The hype about small cells had reached such a peak at this year’s Mobile World Congress that it was almost impossible to find a vendor which had not managed to give the label to their hardware or software product. This was possible because of some rather vague definitions of what exactly a small cell is ‘ blurred lines which most operators were keen to clarify. In fact, the serious discussions about the new way to design 3G and 4G RANs focused on two main approaches ‘ the genuine small cell deployment, involving a dense zone of self-contained metrocells, potentially in their own layer of spectrum; and the distributed RAN, somewhere on the continuum from conventional remote radio units (RRUs) to fully fledge Cloud-RAN. This might indeed involve very low-footprint equipment at the cell site, but is not necessarily supporting small cells in terms of range and coverage.
While there was plenty of deliberate or inadvertent confusion of these two types of new-look RAN, both are genuinely vital to the plans of most carriers ‘ a few in the immediate term, but most in the 3-5 year timeline, as mobile data demands really start to overtake their ability to squeeze more capacity out of an existing network in the time honoured ways (adding new sectors; reducing cell size to microcell levels; upgrading to HSPA+; introducing dual carriers; and of course imposing more stringent caps on users). Most carriers, outside the US, Japan, Korea and China (and primarily the CDMA or TD-SCDMA communities), are still at the stage of extracting more out of HSPA using those methods, while adding LTE to boost urban (and sometimes rural) broadband, plus tinkering with offload to Wi-Fi or femtocells.
But that does not mean that these giants of EMEA, Latin America and parts of Asia are not making intricate plans already to move to the new approaches to network planning, even if actual mass roll-outs may wait until 2015 or perhaps far later. Small cells were undeniably the theme of the show, and behind the marketing labels the debate had already moved on from last year’s focus on cost, backhaul and standards, to look at the nitty-gritty of deployment, including optimizing back office systems and self-optimizing networks to get the most out of a small cell strategy; as well as creating new types of services enabled by these localized base stations; and when to move to C-RAN.
Most carriers will, in time, use both the main techniques under discussion in parts of their network, though most will stop short of the almost religious conversion to C-RAN seen at China Mobile and Docomo. However, the fact that these two major strategies ‘ metrocells and distributed RAN ‘ can be complementary does not mean they should be lumped together under the ‘small cell’ label as happened frequently in Barcelona.
All the major vendors were touting small cells, but were in reality supporting them in different measure. There are the small cell specialists, aiming to compensate for the lack of presence in 3G RANs by infiltrating a large carrier via the back door of a metrozone, perhaps picking up a big vendor alliance in the process. These include the small cell pioneers which have come up from the indoor femtocell space, such as Ubiquisys and ip.access; the escapees from WiMAX, like Airspan; and the carrier Wi-Fi players, notably Ruckus. Also very visible was Spidercloud, which specializes in a small cell Enterprise-RAN. The biggest player in this category is NEC, which espouses an LTE strategy entirely based on small cells and is seeking to get back into the carrier RAN mainstream by that path.
Then there are the major OEMs which have put their full weight behind both the new architectures ‘ usually because they are losing ground to Ericsson and Huawei in traditionally configured 3G and 4G RANs and see a chance to outmanoeuvre those giants in metrocell and distributed networks. Alcatel-Lucent with the ever-disruptive lightRadio and Nokia Siemens with Liquid Network are the prominent examples. Both have been tightly associated with the small cell revolution yet their platforms are arguably more powerful in pushing the limits of the macrocell and microcell, via distributed or cloud processing and flexible ‘SingleRAN’ architectures that support multiple air interfaces and frequency bands. LightRadio may have been ahead of its time in practical implementation terms, but its appearance at MWC two years ago was a catalyst for intense interest in fully fledged metrocell networks for public access ‘ yet it is first and foremost a distributed RAN platform, which can support cells of all sizes, virtualizing the baseband processing and leaving just a stripped-down cube, containing antenna and radio, at the cell site.
