Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 February 2013

MWC: LTE will be old hat already, at least in marketing terms

In the constant game of one-upmanship the mobile industry plays, there will be few companies at Mobile World Congress content with showing off LTE products. Anyone who is anyone ‘ operators and vendors ‘ will be talking about LTE-Advanced as though it’s here today, no matter that many elements of that diffuse standard are not commercially available yet. And since LTE-A may not, after all, deliver ‘true 4G’ (1Gbps stationary data rate among other things) as hoped, the industry must start to look towards the next generation. Cue the unimaginatively named LTE-B, and even, in one NTT Docomo presentation, LTE-C.

Of course, some of this will be legitimate conversation about the roadmap, reassuring operators that there will be no WiMAX-style technology dead-ends and that, if all their mobile data challenges cannot be met in one 3GPP release, there is hope in the future. 3GPP Release 11 was recently completed and the standards body’s radio working groups are now onto Release 12, which ‘ along with Release 13 ‘ is being labelled LTE-B.

All these releases will be complex and made up of many enhancements, which do not have to be deployed all together, or at all ‘ hence each carriers’s LTE-A network may look different, and will evolve gradually in software, with each function added as required by the cellco’s network and business demands. In effect the cellco chooses from a menu of enhancements, which all together would achieve the nirvana of a gigabit, heterogeneous network.

All that puts paid to some of the over-simplified marketing talk that has been bandied around, portraying LTE-A as a simple, one-step upgrade. One of the uncertain elements of the LTE releases for vendors is which of the components will be adopted on mass and which will remain as specialist add-ons for a few carriers.

The hallmarks of LTE-A include carrier aggregation up to 100MHz; eICIC (enhanced inter-cell interference coordination), which allows small cells and macrocells to coexist in the same spectrum; CoMP for interference mitigation; 4×4 MIMO; enhanced self-organizing network (SON) features, and others. In LTE-B, the key new technologies are small cell enhancements, especially for indoor use; new carrier types; 3D MIMO beamforming; machine-type communication; LTE/Wi-Fi integration at radio level and specific public safety requirements, including device-to-device communications. To confuse things further, there are different device categories supporting different levels of downlink and uplink speed within each LTE generation. Cat-1 to Cat-3 are in the market, supporting downlink from 10Mbps to 100Mbps peak, and chipmakers are starting to release Cat-4 modems (up to 150Mbps), as Broadcom did last week. Some are marketing these as LTE-A, but in fact, only Cat-6 (300Mbps) and above count as LTE-Advanced levels.

The companies which could be expected to be actively preparing for LTE-B are the chip providers, which need a leadtime of two years or more to get their designs working with the new standards before these are required in commercial kit or devices. Ubidyne, the pioneer of antenna embedded radio platforms, recently talked about a project it had conducted with NEC to explore the benefits of 3D beamforming, which was done in a proprietary way but will be standardized in Release 12. And Mindspeed, announcing the latest in its Transcede family of small cell processors, pointed out that the system-on-chip was enabled for future support of LTE-B as well as LTE-A.

For most vendors and operators, though, LTE-A itself remains over the horizon, in reality if not in the marketing materials. There are not fully commercial LTE-A networks or devices today. The small handful of operators which have elements of LTE-A active in their networks have done this with equipment commissioned from favorite vendors and created specifically for them ‘ as seen at SK Telecom, which has implemented LTE-A features including carrier aggregation. This is an expensive option reserved for operators that gain significant market advantage by being first to a new technology ‘ mainly those whose user bases are the greediest for mobile data capacity, in Japan or South Korea. And many carriers are attracting attention by claiming LTE-A when they have only actually implemented a single feature, usually carrier aggregation. CA will be the most heavily featured LTE-A element in MWC demonstrations, with chip providers like Mindspeed (on the base station) and Qualcomm (for the device), plus most of the big OEMs, showing off this technique.

Australia’s Telstra, also a habitual frontrunner in new network technologies, is trialling LTE-A with plans to introduce it in areas of high demand in late 2013. Again, it will mainly focus on carrier aggregation (of its 900MHz and 1.8GHz bands) but is also trialling small cell metrozones using some of the LTE-A elements which will ease the way for these systems, including enhanced SON. The carrier is working with long time supplier Ericsson on these urban tests, initially targeting stadiums and other busy locations. Another trial will focus on LTE-Broadcast, where it will be following behind KT of Korea (see separate item). Telstra is seeing traffic grow on its LTE network at a rate of 20% a month, while 3G traffic growth is far slower despite the cellco’s advanced HSPA+ deployment. As of the end of last year, Telstra had sold 1.5m 4G devices in a mobile base of 14m.

The other class of operators which may move early to LTE-A are those which were late to 4G and will try to leapfrog more established rivals by going straight to the more advanced platform. T-Mobile, Clearwire and Dish Network are all promising this approach in the US, for instance, to compensate for launching so far behind Verizon.

But most operators will carry out tests but will wait for fully commercialized, affordable products ‘ and sufficient levels of user demand – before they take the plunge. Of course it is important for vendors to develop those products in advance, to show off their wares and take part in tests, but it would be good to see the mobile industry, for once, refraining from adopting technology leaps as marketing labels, and applying them to offerings that do not merit the label, creating confusion and disappointed expectations.