Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 March 2013

Operators look more credible in bid to seize initiative from Google

Mobile World Congress is a heavily operator-driven event and one of its functions is to give major cellcos a platform to set out their demands from their supply ecosystem. This carrier focus often creates a certain level of antagonism, as operators air their resentment at the way their product ‘partners’ seek to lock them in or control them. Back when MWC was still the ‘3GSM’ show, carriers were inclined to blame device and equipment makers for the early failings of 3G, and their enthusiasm for mix-and-match small cell networks shows that they are still chafing against the way large OEMs set the network agenda.

But in recent years, their hostility has been diverted to the Apple/Google duopoly, and the way those giants are setting the agenda for the mobile web experience, at the same time as creating a platform for over-the-top brands which sideline the operator. In successive years, the cellco community has sought ways to assert its own power and brand experience against the web majors. Most of these have been damp squibs, merely reminding us that operators are good at minutes not megabytes, at tuning networks not delivering applications. There have been attempts to create a carrier-moulded operating system (SavaJe, LiMO), or to move up a layer and build a common development platform to lure programmers from Android and iOS (WAC, JIL).

None of these has changed the balance of power significantly, but cumulatively they have focused carriers’ minds on what they really do well, and how to build on that in applications and services. And with Apple absent and Google taking a low key role this year, it was perhaps too easy to believe the operators were making real progress.