Korea Telecom is signaling its intent to be one of the first operators in the world to install a countrywide mobile TV service using the eMBMS standard, which has had a rocky ride but enables carriers to deliver broadcast video on their main networks rather than investing in dedicated infrastructure and devices. The carrier said it will demonstrate the technology with supplier Samsung, using new Qualcomm chips, at Mobile World Congress next week.
It has been a long journey for the MBMS standard, and its successor eMBMS – and that’s even if it really does arrive in the commercial market in 2013. If so, it can’t come a moment too soon. Broadcast services over cellular have been present in base station software for about eight years, but in the 3G generation, MBMS (Multimedia Broadcast Multicast Services) did not work out, for a variety of reasons.
However, Korea and Samsung have been in love with this idea for a decade, with broadcast analog TV being put into some Samsung phones 10 years ago. Early attempts like that sparked a decade-long effort to work out how to bring broadcast TV to handsets, and at one stage there were no fewer than 18 different technologies ‘ clearly far too many ‘ chasing that particular pipedream.
Some created a living for their supporters. For instance, US-based chipmaker Telegent sold around 100m chips, for power efficient analog TV in phones, mainly in China. But having
chased an IPO in the US, it finally sold itself quietly to China’s Spreadtrum for an insubstantial amount in the middle of 2011. Its sales had crashed amid aggressive price competition from companies such as MediaTek and RDA Microelectronics, and because analog TV signals were being rapidly turned off around the world.
Meanwhile, users were demanding higher video quality and better battery life. Korea, always a pioneer in such efforts, took the initiative and finally settled on two OFDM-based systems, S-DMB and T-DMB, the first launched in 2005 and owned by TU Media, a unit of KT’s rival South Korea Telecom. It is perhaps this service that KT now intends to target.
South Korea is one of the few countries which has massive penetration of broadcast mobile TV, as opposed to the unicast video services which thrive in the US and Europe. It is well understood that if everyone with a phone watched TV for an hour each day using unicast technology, the cellular networks around the world would saturate instantly, because each unicast TV signal is an additional load on the network. This is the reason that the delivery of TV to mobiles has never become mainstream outside Japan, Korea and China, countries which use broadcast technology, whereas in the US and Europe, no business model has been found that overcomes the initial problems of broadcasting mobile TV. Experiments in DVB-H in some 20 countries, and Qualcomm’s MediaFLO, all stumbled on the issues of having to build a separate network; and add a specialist receiver chip ‘ and perhaps an external antenna – to each device. Operators found they would have to charge for channels which were free on TV sets, in order to make the service pay, and fewer people were then interested. It was a series of chicken and egg stories that led to only Japan, South Korea and China making progress, because in each case these systems were mandated centrally and made little money except for a succession of new radio chip vendors.
Today in Japan, over 80% of phones have 1 seg ISDB-T capability and all TV stations transmit in this format, reaching well over 70m regular users; in Korea with a population of just under 50m, there are well over 25m regular users of two broadcast systems, T-DMB, the dominant terrestrial format, and S-DMB, an earlier satellite system that just about still survives. In China there are perhaps 10m users of its the CMMB system.
Perhaps now is the moment for mobile broadcast TV to find a business case outside these exceptional countries. Battery life issues are now far better understood, and the advantage of (e)MBMS is that it is part and parcel of 3GPP base station software releases, from Release 8 onwards. A wired IP multicast connector channel is attached to each base station from a new specialized video service center, effectively a specialist router to send video to a cluster of BTSs. That Broadcast Multicast Service Center is the only new network element required for broadcast.
One of the neat things referred to by KT is the idea of mixing fixed line multicasts with wireless multicast. If an IP multicast is used as part of the interface between a gate’way and the base stations, it means that a single service can be built across cellular and fixed lines. In fact an existing fixed line multicast can just be diverted to a base station and eMBMS will take care of the rest.
A paper just released last month by Ericsson says that in 20MHz of spectrum, using 10% of capacity for eMBMS, the achievable data rate is around 5Mbps. Most networks will be using substantially more than 10% of capacity for mobile data, and at least 50% of that data will be video. The chances are cellular networks will be able to offer wireless multicast video on as many as 10 TV channels without any increase in data usage. The difference would be that millions of people could get access to TV, and not just a few hundred thousand in any given country who have contract data plans with large data caps.
We suspect there will continue to be some resistance to eMBMS in some countries, because where operators are already getting small monthly payments from a few hundred thousand TV customers, they will want to preserve this, but equally if this means far more people can get TV for a tiny investment, other operators will leap into the market. Potentially there could be partnerships, with pay-TV operators using multicast cellular as a deliver vehicle for TV Everywhere linear program services.
We see eMBMS as a trigger for cellular operators to directly compete with pay-TV operators and also with free-to-air broadcasters, which could make the market change that much bigger. One of the obstacles to broadcast mobile TV services in the past was the fact that cellular operators were not in control of the entire service and were beholden on other players. For instance, in the US the hopes for broadcast mobile TV rest on Dyne, which uses the ATSC Mobile Handheld standard, but this is broadcast alongside digital terrestrial TV transmissions, so is controlled by broadcasters. In DVB-H its frequencies were largely owned by broadcasters around the world. So it wasn’t just that cellular could not come up with a business model, but the wrong types of companies owned the assets as far as cellcos were concerned.
Ericsson’s paper points out that ‘by using MPEG-DASH with eMBMS, the same live encoder and common clients can be used for unicast and broadcast offerings. This solution also supports using the same system proto’col stack for both live streaming and file delivery implementation.’ This means that eMBMS fits nicely with the blind alley route that most cellular operators have gone down, of using unicast-only delivery, something that really pinpoints Wi-Fi as the only viable delivery route.
The joint MWC demonstration will use KT’s mobile IPTV solution, Samsung’s network infrastructure, Qualcomm Labs’ LTE Broadcast Middleware and the Snapdragon S4 MSM8960 processor, which is LTE Broadcast capable. Back in August Samsung said that it was working with testing firm Anritsu to develop LTE Broadcast for its Galaxy S Lightray 4G device.