ALU has added metrocell and Wi-Fi support to lightRadio, but the confusion between the two new network approaches really dates to the way its iconic platform was initially perceived (and misunderstood). The same goes for Nokia Siemens, whose Liquid Radio fell into a similar distributed RAN category to ALU’s when it made its debut ‘ it was later that the vendor added true small cell offerings such as FlexiZone (which combines Wi-Fi and cellular metrocells, managed from the same core).
This year, even Ericsson publicly pronounced that the small cell was ready for the real world. It has, officially at least, resisted the metrocell fiercely because of its impact on the vendor’s margins, IPR position and level of control over its customers (though it is doing a good job of arguing that the open system network with commoditized base stations will not work, and end-to-end systems will still be necessary). In reality, Ericsson’s conversion is halfhearted and its actual base station focus was mainly on its AIR upgrades (see Wireless Watch February 14 2013). AIR is an antenna integrated radio for distributed and Cloud RANs, which can help make a macro network more efficient, allocating resources flexibly where they are needed and reducing power and cost at the site ‘ but does not necessarily lead to small cell adoption.
Huawei takes a similar line, and Samsung went further. Having had, in the past, a heavy focus on small cells, this year its rapidly growing infrastructure division said that, in fact, metrocells were not its main interest as yet, and it was primarily concerned with enhancing the macro network. Its Smart LTE platform has supported advanced Cloud-RAN deployment at SK Telecom, and other flagship clients include Sprint, 3 Group and, with a greater small cell focus, KDDI.
The two Chinese majors are hedging their bets between metrocell and Cloud-RAN, but have particular insights into the latter because of projects with the architecture’s chief exponent, China Mobile. The RRU is widely implemented in almost all new 3G/4G roll-outs, but it is evolving rapidly to support bigger and bigger virtualized networks and higher performance.
At MWC, Huawei showed off an RRU system which supported the world’s first four-carrier aggregation for TD-LTE, looking ahead to the convergence of the two LTE flavors at the Advanced stage. The demonstration used 4×4 MIMO antenna arrays and delivered 1Gbps peak speeds with a single RRU. The company said this was a new wideband network benchmark, ‘allowing a single user to enjoy higher data speeds on an LTE TDD network than previously possible’.
The 4-CA solution for TDD is a part of the company’s GigaSite portfolio, based on using a series of Ultraband RRUs which support 80MHz channels and can expand to four carriers with only software upgrades, to achieve the gigabit speed. Huawei has launched a similar series of Wideband RRUs for China Mobile’s TD-SCDMA 3G network. Later this year, it will launch the chipsets to enable end-to-end carrier aggregation on TD-LTE.
Over at ZTE, the vendor launched the Magic range of RRUs, based on its software defined radio base station technology, claiming smaller size, lower power consumption, plus multimode and multi-sector performance.
The Magic series includes 3 RRU modules. At the bottom is the 80W model, which is 58% smaller than the average RRU, says ZTE, at 9.9 liters in volume and 12 kilograms in weight. It can be installed in five minutes, said the supplier. The top end offering is 2x60W and 12 liters in volume, and boasts the highest power output in the industry, supporting large capacity, wide coverage, and the coexistence of multiple radio modes. A single RRU can provide enough bandwidth coverage for highly integrated 2G/3G/LTE multimode networks.
ZTE also unveiled its LTE cloud radio, which promises dynamic coordination to improve user experience at the cell edge.
Of course, given the rise of Wi-Fi and, more generally, end-to-end IP in the cellco network, Cisco is on everyone’s mind, and just before MWC, it had launched its first public access RAN offering (except its flirtation with WiMAX when it acquired Navini), in the shape of its first 3G small cell, together with its Quantum network management tools. Its power in so many aspects of the carrier network ‘ the packet core, routers and outdoor Wi-Fi ‘ make Cisco a terrifying prospect for already pressurized RAN suppliers, and most of them were, to some extent, responding to the California company’s threat. Ericsson bought BelAir last year, of course, while one of NSN’s pre-MWC launches hit right at Cisco’s territory, with Smart Wi-Fi.
