfish from Jolla, founded by former Nokia employees and using the MeeGo OS discarded by the larger firm in favour of Windows Phone ‘ would be a neat outcome, but it could also adopt Mozilla Firefox Mobile, Tizen (another MeeGo offspring), or create its own (though it, rather hastily, abandoned its inhouse project to create a Linux-based platform for entry level smartphones, also in the wake of the Microsoft pact). Of course, given that the modern cloud/browser OSs are all based around HTML5, it could even have a different one for each major region, working with local influencers like Baidu in China and Yandex in Russia.

At the high end, it seems Nokia is also keeping its options somewhat more open than it might have done a year ago. It is well behind the curve on tablets, a delay blamed on Microsoft’s decision to confine Windows Phone to handsets, making its key partner wait for Windows 8 to move to larger screens. However, the Finnish firm does not seem to view WP8 and W8 as the single platform increasingly projected by Microsoft, and while Elop says the vendor is considering a Windows tablet, it has not ruled out Android either.

Elop may be playing politics here, but a decision not to extend the Microsoft partnership to tablets might point to dissatisfaction with the new Windows RT ARM-based operating system, which is far less mature than Android, or with the Microsoft relationship itself, especially if the software giant was not prepared to pay ‘platform fees’ to Nokia for using its OS, as it does with Windows Phone.

However, there would be a serious lack of logic in rejecting Android for smartphones ‘ opting for differentiation over a huge user and apps base ‘ but then adopting it for tablets, just when the Windows family was gaining some real momentum. Most vendors are increasingly seeing advantages in a single OS and user experience spanning all their devices ‘ handsets, tablets, notebooks and even other screens such as TVs or in-car systems. A fully controlled platform makes sense for entry level devices, but adding another over-powerful partner to the smart device mix would hurt Nokia.

Elop told reporters in Australia that his firm was looking ‘very closely’ at tablets and trying to learn from the performance of Microsoft’s own-branded Surface slate, which runs Windows RT. That product caused consternation among some PC OEMs like Acer, and suffered disappointing first-month sales, but Microsoft now insists there will be more third party models coming to the shelves this spring, while the first models running the Intel-based Windows 8 Pro will also debut this month.

Elop told the journalists: “We are studying very closely the market right now as Microsoft has introduced the Surface tablet, so we are trying to learn from that and understand what the right way to participate would be and at what point in time.” He focused on Windows choices, but as Australian Financial Review reported, a Nokia PR executive reminded him that no decision had yet been made on whether to back Android. While he said ‘our first focus on what we look at is clearly in the Microsoft side’, he added that Nokia would ‘consider any option’ in tablet OS terms.

The CEO’s instinct would be to support an OS from his former employer and deepen the ties with Microsoft. “It is important to note that the opportunity for companionship is something that any user is looking for,” he commented. “So, when you think about the Lumia 920 running on Windows Phone, having a Windows tablet or PC or Xbox is something that will give us the opportunity to have a pretty integrated experience.’

No product appears to be imminent, though Nokia has often pulled major surprises at its favorite event, Mobile World Congress (including the Microsoft alliance itself, which stole everybody’s thunder two years ago when it was announced on the eve of the Barcelona event). There have been many rumors of Nokia tablets, most recently a 10.1-inch model with auxiliary power supply. This could be the topic of Nokia’s media event at MWC, but so far the stories have all proved untrue, which has also given rise to many whisperings about conflicts with Microsoft, failed product developments and other possible reasons. In November 2011, even the head of Nokia France said he expected his company to have a Windows tablet by mid-2012. However, the most likely reason for the caution is that Nokia has had to focus its efforts on the tough job of re-establishing itself as a credible smartphone provider, launching the Lumia Windows Phone range while also rolling out new midrange models for emerging markets.

