Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 March 2013

As HTML5 platforms gain power, carriers can’t resist the lure of their own OS

Operators may sensibly have pulled back from the OS and focused their attention on APIs, but they retain a desire to control a full operating system platform. Their latest chance to do this comes from the wave of new mobile OSs appearing this year, all of them looking a generation beyond Android and iOS to a world of streaming and cloud services, rather than native apps and downloads. The likes of Mozilla, Canonical and Jolla are responding to emerging changes in user behavior, but the carriers see the chance to throw their weight behind fledgling challengers to iOS and Android, and therefore hope to reduce the power of Apple and Google.

Microsoft and BlackBerry, of course, are also courting carriers with the lure of being a possible ‘third way’ in mobile OSs. However, the new breed of platforms have advantages over those two elderly players ‘ they are pushing ahead to a new and growing market, not trying to chip in on one where the leaders are well entrenched; they are mainly start-ups or open source organizations, so may prove more malleable in the cellcos’ hands than giants like Microsoft; and they are developing browser-based systems that are well suited to lower end devices, and to the emerging economies where cellcos not only see high growth ahead, but where they also retain greater power over the consumer than in the developed mobile markets.

Operator enthusiasm for Mozilla’s Firefox Mobile and other new offerings was unsurprising then, and is helping to attract support of handset makers and developers for these new platforms ‘ it would be tough to get companies like ZTE to promise smartphones for an unproven OS without carrier support. And because MWC’s agenda is so driven by the cellcos, the new platforms had a great opportunity to bask in the sun in Barcelona. It remains to be seen whether any of these HTML5-oriented platforms ‘ Mozilla Firefox Mobile, Tizen, Ubuntu Mobile, Jolla Sailfish, Alibaba Aliyun, Baidu Cloud OS or even a rejuvenated LG webOS ‘ survive, or whether they will be eclipsed by the next moves from Apple, Google and Microsoft. But they will certainly force those giants to respond and the certainly created chatter at MWC.

Tizen, the open source OS backed by Intel and Samsung, made a splash with its official coming-out. Release 2.0 sourcecode and software developers kit were announced, boasting an enhanced web framework with many of the latest W3C/HTML5 APIs supported. Although Tizen is known for its focus on HTML5 it now has a native framework with support for background applications, IP push and text-to-speech. Also added were a Web UI framework with full screen and multi-window support, and extra APIs for Bluetooth and NFC devices plus access to calendars, call history and messaging.

Samsung, along with Intel the main backer of Tizen, has promised devices for the OS this year. But the platform won new supporters at MWC too, with Orange committing to launching handsets running the OS later this year. As well as Tizen’s main backers, Samsung and Intel, Huawei and Sprint are among others in its consortium. Development partners are starting to come on board too, among them Appcelerator, which plans to add Tizen support to its mobile development platform by the end of this month, along with a common application store for all Tizen-based devices by May. The company will also collaborate with the Tizen Association to offer incentives to developers who move the first 500 apps to the OS.

There was also considerable conversation about Ubuntu, which does not categorize its forthcoming smartphone version as a ‘mobile OS’ but is part of the most ambitious attempt yet to create a fully unified platform spanning mobile, PCs and other screens. In the run-up to MWC, Canonical unveiled a developer preview and a tablet iteration, just six weeks after it had announced it was planning a platform to take Ubuntu beyond the PC. Available initially ‘ and ironically ‘ on Google Nexus devices, the preview SDK includes a range of templates to help build native applications quickly, using Qt Meta Language on top of HTML5 and OpenGL. The full OS, due in October, will target entry level smartphones, like rival Linux platforms such as Mozilla’s, and Canonical claimed a deal with ‘a very large supplier of silicon to the mobile industry which will be optimizing Ubuntu on their chips’.

The organization says it has a vision of a single Ubuntu platform to ‘deliver a mobile, tablet, desktop or TV experience depending on the device it is installed on, or where it is docked.’ “Developers will not need to cross-compile or package applications differently for phone, tablet, PC and TV. One platform serves all four, a single application binary can do the same,’ said the launch statements. Likewise, the new tablet interface is the “next step towards one unified family of experiences for personal computing on phones, tablets, PCs and TVs’, the group said.

However, it was Mozilla that made the highest impact in Barcelona with a pre-show event on Sunday, where it demonstrated its Firefox Mobile OS and announced a list of 18 cellcos which have pledged to support it. Some of these had previously announced their backing for a system which operators hope will allow them to seize back some control from Apple and Google, while others were new recruits.

They include Mozilla’s flagship partner, Telefonica, and its arch-rival in the Latin American region, America Movil. The support of these two heavyweights will ensure that Brazil and other LatAm countries gain Mozilla handsets this year. The first countries to see the devices will be Brazil, Colombia, Mexico, and Venezuela, said the browser organization, as well as Hungary, Montenegro, Poland, Serbia and Spain.

The other operators are Deutsche Telekom, Sprint, Telstra, China Unicom, Etisalat, Hutchison 3, KDDI, KT, MegaFon, Qtel, SingTel, Smart, Telecom Italia, Telenor, TMN and VimpelCom. And AT&T left the door open too, when CEO Ralph de la Vega said in an interview that ‘there was room for more operating systems. If customers demand a Firefox device in future, AT&T would provide it, he told CNet, adding: “It’s certainly attractive, but it’s a little early on for us to be commenting on that.’

Although Mozilla promised a tablet version soon, it has not gone after cutting edge devices, but is instead focusing primarily on the areas where Apple is less powerful ‘ emerging markets, entry level smartphones, and operator branded gadgets. Hence the enthusiasm from the carrier community, which sees the chance to enhance the visibility of their brand and user experience, over that of OEMs or platform suppliers, in markets where the Android/iOS duopoly is not yet entrenched (and where the highest future smartphone growth is centered).