This is the latest addition to the FlexiZone architecture for mixed Wi-Fi and 3GPP small cells, eventually leading to a fully integrated HetNet. Smart Wi-Fi consists of four elements to help carriers manage their various access points as a single pool of capacity. “Nearly all smartphones and tablets have the ability to use Wi-Fi. Operators have a clear opportunity to use this mature, cost effective technology to enhance the experience of mobile broadband, especially in underserved indoor public areas”, said Randy Cox, head of small cell product management at NSN.
The four elements of the new platform are Smart Wi-Fi Connect, Converge, Optimize and Personalize. Smart Wi-Fi Connect provides access points and gateways for operators to plan and deploy their own WLans, as well as tools to analyze, plan, deploy, integrate and optimize the operator’s own or a partner’s Wi-Fi networks.
Smart Wi-Fi Converge allows Wi-Fi to be integrated into the existing packet core and suppots device provisioning and subscriber authentication for seamless subscriber access to Wi-Fi. There are also features to manage security, billing and policy control and to deliver cellular services over Wi-Fi.
The third component, Optimize, introduces traffic steering capabilities based on Wi-Fi traffic loading. Operators are able to decide when to switch subscribers between Wi-Fi and cellular depending on traffic levels, helping to make QoS more predictable.
Finally, Personalize includes the recently introduced Customer Experience Management on Demand for Wi-Fi. This gives cellcos subscriber level visibility and allows them to target subscriber segments to provide promotional Wi-Fi sign-up campaigns and/or automatic Wi-Fi provisioning.
Over at Cisco, the company was also launching tools for managing combined mobile and Wi-Fi networks, and announced Vodafone’s Dutch unit as a first public customer for the new Quantum platform. This range includes the Quantum Network Abstraction Suite, which creates a real time network abstraction layer for network data collection, aggregation and orchestration to support network decision processes.
Other tools include the Quantum Policy Suite to enforce application-centric policy capabilities on any kind of network; the Quantum Analytics Suite with business and network capabilities; and the Quantum WAN Orchestration Suite of network management tools to support capacity and traffic management, particularly in IP/MPLS environments.
Cisco also, as promised by CEO John Chambers last fall, introduced its first cellular base station. While the firm has no intentions of taking on Ericsson in macrocells, it sees small cells as a logical extension of its Wi-Fi infrastructure business and its major femtocell contract with AT&T, which it supplies via a deal with ip.access. The new 3G Small Cell Module is compatible with Cisco’s Aironet Wi-Fi family and integrates licensed and unlicensed small cells with a plug-in 3G radio. It is targeted at enterprise deployments and can be supported by the ASR 901S small cell router, which is deployable on an outdoor pole. This product is being used for backhaul by Softbank, WiLine Networks and South Africa’s Telkom.
This sees Cisco starting cautiously, in its Wi-Fi and enterprise comfort zones, but still ticking another box on the cellco’s shopping list. Until recently, Cisco may have been content to concentrate on its strengths in the core, assuming this would be the source of power over the operator, and that the access points themselves would become commoditized. But now it needs to keep an eye on the edge too. Some carriers are looking to distribute significantly more intelligence and processing power to the edge ‘ as seen in Nokia Siemens’ Liquid Applications launch, for instance, or Samsung’s Smart LTE platform, where servers and network functions are combined to support functions like content delivery close to the user. In this situation, offering cellular as well as Wi-Fi base stations becomes important so that Cisco can push the line it has successfully proffered in the enterprise network ‘ that it can support intelligence anywhere on the network, and from end to end, creating a truly flexible resource. The phrase that Sun coined three decade ago, ‘the network is the computer’, has finally come to mobile telecoms. Even more than migration to all-IP, this is the golden opportunity for Cisco to muscle in on Ericsson’s turf, without ever having to throw a macrocell in anger.