Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 March 2013

Is Apple reaching saturation point?

The unusual climate of caution that has been building around Apple since late last year continues to hang over the vendor. The latest blow was struck this week by three Citigroup analysts, who said they think demand for iPhones and iPads was ‘softening’.

This, of course, would be disastrous for Apple, since the iDevices are its main profit engine and the handset is its single biggest product. Despite complaints that the company has not come up with many new ideas in recent upgrades, the smartphones have continued to sell well. However, Glen Yeung, Jim Suva and Walter Pritchard have cut their forecasts for the second quarter, speculating that Apple may be reaching saturation point.

In a client note, they cited indications of reduced demand for components, and said that supported “existing concerns that end demand for [full sized] iPad and iPhone 5 in particular is softening’. The note says: “In conducting our regular field work with the hardware supply chain, we again find evidence of reduced demand to Apple’s suppliers for iPhone 5 related components.’

For the current quarter, Citi now estimates that Apple will sell 34m iPhones, down from its previous forecast of 35m, and for the June quarter, its prediction is down more sharply, from 32m to 25m. Things are worse for the iPad, where the analysts says sales of the full sized model are in decline in the US and Japan – by more than 10% year-on-year in the last quarter of 2012.

One factor for the tablet is potential saturation of a segment that is confined to relatively high income users ‘ hence the launch of the smaller iPad – and where owners do not upgrade their devices on a 12-18 month cycle.

Another factor is Apple’s increasingly problematic launch cycle. With a new iPad expected in early summer, sales tend to fall off in the months beforehand. This process affects any high level device, but is exaggerated for Apple because it launches only one new model per product line each year, and because of the intensity of media speculation which rages for months before any likely upgrade.

However, there are also hints that the iPhone base may be getting somewhat less excited about new models. Numerous analysts suggest iPhone 5 sales have been lower than those of its predecessors, despite the addition of LTE, because there are far more high end choices, notably the Galaxy family, and apathy may be spreading even to the installed Apple base.

Apple is expected to launch the next iPhone in August, and new iPads could be unveiled in April. Citigroup is looking for the tablet range to diversify further, with a new full-sized model plus both RetinaDisplay and non-Retina versions of the iPad mini. However, they are not convinced by talk of a low end iPhone this year. “Despite much speculation amongst investors and third party research, we find limited evidence of a low end iPhone at this stage,” the analysts said. “We anticipate a large-screen iPhone in late 2013/early 2014. But clear indications of a low end iPhone remain elusive.”

Also struggling to return to past handset glories is HTC, HTC continues to struggle for turnaround

HTC made a high impact with the launch of its new HTC One superphone, but it continues to struggle against falling revenues and market share.

For February, the Taiwanese company reported unaudited revenue down almost 44% year-on-year to TWD11.37bn ($383.9m), the sixteenth consecutive month in which sales have fallen compared to the year-ago period.

The firm has said it expects revenue for the whole of the first quarter to come in between TWD50bn and TWD60bn, which would require a strong uptick in March, considering the combined figure for January and February is TWD26.9bn ($908m), down from $1.25bn for the first two months of 2012.

That puts heavy pressure on the new HTC One to have a massive first few weeks. It will ship in a wide range of markets this month and is ‘ like BlackBerry’s Z10 ‘ generally seen as a make-or-break offering. HTC has said it is expecting a ‘material increase in revenue’ as a result of the launch, but the timescales are very short to see some of that increase turning into a much-needed boost for the first quarter.

At the end of 2012, HTC had 4.6% market share, down from 10.3% a year earlier, according to figures from IDC, which believes the Taiwanese firm shipped 32.6m smartphones in 2012.