Mozilla CEO Gary Kovacs said at the launch event that the mobile world was being ‘unnaturally controlled by a few parties’ but an HTML5 device would ″enable everyone around the world to participate in mobile ‘ the web itself is the ultimate leveller of the playing field.″

It is not just cellcos aiming to gain power from supporting Firefox Mobile. Qualcomm is making a habit of establishing first stage monopolies in new OSs by working intimately with their authors ‘ it is the only major provider of Windows Phone processors, and for now is the exclusive provider of chips for Firefox phones (and may well also be the silicon giant promised by Canonical). ″It’s going to provide a lot of flexibility for the operators,″ said Qualcomm CEO Paul Jacobs. ‘This is going to provide a very, very large ecosystem.″

Mozilla also hopes to shake up the device sector, which is increasingly in the hands of Apple and Samsung. Carriers are keen to offset the power of those companies and so increase their own ability to influence OEMs’ directions and pricing. Many of the early devices will be carrier-branded and made by tier two vendors, which Telefonica CEO Cesar Alierta said would ″change the prevailing value chain in the digital world’. He said: ″Firefox operating system is the answer. Duopolies are not beneficial for any industry.″ It was not clear whether he was referring to the Apple/Samsung or the iOS/Android duopoly, but either way, launch plans by these major carriers are far greater than toes in the water to make Apple nervous. They represent real opportunities for smaller vendors. T-Mobile will launch Firefox handsets in Poland first, and then in other eastern European markets, while American Movil aims to launch them in all its Latin American markets, marketing, as CMO Marco Quatorze put it, ″the beginning of the end of the walled gardens’.

Though Samsung may have said it was not interested in Firefox (having enough OSs to be going on with, and likely to merge its own bada into Tizen), Mozilla’s platform will not be only the preserve of tier two players. LG, Huawei and ZTE have both pledged support, no doubt looking, like the cellcos, for a platform which supports next generation services and over which they can have more influence than Android, giving them hope of differentiation.

Chinese support is critical to new platforms, because of the size of the smartphone market and the fact that its newness means Google and Apple are not entrenched in the way they are in the west. Jolla’s Sailfish is being taken seriously because it has strong Chinese partnerships, and Mozilla has attracted three handset OEMs from the country (the third being Alcatel One Touch). Its quartet of phonemakers will all launch devices this year and ZTE actually launched its first model at MWC. The ZTE Open will come to Telefonica’s units in Spain, Venezuela and Colombia in mid-2013. It is an entry level smartphone with a 3.5-inch, HVGA TFT touchscreen display, Wi-Fi and 3.2M-megapixel camera.

Of course, China also has its own mobile web platforms, such as Baidu Cloud OS and Alibaba Aliyun. China Mobile recently called for homegrown OSs to be prioritized over Android ‘ despite its huge support for that platform, albeit with its own, largely de-Google overlay and store. And last week, a white paper published by the country’s Ministry of Industry claimed China was becoming ‘too dependent’ on Android, arguing that, although the OS is open source, Google strictly controls the core technology and the roadmap. It goes further, and accuses Google of discriminating against Chinese developers. It claims this is done by staggering the sharing of code, so that favored partners get first access ‘ an accusation made on a wider scale during the mishandled release of the first tablet-optimized Android version, Honeycomb. This was initially available only to vendors which Google judged able to deliver a high quality of experience.

The report also alleges that Google uses commercial agreements to thwart Chinese companies’ attempts at mobile device development. Although it does not recommend any official action, such claims will raise the specter of more formal government probes in future, at a time when the search giant is under intense scrutiny by many antitrust agencies, and recently made a deal with the European Union.

Android is said to run on about 90% of Chinese smartphones, despite major efforts by Apple and Microsoft to boost their own platforms, and the emergence of local operating systems. Some of these take Android as a starting point and others are centered on HTML5 browsers. Google incurred anger in China last year when it appeared to pressurize Acer not to launch a promised Aliyun handset, claiming this broke the terms of the Taiwanese vendor’s contract with Android’s industry body, the Open Handset Alliance.

Duncan Clark, chairman of technology consultancy BDA, told Reuters that the white paper suggests that Chinese authorities might regulate the use of Android in future in order to make the ecosystem more friendly to local players, though it will have to be careful not to restrict vendors’ usage of the OS, which has powered the rapid growth of Chinese smartphone makers like Huawei and ZTE.

This is a highly political debate which will not be quickly resolved, but it highlights the opportunities that the world’s largest smartphone market offers to platforms which want to offer an alternative to the big two, and which know they can get the major carriers on-board to help.

Indeed, Marc Dillon, CEO of Jolla, may get the last word. He told MWC that the mobile industry was in ‘what may be the last step in the golden age of ecosystems ‘ what is happening now is that everybody is getting squeezed’. While operators are faced with becoming bitpipes, OEMs are also squeezed. He said: ‘When I got off the airplane here in Barcelona, the first thing I saw was a billboard from a very large company which said ‘we have reinvented mobile’. And it has exactly the same Android as everyone else.’ By contrast, he argued, the various new OSs can be very different, yet do not have to go through the pain of creating their own ecosystem, as developers can tap into all of them using HTML5. Jolla, Mozilla and Canonical executives took the stage together in Barcelona to tout their common aims and Dillon said: ‘If we are in competition, then we’ve all already won, because it’s about creating diversity from the existing walled garden and the existing couple of ecosystems’ Diversity is the thing that creates innovation.’ For the carriers seeking to be puppet masters in the HTML5 play, diversity is appealing for another reason ‘ no more duopolies, and a market in which they hope they can play divide and rule.