Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 February 2013

Nvidia makes the crucial leap into handsets with Tegra 4i

Nvidia has played a blinder in PR terms with its move towards integrated LTE device platforms. Rather than promising something it clearly did not have, like some competitors, its CEO managed expectations carefully by warning, in high profile comments, that the firm would not be a big smartphone player until it had an all-in-one chip combining the Tegra processor and the i500 LTE baseband (currently still separate products). Then, just days later, Nvidia produced exactly the solution Jen-Hsun Huang had said it needed for its handset breakthrough, its first all-in-one system-on-chip, the Tegra 4i. Not only that, but it also announced a customer, ZTE, which was ready to give Tegra its big break in smartphones.

This not only threw down the gauntlet to integrated chipset king Qualcomm, but presented the image of a company which could recognize its weaknesses and address them promptly.

As 4G smartphones come close to the mainstream, price pressures are already setting in, making it important for OEMs to be able to source all-in-one chipsets with integrated LTE baseband and application processor. These reduce cost and power, and in 3G have been very much the stronghold of Qualcomm. Jen-Hsun Huang, CEO of Nvidia, admitted on the firm’s recent Q412 earnings call that it would not make a major impression on the smartphone market until it had an integrated SoC. It acquired modem maker Icera for that purpose and expects to offer an all-in-one product later this year, but until then, its mobile sales will remain focused on the tablet, with its more forgiving component real estate and margins.

“This is an area where we will likely need to have an LTE modem in order to be successful and that’s the reason why we work so hard to accelerate our LTE modem to market,” Huang said. ‘We’re working around the clock and with an LTE modem, the Tegra processor and our software capability, we will be able to address a much larger phone opportunity going forward. But we’re not expecting to have a whole lot of phone design wins until we engage the market with LTE.”

He added in a subsequent interview: “The baseband has changed from being a separate part. Nearly all our opportunities have been where LTE not required. When we are in situations where LTE is required, it’s harder for us to compete for that business because competition has had the edge in that.”

Despite these constraints, Tegra processor sales were up 98% year-on-year in the fourth quarter to $208.4m though that sum was down 15% sequentially. Overall, Nvidia reported Q4 net income of $174m, or 28 cents a share, up from $116m, or 19 cents a share, in the same period a year ago. Revenue was up 16% to $1.11bn.

Nvidia will be looking for even greater growth once it has its all-in-one chip. It announced this in the run-up to MWC. The offering is dubbed Tegra 4i and is a high end chip on all fronts, going head-on against Qualcomm’s Snapdragon. The 4i runs on a quad-core CPU with a fifth low power core to save battery life ‘ codeveloped with ARM – plus a 60-core GPU (graphics processing unit). It incorporates the i500 LTE/multimode soft modem, acquired with Icera, which has now been optimized for integration. Nvidia claims the SoC is half the size of the Snapdragon 800, which will reach commercial devices in the same timeframe as the 4i. It also stresses its chip’s advanced photography capabilities.

Nvidia also unveiled a smartphone reference platform called Phoenix to show off the prowess of the new chip and to help partners get Tegra devices to market more quickly and cheaply.

One of the hallmarks of Icera, which Nvidia bought in 2011, was its software defined radio (SDR) technology. This allows the new chip to move seamlessly between LTE and 3G bands, and the soft modem means it can be reconfigured over the air for new frequencies or air interfaces, even after a device has been bought. It is being launched with LTE Cat 3 support (100Mbps peak downlink) but is software upgradeable to Cat 4 with carrier aggregation (150Mbps). This capability is just starting to appear in chips, such as Broadcom’s which are due for commercial devices in early 2014.

“Everyone has always felt SDR would be the holy grail,” Phil Carmack, the head of Nvidia’s mobile business unit, told the Wall Street Journal. Will Strauss of chip analyst firm Forward Concepts commented: ‘Nvidia introduced the Tegra 4 and the i500 LTE modem as separate chips at the recent Consumer Electronics Show, but that was just the preamble to the real story. The stunner is the Tegra 4i application processor and modem on the same die. It took Nvidia only 20 months after the Icera acquisition to field this … Compare that timespan with comparable acquisitions and it’s clear that the marriage has gone well.’

Then, Nvidia followed that breakthrough up with an actual new handset win, even before the Tegra 4i reaches commercial devices. ZTE says it will launch a line of smartphones running on the quad-core Tegra 4 before midyear, with one also including the Nvidia i500 soft modem. It is then expected to adopt Tegra 4i too to help it push into midrange 4G device sectors.

The ZTE win is important for Nvidia. The Chinese firm is hovering around the top three in handset rankings and is sure to be a power player in affordable 4G smartphones, which play to its strengths in emerging markets. It also shows that, despite Huang’s caution, the standalone Tegra 4 can make it into handsets, even though it has mainly succeeded in tablets, as can the i500. ZTE was the first major OEM to introduce both Tegra and Nvidia’s i500 modem into one design and it will now build a whole range on that combination. It already offers the Grand Era U985, based on Tegra 3.

The Tegra 4 runs on the latest ARM Cortex processor, the A15, and supports the big.Little architecture, with a fifth low power core to take on basic tasks and extend battery life. The chip also has 72 graphics cores, six times as many as its predecessor.

However, Qualcomm’s president and COO Steve Mollenkopf refused to be fazed by Nvidia’s progress. Speaking at a recent Goldman Sachs technology conference, he said: “If you look at the landscape of LTE, we’re on our third generation. Most people are trying to figure out how to produce a device that would compete with our first generation.” He boasted of his firm’s lead in integrated platforms, adding: “Most people that bet against integration in this business are not in this business any more’, a clear reference to firms like Texas Instruments and Freescale, which have been progressively exiting the handset space.

Qualcomm itself has added two new processors to its Snapdragon range, targeting entry level and midrange smartphones. The Snapdragon 200 and 400, which will appear in commercial products later this year, join the high end 600 and 800 models, unveiled in January.

The 200 is the entry level product, though it still features four cores, indicating how mainstream that technology has become. Only a year ago Qualcomm remained cautious about quad-core in handsets, arguing that it was more important to optimize dual-core platforms for greater performance and power efficiency first. However, it went the quad-core route later in the year with the new Snapdragon line-up and is now extending the technology downwards.

The 200 has four ARM Cortex A5 cores running at up to 1.4GHz each, an Adreno 203 GPU, and support for HD video playback, dual SIM cards, and up to 8-megapixels in the camera. The midrange 400 comes in two flavors ‘ one with two cores of up to 1.7GHz each and one with four cores of up to 1.4GHz. The 400 also includes the Adreno 305 GPU and 1080p HD video playback and capture and supports Miracast and up to 13.5-megapixel cameras. Both promise better battery life than their predecessors and integration with Qualcomm’s modems.

Qualcomm also saw the Snapdragon 600 appearing in two new handsets this week, the HTC One and the LG Optimus G Pro.