The long saga of Sharp’s future ownership drags on, but is interesting for the industry at large because of the power players which may be involved in its bail-out and the vital importance, for smartphone and tablet makers, of controlling advanced display technology.
Qualcomm has already taken a stake, and other rumored participants have included Intel, Apple and Dell ‘ all companies which need the kind of cutting edge touchscreen technology Sharp develops. Now Samsung has taken a holding in its display rival, raising the interesting prospect of the two biggest handset makers both holding stakes in the same screen vendor.
Apple has supported Sharp in various ways, reported to include financial injections and guaranteed orders, as it seeks to foster a counterweight to Samsung in its supply chain for RetinaDisplay. Having such a key competitive technology manufactured by its smartphone nemesis increasingly sits uneasily with the iPhone maker, and with Sharp, it can have far greater influence on R&D and manufacturing directions.
The latest twist in the story may, then, displease Apple, since Bloomberg reports that Samsung itself now wants a stake in its Japanese display rival. Apparently, the Korean giant is in talks to invest about ’10bn ($107m) in Sharp, and sources said a deal could be announced as early as this week.
Sharp has been struggling for two years amid rising competition and a slump in its TV business, reporting a 16% year-on-year drop in sales in the six months to September 30 2012, and forecasting a record loss for its fiscal year to the end of March.
But it still has considerable advantages in display technology, including its pioneering IGZO platform. This attracted an investment of up to $120m from Qualcomm in December 2012, which provided welcome relief after an earlier deal with Hon Hai/Foxconn had fallen through because of the plummeting value of Sharp. The Qualcomm alliance includes an 18-month pact to ‘develop and commercialize high quality color, low power MEMS displays incorporating IGZO’, advancing Qualcomm’s long standing interest in MEMS screens. Sharp has pioneered IGZO (Indium Gallium Zinc Oxide) technology, which supports very slim displays using existing LCD manufacturing processes.
This may also have caught Samsung’s eye as it races to maintain its leadership in touchscreens, and particularly its dominance of the AMOLED sector. Like Qualcomm’s $120m, its own $107m would be a drop in the ocean of cash needed to turn Sharp around, but it will increase confidence, as well as creating some interesting dynamics in the increasingly competitive world of touchscreen displays.
Samsung has paid ‘10.4bn ($112m) for a 3% stake in Sharp but this is not just a financial injection, but like Qualcomm’s investment last year, comes with a technology collaboration deal. Samsung will bolster certain LCD display lines, which will ensure that the Japanese firm can continue to supply these screens to its customers ‘ last year it warned of ‘material danger’ of going out of business as its finances faltered. That would have been a huge blow to mobile device makers, which have regularly suffered from shortages of screens in the past two years. Although Chinese and Taiwanese manufacturers are rising in importance, encouraged by Apple and others, the market for really cutting edge displays is heavily concentrated in the hands of Samsung and LG, both of whom tend to give their own handset sister companies priority access, and Sharp.
While Samsung and its new partner compete in some segments, it is in the Korean firm’s interest to safeguard the future of certain screen sizes in which Sharp specializes. Samsung’s competitive edge comes from its power in AMOLED screens, but as a group, it buys many TV and mobile displays from third parties, including Sharp, too. It will look to secure its source, and counterbalance Apple’s influence on how the Japanese firm allocates its resources.
Analysts at DisplaySearch believe Samsung’s main agenda is to secure supplies from Sharp of three large panel sizes plus high resolution mobile displays using CGS (the elderly continuous grain silicon technology pioneered by Sharp) and oxide TFT, in which Sharp is a leader. Samsung may use oxide TFT backplanes from its new friend for its AMOLED TV, and the Korean firm is reported to want to reduce its own investment in making TFT LCDs, to focus resources on AMOLED.
They wrote in a research note: ‘Samsung and Sharp have long been rivals, but Sharp has apparently determined that forming an alliance with its rival in flat-screen TVs and mobile phone handsets is required to improve its performance and financial standing. Samsung’s purpose is mainly to secure TV panels … Due to the reduced orders for displays for Apple’s iPad, Sharp has been shifting Gen 8 capacity, which was originally making 9.7-inch tablet PC panels, to produce 32-inch LCD TV panels for Samsung. In total, Samsung will be buying more than one million panels from Sharp, so it may make sense for Samsung to invest to secure the source.’
The Samsung cash, according to Sharp’s statements, will allow it to introduce “new technology for LCDs with high definition features” while rationalizing manufacturing facilities for tablet and notebook HD LCD screens. These changes will be executed over the next two years, addressing the upheaval which the decline of the conventional PC, and the rise of the tablet, have inflicted on LCD manufacturers.
According to Ricky Park, an analyst at IHS iSuppli, tablet screen competition has driven prices down sharply, to between 50 cents and $1 a unit, even as inventories for notebook screens mount up, and demand for large TV LCD displays remains stagnant.
Although Sharp is not out of the woods yet, it is demonstrating greater control over its own destiny than it was a year ago. For instance, with support from Qualcomm, Samsung and possibly Intel and Apple, it will have less need of a deal with Foxconn/Hon Hai. The Taiwanese manufacturer had intended to purchase a stake in Sharp to gain guaranteed access to mobile displays, for the iDevices among other products, via a co-managed facility. But the financial deal fell through, and now Sharp may be wary of handing more power to Foxconn, bolstered by its other backers. ‘Sharp’s strategy is to balance multiple investors rather than rely on one. Foxconn might not be happy with this because of its poor business relationship with Samsung,’ wrote DisplaySearch analysts, though they also speculate that, with Foxconn’s Apple business apparently being squeezed, it may seek an ODM relationship with Samsung as well. ‘Sharp is becoming a big ship, with investments from many companies. All of these investors will see different benefits and conflicts in this big Sharp ship.’
In another move to consolidate its touchscreen technology base, Samsung signed a multiyear licensing deal with Immersion, pioneer of haptics technology to provide feedback when a display is touched.
The vendor already uses Immersion haptics in various products, including the Galaxy S3 and Galaxy Note, but a previous, more limited licensing deal had expired. The new arrangement covers Immersion’s Integrator product, which claims to “fundamentally change how a user experiences haptics’ with ambient tactile feedback that sits in the background and and is optimized for multimedia environments such as gaming and video. Integrator works in conjunction with Immersion’s TouchSense, also included in the licence along with simpler haptics offerings. Immersion raised its 2013 revenue projections because of the deal, indicating the power Samsung now wields over the whole display supply chain.
Last year, Immersion settled a patent infringement dispute with Google and Motorola Mobility, and signed a licensing agreement plus compensation for prior shipments using some of Immersion’s technology.
Samsung has made a series of acquisitions in recent years to strengthen its hand in touch-based user experience. Most recently, it took a 5% stake in intelligent stylus maker Wacom. One of its most significant deals was to acquire Dutch ereader inventor Liquavista in early 2011. The smaller firm,
a spin-off from Philips, uses ‘electrowetting’ technology for displays for ereaders, handsets and other mobile gadgets. Its system is distinguished by its low power consumption, about 10% of usual displays even with bright color, according to Samsung; and by its ability to operate in different modes (transmissive, reflective, transparent and transflective).