Its confidence in its Microsoft friendship will not have been bolstered by news that the Windows giant is to invest in Dell, another possible rival for its device affections. There will be much speculation over how the planned buy-out of Dell could affect the wounded PC giant’s direction, but its new major shareholders ‘ Microsoft and Silver Lake Partners ‘ will hope one will include a successful mobile push.

However, Nokia may not be too worried. PC makers in general, and Dell in particular, have a dreadful track record in the mobile world that threatens to eat their lunch ‘ remember the Axim, the Venue and the Streak, all quickly canned amid yet another change of direction in non-PC devices? So far, Dell’s main contribution to the smartphone market is to have pioneered the now-popular ‘phablet’ format with the 5-inch Streak. Under its new privately held structure, it will need to apply that kind of lateral thinking, with far better commercial execution ‘ which is where Microsoft may help.

Speculation naturally abounds that Dell will be to the Windows giant what Motorola is to Google (though minus the patents) ‘ a vehicle to create an integrated hardware/software experience under its own brand despite the obvious conflicts of interest with other OEMs.

The deal itself, if it is approved by current shareholders, has been in the works since last summer and would see Dell being bought back by its founder Michael Dell ‘ who will remain as chairman and CEO ‘ and by private equity group Silver Lake, with Microsoft contributing a $2bn loan. This would be largest leveraged buy-out since Hilton Hotels in 2007 and Dell would delist from the US stock exchanges.

Under the proposed terms, Dell shareholders would receive $13.65 in cash for each share of common stock, in a transaction valued at about $24.4bn, a premium of 25% over Dell’s closing price on January 11, the last trading day before rumors of the buy-out went public. The company has 45 days to see whether a better alternative offer emerges, so an acquisition bid is possible, and Michael Dell has recused himself from all board discussions and from the board vote to avoid accusations that he drove the deal. He plans to contribute his shares, which total about 14% of the firm, and ‘substantial’ cash sum, to the new-look Dell. Dell had its IPO in June 1988 when it was valued at $50m.

The obvious advantage of being private in a rapidly moving market is that Dell can be more flexible and can invest more easily in projects that have medium term returms rather than immediate impact on the stock. Analysts cited Dell’s Project Ophelia as an example of the kind of development that could be easier without Wall Street to please ‘ this is a prototype $50 Android computer in a USB stick format which can be plugged into any screen, TV or peripherals, and run full desktop PC-quality software from the cloud as well as stream media.

‘I believe this transaction will open an exciting new chapter for Dell, our customers and team members,’ Michael Dell said in a statement. ‘We can deliver immediate value to stockholders, while we continue the execution of our long term strategy and focus on delivering best-in-class solutions to our customers as a private enterprise. Dell has made solid progress executing this strategy over the past four years, but we recognize that it will still take more time, investment and patience, and I believe our efforts will be better supported by partnering with Silver Lake in our shared vision.’

Slowdown in Windows RT launches:
The Windows 8 tablet space could get crowded this spring, with Hewlett-Packard, Acer and others set to launch devices based on the Intel Clover Trail chip and W8 Pro before the end of the first quarter, despite caution before the holiday. An HP Envy Series hybrid tablet/laptop is already available for order while Acer will offer a 10-inch tablet for $499 and there will be tablets from Lenovo and Asustek too.

However, analysts do not expect new Windows RT devices to be unveiled this quarter as Microsoft seeks to drive sales and momentum for the existing choices ‘ its own Surface and other models from Asustek, Dell, Lenovo and Samsung.

Microsoft restricted the number of OEMs which could launch first generation Windows RT models in order to control the quality of the products ‘ and, argued some vendors like Acer, to leave the way clear for Surface. This Google-style approach might have helped prevent perception of the new OS being damaged by poor quality releases, but it also limited sales potential, according to Paul Jacobs, CEO of Qualcomm, the primary chip supplier for Windows RT and Phone. ‘The fact that there were only a handful of manufacturers that were allowed to participate, definitely in my mind held down the competition on form factors and everything that I would have liked to have seen,’ Jacobs said in an interview with Bloomberg.