The UK has, almost by accident, become a flagwaver for refarming GSM spectrum for LTE, and now its regulator, Ofcom, is proposing to make all three main mobile bands ‘ 900MHz, 1.8GHz and 2.1GHz ‘ technology neutral, to encourage expansion of LTE.
The country’s largest cellco, EE ‘ a France Telecom/Deutsche Telekom joint venture ‘ has already deployed LTE in its refarmed 1.8GHz GSM spectrum. Ofcom controversially allowed the firm ‘ the only owner of frequencies in this band ‘ to roll out 4G services before its rivals had the chance to acquire their own LTE bandwidth in the 800MHz/2.6GHz auction (now taking place).
One way Ofcom placated Vodafone, Telefonica O2 and Hutchison 3 was to promise a more rapid path towards freeing up additional spectrum for mobile broadband. The two larger firms run GSM in the 900MHz band, which has only the beginnings of an LTE ecosystem, in contrast to 1.8GHz, which is being deployed round the world for 4G. All four cellcos run 3G in 2.1GHz, and 3UK is to gain about 25% of EE’s 1.8GHz spectrum as a condition of the latter’s merger.
Ofcom has followed up on its pledges and published proposals to liberalize all mobile licences in the three key cellular bands to support LTE. The move will ‘meet a long standing objective to liberalize all mobile licences so that there are no regulatory barriers to the deployment of the latest available mobile technology,’ according to Ofcom’s statement.
However, the 900MHz and 2.1GHz bands are unlikely to be refarmed for some years. European operators generally see a long future for 3G+ enhancement, providing coverage, voice and other advantages to complement LTE. Therefore they will hesitate to reuse 3G spectrum until they are ready to migrate completely to 4G, which for some will take a decade. As for 900MHz, it is being used for 4G only by very few carriers, and has less capacity and, currently, far fewer devices than its 1.8GHz cousin.
And as Matthew Howett, an analyst at Ovum, said, previous plans to liberalize the spectrum had met with opposition. He told IDG: ‘Ofcom’s previous proposals to liberalise the 900MHz and 1800MHz bands for 3G services were famously met with fierce opposition from some parts of the industry, since at one point they implied taking back spectrum from some operators and redistributing it to others in order to more fairly distribute the benefits that operators get from the refarming. Arguably those proposals heavily contributed to the delays the UK has seen with starting its 4G auction which finally got under way in January 2013.’
In the auction, being conducted in secret, seven firms are competing for a total of 28 lots across three bands, and the process is expected to last for several weeks.
Ofcom’s proposals also include increasing the maximum base station transmit power in the 900MHz band as requested by O2 and Vodafone. The regulator is inviting responses to the proposals before March 29. The move is in line with efforts at a European level to open up 3G bands for LTE.
Meanwhile, EE says its LTE coverage now reaches 45% of the population after 90 days of roll-out, having added nine additional towns and cities last week. However, it will not have the market to itself for much longer. Even before the spectrum auction is completed, Hutchison’s 3UK, always a disruptive player, has sparked a price war, promising it will offer LTE services for no extra charge.
This comes in sharp contrast with the policy of EE, which took advantage of its temporary monopoly by charging hefty premiums (though it did reduce its data prices recently in anticipation of competition).
3UK took a swipe at EE in pledging that, ‘unlike some other UK mobile operators’ it would offer LTE services across all existing and new price plans without customers having to pay extra to upgrade to the faster speeds. In a statement, CEO David Dyson said: ‘As we add the next wave of technology to our Ultrafast network, we’ve listened to our customers and thought long and hard about the right way to do it. We don’t want to limit Ultrafast services to a select few based on a premium price and we’ve decided our customers will get this service as standard.’
Of course, the smallest of the UK’s four network owners must still win spectrum before it can make good on its promises. It will receive about 25% of EE’s 1.8GHz holdings as a condition of the latter’s merger (of Orange UK and T-Mobile UK) and could refarm those for LTE as EE itself has done. It is likely to be bidding for both 2.6GHz and 800MHz concessions in the auction, which is in process, but has expressed fears that it might lose out to its larger rivals ‘ EE, Vodafone and Telefonica O2 ‘ in the hotly contested 800MHz band.
There are seven bidders in total though the three non-cellcos ‘ BT, a PCCW subsidiary and MLL Telecom ‘ are thought to be pursuing only 2.6GHz frequencies. Regulator Ofcom has mandated that some spectrum in 2.6GHz is reserved for a fourth national carrier, which could apply to 3UK itself or any of the would-be new entrants.
Meanwhile, EE is reported to be readying a stock market flotation this year that would value it at £10bn ($15bn). According to weekend reports in The Sunday Times, the operator is close to appointing advisors on a sale. Its parents, Deutsche Telekom and France Telecom, have both said an IPO is their ‘preferred option’ though the final decision would depend on the conclusions of a ‘strategic review’ to take place during the course of 2013, and some private equity firms are understood to be interested in buying a stake outright. It is likely that the telcos would look to sell about 25% of the joint venture, which would raise about £1.25bn apiece while keeping control.