The rows over India’s disastrous GSM spectrum saga continue, with cellcos demanding a 50% cut in the reserve prices proposed for 1.8GHz licences in the key operating circles of Delhi, Mumbai, Rajasthan and Karnataka.
The spectrum was first auctioned in 2008 but the licences were cancelled last year after a corruption scandal. In a re-auction, many key franchises went unsold because of high reserve prices. The Department of Telecom has already cut the minimum cost of the CDMA spectrum, which also went unsold, and the operators’ trade association, the COAI, wants the same for the GSM band ‘ even though some argue this has gained significant value since it is likely the regulator, TRAI, will allow it to be refarmed for LTE.
The COAI said, in a letter to the telecoms ministry, that the decision to cut the price of 800MHz CDMA spectrum by 50%, whilst reducing GSM rates by only 30%, was ‘arbitrary and discriminatory’. The body also asked for the same price cuts across all circles where there is unsold spectrum, rather than just the four areas that failed to attract bidders in the November re-auction.
Some carriers say they will not take part in the latest sale if the conditions are not changed. One is Norway’s Telenor, which will relaunch this year with a new local partner and brand (Telewings). The cellco said in a statement that the prices are still too high and fears that the second round of sales ‘will be no different from the first.’. It said: ‘We are also concerned by the differential treatment between 800MHz CDMA spectrum and 1800MHz GSM spectrum. Considering that an unrealistic reserve price caused auctions to fail both of these bands in these circles, it is difficult to understand why the right decision of 50% reduction is being taken only for CDMA operators.’
Vodafone also said the rules for the GSM auction were illegal and discriminatory. Under the rules, Vodafone, along with other existing service providers such as Bharti Airtel and Idea Cellular, will be obliged to take part in the process if they want to renew their operating licences in the four circles, as their existing 900MHz spectrum will be also be put up for sale. The prices were ‘arbitrarily’ fixed, it said in a petition to the ministry, with no reference to international benchmarks. The price tag for 900MHz spectrum will be almost three times higher than 800MHz at its current rates.
Vodafone is also complaining that some of the 1.8GHz spectrum it did acquire in November is still being used by its previous owners, despite the cancellation of their licences. It requested the DoT to free up its spectrum immediately. “For instance, operators like Idea, Videocon, Uninor are on the same frequency band in circles like Assam, Haryana, Jammu and Kashmir and Orissa,” the operator said in a letter to the DoT. It accuses the government of receiving “unjust enrichment” by charging both new spectrum owners and operators with cancelled licences.